Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

grinding back a roughing gouge

Posts

grinding back a roughing gouge

#1

grinding back a roughing gouge

Terry in Ottawa

>My yard sale roughing gouge has pitting at the cutting edge and about 3/16" back from the edge.

When I grind back past the pitting, should I grind straight into the wheel and then regrind the bevel, or should I follow the bevel back to fresh metal? I have a white wheel (80 grit?) on a 6 inch bench grinder. Any idea how long this should take?

Thanks

Re: grinding back a roughing gouge

#2

Re: grinding back a roughing gouge

John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)

>Why waste all that metal? Unless the metal is severely pitted (which should cause you question using it in the first place), simply grind it at your prefered bevel angle until it is sharp. Any nicks in the edge can be avoided by rolling the gouge a bit more onto its side. You may not get a quality finish but that gouge is not designed to do so.

John

Re: grinding back a roughing gouge

#3

Re: grinding back a roughing gouge

Eduardo Sarmiento Hall-Lima Peru

>well I disagree with it ,I have used a gouge for a long time and have the sides grind back and it does a great shaping and finnishing job for out-side turnings much better than scrapers once you get the hang of it it makes a great shear scraping cut,of course is not a really good anymore for roughing chores but it works for me and will post pict of it tomorrow,the ones that say that will not work as a bowl gouge are not really telling like it is,most of europeans and south americans use this every day for all kinds of work.it makes beatifull shavings .of course NOT ON THE INSIDE OF BOWLS my 2cents

Re: grinding back a roughing gouge

#4

Re: grinding back a roughing gouge

Bill Neddow

>I agree with Ed. I have been using a 1 1/4 inch Sorby spindle roughing gouge to turn the outsides of bowls for years. I also have ground back the top corners about 10 degrees -- strictly as a precaution against getting catches.

There seem to be two reasons given for not using this tool to rough the outsides of bowls.

1. It is too big. Well I have a 3 hp lathe and rough 4 to 6 bowls ranging from 16 to 22 inches per day. Right now I am working my way through an Oak log and anything I can do to speed up the process is welcome.

2. It is not designed for this work and the tine will break. This is a flaw in the tool design. I first bent mine doing spindle work. I prefer to have to deal only with my own limitations (enough of them!) and not have to cope with other limitations imposed by tool design. So I took a piece of 5/8 inch drill rod and the gouge up to my local garage man and had him replace the tine. It may not be pretty, but boy, it does not bend now!

I use it much like a bowl gouge with a standard (not a fingernail) grind. My bowl blanks are not pretty. Lifting over 100 pounds of oak up onto a bandsaw table is not an option, in my books -- so I simply knock the corners off with a chainsaw. The result -- a minumum of eight corners flying by when I start turning. Now this is where this tool excells. I always start to turn at the center of the bottom and work my way out to the corners with each pass. That way, I kind of sneak up behind the corners and knock them off when they are not looking. When you start, you will be turning a lot of air as well as bark and corners. I find the tool fabulous for this and if I start at the centre and use a push cut out toward the corners, I can get the bevel to ride, which keeps me from pushing the tool in too far and getting a catch. Once you get the bowl round and the tool is touching wood all the way, switch to a bowl gouge because it will be faster.

I find it just halves the time it takes for me to rough a bowl. However, I have not been able to get people to listen to me as there is a strong aversion to doing this. I have only run into one other turner who uses this technique, and like me, he does not mention it in the company of other turners any more because of the reaction he gets. Everybody seems to think it is terribly dangerous. I rough about a transport truck load of wood (or more) a year and have not run into any dangerous situation in over five years. And believe me, I am not that lucky!

Glad to hear from Ed that others are also using this technique. It gave me the courage to "come out of the closet".

Re: grinding back a roughing gouge

#5

Re: grinding back a roughing gouge

John Lucas

>Bill I use the same technique you are describing but I use a 5/8" bowl gouge with a long handle I made. It is far safer than the roughing gouge and with a swept back wing grind will remove a lot more wood in a single pass. I learned this technique from John Jordan. With the gouge at the proper angle and enough horsepower you can remove 1/2" of thickness in one pass. By "sneaking up on the corners" as you put it you take away a lot of the vibration problems associated with turning out of round pieces. The weight and leverage of the long handle also helps absorb vibration so it's less tiring to use.

Re: grinding back a roughing gouge

#6

Re: grinding back a roughing gouge

Bill Neddow

>John, I'm glad to hear someone else is using the same technique. I have two 5/8 inch bowl gouges with long handles, one a Glaser and the other a Stubai -- both good tools. But I keep coming back to my old 1 1/4 inch Sorby roughing gouge to do the outsides of bowls. It also has a long handle. I get 1/2 to 3/4 inch chips with it, as opposed to the 1/2 inch ones with the proper bowl gouge. It is important to remember that I only do this with the Sorby until the piece of wood is rounded. Once the chisel is touching all the way round, it is more efficient to use the bowl gouge.