Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

Posts

One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

#1

One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

adrien

>After reading Terry Daniel's (and others') plaints about banjos being too high on many lathes, I had some correspondence with General's sales department. Here's the answer:

"Available is item # 2614-18 tool rest which is 1 inch lower. Cost is $148.00"

From: "General"

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

#2

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

adrien

>The brackets <> didn't let the address get printed....:general@general.ca

to print out in the message or optional Link URL.....

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

#3

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

Don Henthorn

>For $148.00 I could buy a piece of 1/2" plate steel and a little machine work and piece of pipe and locking bolt and have enough left over forsome really nice chisels.(-: Of course I am poor and used to making do. But I did that very thing to make a banjo for my old Blount lathe and used it for years. Probably cost me all of five dollars.

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

#4

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

Bart Rhoads

>Sorry, I guess I need someone to explain that to me. I have owned a General 260-20 for about 6 yrs now. I turn approximately 5 to 6 days a week making both bowls platters and hollow vessels and I havent seen a need for a lower banjo yet. I guess I have my tools ground at an angle that is just at the correct angle for my tool rest.

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Adrien, I have noticed the problem also. The problem with the lower banjo is now the tool rest has less support, the post isn't all that long. Aftermarket tool rests may solve the problem as the rest is not as thick where it joins the post. I make my own rests, I am away on vacation, I'll post photos when I get home. Bart, the reason I like to lower the tool rest is because I can attack the wood with a lowered handle, changing the angle where the tool contacts the wood. This works well with wood that tend to tear out such as butternut and walnut.

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

#6

and it puts less pressure against the wood

tdaniel

>

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

#7

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

Pat Mulligan

>If I buy another banjo for my General it will be a Oneway.

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

#8

Re: and it puts less pressure against the wood

john Lucas

>Terry The pressure against the wood is from the turner pushing on the bevel. If you let the tool do the work you will have the same pressure given the cut is the same thicknes. The chip coming across the cutting edge pushes the tool against the wood.

I've tried your cut and I like it. I've used it for years when turning my mirrors but I find it difficult to really accurately control the shape of the vessel. I started using that cut because I needed to find a way to control the cut using my body when cutting from the middle out. My mirrors usually slope down from the center to the edge and I needed to cut downhill on the grain. With a push cut this required holding your arm way out in the air and the accuracy of the cut was poor. Now I have a sliding headstock so I can cut using my body while standing in front of the lathe. I can get an almost perfect arc using this method.

Using a push cut you are controlling the cut from the end of the tool. A very minute movement of the handle which may be 15" away from the tip will give you an incredible amount of fine control. The tool is also supported 1/4" or less from the cutting edge so if you decide to take a larger cut such as you would when roughing you can do that. Then with the very next pass you can take off a hair's width without ever moving the tool rest.

Sometimes it's not just the tool rest banjo that needs to be lowered to use your cut. Some tool rests have an offset center column that gets in the way when using the low shearing cut. This requires the rest to be moved so you can only use half the tool rest.

I'm not putting down your cut I it works well. It's just not the best cut for everyone. People should try both and see what works best for them. Of course the same is true for bevel angles and grinds.

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

#9

more than meets the eye

tdaniel

>john, come down sometimes and we'll do a little "hands on". The best cut that can be oftained from any tool is when the curls are spiral shaped (like corkscrews). I call this a "slicing cut". It is like using a skew. This cut takes very little pressure against the wood. I demonstrated this to an advanced student recently. He made his best finishing cut for about 2" on a bowl we were making and then I made my best cut right beside his. When we stopped the lathe and compared the cuts both were smooth but his was burnished. I think some people ride the bevel way too hard. A low handle slicing cut makes a bowl steady unnecessary. And you are right, the long handle allows much better tool control.

TD

Re: One inch lower banjo for 26020 General Lathe

#10

Re: more than meets the eye

John Lucas

>That would be fun to compare the cuts. Maybe next time I head to Atlanta I'll take the Elijay Highway. A push cut can be done where the tip of the tool is cutting at the same angle as yours, like a skew with the edge about 80 degrees or so. The bottom wing removes the bulk of the wood and the tip cleans everything up. It does look burnished like the cut off the skew but I think that's a good thing. I've never actually used a bowl steady so I don't really know the advantage. I've turned bowls down to 1/8" just to see if I could do it.