Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Unintentional thin wall bowl

Posts

Unintentional thin wall bowl

#1

Unintentional thin wall bowl

Ed Kelle

>This actually was roughed out to be a thick walled bowl which I wanted to put an outward textured rim on like I have done before. I left it aprox 1" thick with this in mind and did the DNA soak that I have been using the past few months. When I remounted it, it suddenly became obvious that this had warped quite a bit and by the time I was cleaning up the inside, I knew these just would not be enough wood to do any kind of texturing. It was under 1/2 inch at the time for for a 10" bowl this seemed way to thin for the thick textured rim that I wanted. So I decided just to work on my technique a bit and got it down to about 1/4" just about the whole was down. yea this was a big step for me, I have progressed from the big clunkers I have turned out in the past. Done mostly with my Ellsworth gouge which I love. Only a very small amount of scraping. But quite a lot of hand sanding, due to the fact that I have some play in my lathe which leaves low spots at 180° to each other. But it is an issue I just have to work around for the time being. At least I have gotten better with my techique and have not had as much tearout on the endgrain, so that sanding was not necessary to clean this up. Still sanding by hand until I get some pads for my Milwaukee, put in about 2 hours sanding on this one working my way up to 600 followed by some finer hand sanding pads. So far it has one coat of oil on the cherry. Lots of nice reds and greens going on in it which aren't too visible in the pic.

It has a very low foot on the bottom and sits well. I'm just amazed at how light it is. I doubt I will become a turner who specializes in thin works, but at least I can see some good progress. Nothing spectacular as far as the shape goes, but it was good practice.

Now as far as my questions, would you think that this warp was just one of those random things? It seems like this piece was prety balanced as far as the grain being at the same heights on either side, and I stayed quite a bit away from the pith, so that probably did not matter much either. Knowing that I wanted to have a final thick rim (maybe3/4 thick, to which I would slope outwards to make it appear thicker), should I have made this roughout even thicker??? Any guesstimates would be welcome.


img

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

#2

Re: Whatever

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Doesn't kill you, makes you stronger!

Ed, Just imagine how well you'll do when that Stubby arrives if you can do This with what you got now!!

Good job, keep on keepin' on!

Mark

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

#3

Re: Whatever

Ed Kelle

>Wow! You're sending me a Stubby? How generous! I will go outside and wait for it ;)

The closest thing I have to a Stubby is actually my little Jet mini, which runs wayyy smoother and better than the big old Deltoid. I try to do as much work as possible now with the Jet and my sanding energy for when I absolutely positively need to use the big one. Skills have improved quite a bit in the past 3 weeks now that I am not under constant machine induced stress.

Thanks Mark

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

#4

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

Jack Savona

>Ed, nice lines on that bowl. They go well with its thickness/thinness. I like the general sweep inwards starting at the rim. However, while I like it as is, something inside me also wants a curve on the rim, at least an inward slope on the inner rim, for the flow.

If I made that bowl just as it is, I would be very pleased with it. Long live design opportunities!

Jack

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

Keith Tompkins

>Hi again, Ed. This looks good also. The flared rim also works well for goblet forms. I have noticed that cherry moves quite a bit as it dries...some of my pieces have warped over an inch out of round, but no cracks.

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

#6

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Ed, I've made this basic form many times, sometimes intentionally, sometimes due to "opportunities" such as yours. Either way, it is a pleasing form that customers love and buy readily. Nice job on this one.

The inward sloping rim provides you a possible trick on the eye - elongating the slope makes the rim appear thicker than actual, this can be used to provide an effect that tricks the beholder as they expect visually a much heavier bowl and are surprised when they pick it up. I'm not sure this is great for sales but it offers great visual appeal.

All fruitwoods warp (a lot)! Cherry is no exception, but the amount of warp in cherry varies greatly from tree to tree. Thicker roughouts are safer in this respect. The bottoms don't need to be as thick as the rim on the roughs as the bottom doesn't move so much. I always let my customers know that even though the bowl may be round when they buy it, within a few seasons it will be oval as all wooden bowls are eventually.

2 hours sanding? Yikes! Regardless, the results look great.

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

#7

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

Ed Kelle

>Thanks Jack. Yes I also like the inward slope on the top but I just wish I had curved it a bit more. On a profile view it just needs a little more, but by the time I noticed this, I didn't have enough material left to work with. I kind of had a Greek vase type curvature in mind. I'm going to keep at this form and develop it a bit more in future works.

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

#8

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

Ed Kelle

>Thanks Keith, I am going to try and flare a few goblets as well.

As an aside here, last night I looked for goblets on the AAW gallery and after looking at all the pics, I only found about 4 references. Do you think that they are seen more as a beginner project which people quickly get bored with? The gallery is filled with tons of amazing work that takes countless hours, but hardly any spindle work at all. I even admit that I am drawn more to bowls and artsy works as well.

Maybe another opinion survery for you to post?

I hope to be going up to Albany in Oct, maybe I will see you there

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

#9

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

Ed Kelle

>Thanks Mike, I agree with the visual trick of the sloping rim, but in this case it was so thin that it would not have made much difference unless I went to a severly steep angle, and I figured this would not look good. It would look sharp and pointy. ouch.

I figure the warp in this case was just one of those things. My other rough outs have not moved as much, and they are all from the same tree. No biggie. It came out nice in the end.

I'll try to keep the wood movement in mind for the future.

Yup 2 hours sanding. Most of it with the lathe off to deal with the trouble spots. Heck 2 hours really isn't much for me considering I have done jewelry boxes which I have sanded and shaped for a few days. sanding stone scupltures can take even longer. Guess I have quite a long history of hand sanding, it is almost relaxing to me. I'm quite the odd ball with that. ;)

Re: Unintentional thin wall bowl

#10

It's Beautiful!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>