We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>What's the difference apart from the grind? They both seem to made from round bar stock with a shallow flute. Some well known vendors don't even list a detail gouge. Is a detail gouge supposed to have an even shallower flute to make it stronger? That is the only clue I have, apart from the profile and grind, and of course more money for a "detail gouge." If this is so why not just get a "spindle gouge" of round bar stock, and grind the requisite profile?
I turned 1/4 and 3/8 spindle gouges into detail gouges. I don't know if there is a difference but these work very well for me. The 1/4 is sharpened "pointy" and the 3/8 has a more rounded tip.
Keith Thompkins is the one who turned me on to the detail gouge and, up till then, I was of the same thinking as you; ie is it just more expensive because they call it by a different name? After buying one and getting used to the sharper or more aggressive cut, I now use it in place of any/all spindle gouges. Keith uses it to hollow small bowls and forms, which I do, too, but in that case the detail gouge is very aggressive but fun.
As to the flute, I believe the flute is deeper than the spindle gouge and that's what makes it give you a more aggressive cut. I'm sure Keith will chime in on this and give you a lot more and better description or explanation.
You have it mostly correct. I find that detail gouges tend to have a more shallow and more narrow flute. This is dependent on the maker. Some brands spindle gouge looks like anothers detail gouge.
As for making your own. You can certinaly do that. Just get some bar stock and mill or grind a flute in the stock then have the stock heat treated.
>Ok I'll throw another into the mix. I have a continental gouge that is my favorite for small turnings. I like it over the spindle and detail gouge because the side walls of the flute are thicker. This makes it vibrate less and I grind the sidewalls a little so I can use them in different ways.
After seeing Mike Hosaluk using the P@n spindle gouge I may buy one of those. it's thick and solid but you grind it so it functions more like a detail gouge with a long thin grind. This has the mass to function as a rough out gouge but the thinner angle at the front makes it great for detail work. It has really good edge holding power.
>I am thinking I will just order the Penn State HSS 3/8 and 1/4 gouges and practice with different grinds. Link below.
At 10.95 ea they won't break the bank, and gee they even come with handles! From the picture it looks pretty robust with a modest flute. I will check the Wood Central grinds library for ideas on profile. I will also try regrinding my small Sears continental gouges for grins. After all I don't use them for anything now.
Comments on above will be appreciated.
This site is more than great. Thanks for the timely and thoughtful responses. As a new turner I always post with a bit of uncertainty, but end up with kindly and helpful feedback that lets me move on. I guess this is all something of an ongoing experiment. This is fun indeed!
I just bought one of your un-handled 3/8" bowl gouges and love it! I'd been wanting to buy a handle system and took the plunge in Kansas a couple of weekends ago. Ended up with the Hosaluk handle and your bowl gouge that you make for him. I'll be back for more!
>I have never heard it expressed like that. I watched George Hatfield use a detail gouge at 25 degress for three weeks, and your above insight never occured to me. Thanks.
DAve Lancaster, for all his hogging out, said to use a smaller gouge to get a finer surface. And then he did it!
>Hi Jerry, a detail gouge has more mass under the cut than a spindle gouge does. Therefore, it can be used with more overhang of the toolrest than a regular spindle gouge can. More mass, less vibration. It works for hollowing for the same reason. I like the Packard/Hamlet and P&N tools. For spindle work, I use the tool on it's side, contacting the centerline of the work.