Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Mahogany Bowl Mishap

Posts

Mahogany Bowl Mishap

#1

Mahogany Bowl Mishap

Barry Turner

>I went to the shop to turn a bowl. I had a dry 10" X 10" X 4" Honduras Mahogany blank that I bought some time ago. I turned the outside shape with a 4" foot and a 2" tenon. I power sanded the exterior and reversed the bowl to hollow it. After hollowing, I intended to reverse the bowl again and turn away the tenon, leaving a simple 4" concave foot.

I trued the rim and started to establish the wall thickness, using my new Crown PM bowl gouge. All was going well. The bowl was hollowed about halfway down when I got a king-sized catch and ripped the bowl from the chuck, leaving the 3/8" X 2" tenon behind in the jaws.

The bowl is intact, except for a deep gouge in the rim, which can be turned away. I salvaged the tenon from the chuck jaws and carefully glued it back to the bottom of the bowl using medium-viscosity CA glue. I'm going to leave it clamped overnight and try again.

Considering the ease with which I was able to rip the tenon from the bowl made me wonder, is a 2" tenon adequate for turning a 10" diameter bowl? I suspect that it may be on the small side. Is there a rule of thumb for tenon size in relation to bowl diameter? Thoughts anyone?

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

#2

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

Mike Schwing from Md.

>A 2" tenon is usually sufficient to hold a bowl on the lathe through all of the potential mishaps that can occur while turning. I've had it happen once, and heard of it here on this forum a few times again with softer woods, where the tenon will separate like you describe.

The general concensus is that the jaws, when gripping very tightly, create a weakness in the tenon that will allow it to break in a very clean face grain separation, usually right at the shoulder where the jaws have points of a sort.

My feeling is that the arrangement has been sound enough to allow many thousands of bowls to be successfully turned this way, but that things can and do happen. Screws pop out of faceplate attachments sometimes, too.

Were you really clamped down tightly on the tenon? If so, maybe a little less pressure next time. They don't need to be a death grip.

Of course, figuring out why you had the catch and eliminating that issue will prevent this from happening again.

But yeah, a 2" tenon is fine for a 10" bowl.

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

#3

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

Barry Turner

>No, I didn't have a death grip on that tenon. In fact, I believe I snug up the chuck a bit less than others do. I have turned quite a few bowls with a 2" tenon. I have had this separation problem a couple of times before. Both other times were with green wood, which is a bit weaker. This is the first time it has happened with dry wood.

I like to turn a 2" recess and use the chuck in the expansion mode, he grip seems more secure, but it seems more difficult for me to get a nice looking foot that way.

I am convinced the sole reason for the problem was the gigantic catch, not a poorly-sized or executed tenon. Which I got trying to do a finishing cut with that pesky Crown PM bowl gouge (Ellsworth grind) near the rim of the bowl. I love that gouge, but still haven't gotten the hang of some of the cuts, (this one, for instance) in spite of watching the video a couple of times. I think I may have to get some "hands-on" from someone. Thanks.

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

#4

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

mick

>I turn quite a lot of mahogany, or madeira as it is called locally, here and I find it splits along the grain very easily. I have some 150+ year old mahogany that I rescued from a renovation job that is completely sound and beautiful wood, but I can only turn it end grain because it splits just like yours when I try to turn it face grain.

Mick, in The Bahamas

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

#5

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

Barry Turner

>That's interesting to know. The only other times I have turned Mahogany was using a recess and the chuck in expansion mode or between centers. I'll be more careful with Mahogany from now on. Now, if I can just salvage this bowl and get it to completion. Thanks.

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

#6

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

Glenn Madsen in the SF Bay area

>"I am convinced the sole reason for the problem was the gigantic catch, not a poorly-sized or executed tenon. Which I got trying to do a finishing cut with that pesky Crown PM bowl gouge (Ellsworth grind) near the rim of the bowl. I love that gouge, but still haven't gotten the hang of some of the cuts, (this one, for instance) in spite of watching the video a couple of times. I think I may have to get some "hands-on" from someone."

I take comfort in the notion that I am not the only one to have done this recently. There is a 35 gallon trash can full of interesting firewood, from my learning the use of that gouge profile...

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

#7

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

woodspinner/ Bill Hale

>Many times when I have wood that I consider brittle or soft I will turn the exterior as norman shaping the tennon. I then shut off the lathe and rin a layer of thin CS around the tennon at the bowl base. Let it cure and re run the edge and bottom of the tennon to clean it up for mounting. This seems to stabelize the tennon and less splitting off.,

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

#8

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

Barry Turner

>Yeah..........and that cut looks so damned easy in the video with Ellsworth doing it............you know this is gonna occupy my mind until I figure out how to do it........can't sleep, no appetite.......etc.

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

#9

Re: Mahogany Bowl Mishap

Barry Turner

>I glued the broken tenon back on the bowl with medium-viscosity CA and clamped it overnight with the tailstock of the lathe. I put it back in the chuck and finished hollowing without mishap, then power sanded. All that remains is to reverse the bowl and turn the foot, do a little hand sanding and apply some finish. Whew! Almost fed the firewood pile with that one! Thanks everyone.