Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Cracks on cherry bowls

Posts

Cracks on cherry bowls

#1

Cracks on cherry bowls

Jorge Castaneda

>Hello,

recently had my very first opportunity to work with green cherry, and also to practice coring, here are the results, two large cherry bowls, 14" across 6" deep, about 3/4" thick, a little more at the rim; the work sesion was pleasant, and the smell was nice, but both did develop cracks, the one on the left was waxed as soon as the roughing was done and had one crack in 3 weeks, the one on the right was inmersed in alcohol for a day and then put in a paper shopping bag and taped, 3 days later curiosity made me open the bag and it had developed 4 cracks, 3 visible on the picture. Bot came from the same billet and a slab of 2 1/2" was removed to do away with the pith and they still cracked. The smaller bowls made from the corings all received the same treatment as the biggest one and none cracked.

I would appreciate coments and suggestions, I have another dozen blanks and hope to learn how not to crack them, and improve my coring skills, thinking about boiling them now.

Thanks for looking

Jorge


img

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#2

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

David Galloway

>I will be interested in the responses. I have had very inconsistant results with cherry. Some of my largest pieces have done very well and some have cracked badly. I need to be more thoughtful in terms of noting times of year, age of wood, etc... But I do love to turn cherry.

Great article on the virtues of cherry in Thomas Moser's furniture book, by the way.

David Galloway

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#3

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

Dominic Greco in Richboro, PA

>Jorge,

I've run into this time and time again with cherry. IMHO it has a lot to do with grain balancing when cutting the blank up as much as it does the finicky nature of this wood. And some times, no matter how hard you try, cherry will crack! (Honestly, the only wood I think is worse in this regards is apple).

By "balancing the grain" I mean that the grain "density" should be symmetrical about the centerline of the blank, thus ensuring that the grain will be the same with the roughed out bowl. Even grain, even drying.

I recently rough turned (2) 10" diameter shallow bowls from cherry crotch. These were alcohol soaked and didn't split (well, they hadn't split since the last time I check on them a week ago). I attributed these bowls not splitting to my attention to balancing the grain when chainsawing the log.

However, I've also had some success with boiling cherry bowl blanks. Not only does this seem to reduce the occurrence of cracking with cherry, it makes your kitchen smell like cherry preserves! :>) You've just got to remember that after boiling you need to allow the water (and blanks) to cool before removing the bowl blanks. Otherwise they'll crack.

Good luck!

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#4

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

Carole in VA

>I boil all my fruitwoods now. Try to have a fairly even thickness throughout the bowl and boil it longer than you think you need to, depending on thickness. Be sure to let the wood and water cool to room temp before removing. Let it surface dry for a little bit, then use the DNA method if you want to speed drying. If you don't want to use DNA, I think you would still want to wrap in bown paper to dry. Boiling was the only way I could get past the cracking in some particularly fractious pear and cherry I had.

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#5

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

Jorge Castaneda

>David,

I will look at that book. Ihave worked widely with cherry in flat work, always bone dry, this is a different game.

Thanks

Jorge

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#6

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

Jorge Castaneda

>Dominic,

>the grain "density" should be symmetrical about the centerline of the blank<

I know exactly what you mean, that was the first thing I learn my day with Bill Grumbine and always try to acomplish that balance, not always succeding.

Thanks for the tips about boiling.

Jorge

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#7

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

Jorge Castaneda

>Carole,

Thanks for sharing your experiences, I'll pay apecial attention at the thickness thing as I tend to just work by eye. About how long you would boil bowls like these two?

TIA

Jorge

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#8

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

John Lucas

>Jorge

I've had some troubles with Cherry in the past but not lately. I try to turn it as soon as I get it or cut quite a bit off the log before I cut the bowl blanks. John Jordan turns a lot of cherry and doesn't have any problems. He says that you have to be really careful to cut away all of the checks and start with really good wood. I also turn them to a consitent thickness thoughout. I turn the bottom of the bowl a little thinner so the bottom +tenon is not far from the thickness of the sides.

I did have an oak bowl crack pretty bad the other day but I think it was mostly because I was trying to keep cool and had big fan running all day long in the shop. the bowl was probably too close to the fan.

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#9

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

Jorge Castaneda

>John,

The cherry came from the Syracuse NY area, already cut in 16' sections, I did wax the ends as soon as I got it but could not work on them inmediately, too many things going on, now I am aproaching the slack time and then I can go turn big guns if it is not too hot. I guess I'll scratch this batch as learning experience and next time I buy cherry, buy the log.

Thank you

jorge

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#10

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

Barry Irby

>A guy (who shall remain nameless) in our club turns a lot of cherry. Dozens or hundreds of bowls, some 16" He roughs them to about an inch and a quarter and air drys them on a wire rack. He cuts the chuck foot off. Claims that's where the cracking starts

I have turned quite a few green to finish and have had good success. I turn them thin, about 5/16 to 3/8". I do have trouble with apple and have decided to turn all the sap off it and only use heart wood.

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#11

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

Carole in VA

>I don't have a clue how long you would need to boil those rascals. I have only done small bowls (6"-8") about 1/2" thick (I only have a Mini)and I boil them about an hour and a half. Jim King is the Master Boiler so maybe he will chime in here.

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#12

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

Jorge Castaneda

>Barry

Looking at my bowls, they still have sap wood on them, next time I'll try removing all of it; I will also try leaving them thicker.

Turning to finish the bowl in one go is still another path to try,

Thanks very much

Jorge

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#13

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

Eduardo Sarmiento Hall-Lima Peru

>Hi jorge why dont you get in touch with jim king he can give you a tip or two aboth boiling the wood so you dont get cracks? check his place and go to interesting reading ED

www.exoticwoodworld.com

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#14

Dick Hines

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

Dick Hines

>Every thing I turn that is wet, almost venery thing I turn, I dunk in DNA bath over night and the rap it up in a brown bag per instructions giver by Dave Smith. Doing this has saved me a lot of trouble with wet bowls.

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#15

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

Barry Irby

>Apple is terrible about cracking if you leave the sap on it and cherry is nearly as bad. Actually, most of the "fruit" woods share this trait to some extent. Maybe other woods, too.

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#16

Boiling will help but I don't like to do it.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi Jorge,

One thing I heard in your explanation was that you put the bowl in a bag after soaking. I assume you noticed that the bowls were cracking from the outside. Because of the larger outside surface area more moisture will be lost from the outside. The moisture loss will cause the wood to shrink on the surface and the resulting tension will cause cracks to form. The reason I suggest that the out side of the bowl be wrapped in brown paper is to slow down the moisture loss from the outside surface. Allowing the inside to dry at the same rate as the outside will reduce the cracking problem to near zero. Putting sealer only on the outside slows down the moisture loss too much which induces more distortion.

Putting a bowl in a bag does slow down the moisture loss but it doesn't help even out the stresses. Also, turning the bowls to thinner thickness reduces the total stress across the wall. So my diagnosis from 3,000 miles away is to try wrapping the outside after soaking a bowl and leave the inside open to air. I also suggest a longer soak time in the DNA. I found the first wood that didn't respond to overnight soaking. Madrona bowls soaked 24 hours cracked severely in less than a day. I soaked a second batch of madrona bowls for 3 days and the only cracking was around knots in a couple bowls. Madrona is worse than any apple or plum I have turned.

Dave Smith

The end of a beautiful summer day in Longview, WA.

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#17

Re: Boiling will help but I don't like to do it.

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Which species of cherry are you using? All three of the following are native of Maine: A mentor with a lot more turning experience than I have warns against turning pin cherry, Prunus pensylvanica or common chokecherry Prunus virginiana because both have a tendency to come violently apart while turning, which is an even bigger problem than cracking afterwards. Black cherry, Prunus serotina is the native cherry that you want to turn.

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#18

I turn the native stuff that grows around here.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi William,

We don't have the nice black cherry trees around here so I turn what I can get. Mostly fruit trees but I do get some good sized wild cherry trees from time to time. The real problem is turning the the blanks while they are fresh. It cracks crazy in a very short time. I soak the rough outs in DNA and lose very few of the pieces drying the drying process.

Dave Smith

Getting close to my bed time in Longview, WA.

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#19

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

pfduffy

>A small but perhaps important addition to the discussion; drill out the base of the bottom tendon with a forsner bit before beginning the chosen drying process. Drill as deep as is necessary to closely match the thickness of the sides of the bowl. I find that the rate of drying is more evenly distributed, resulting in fewer cracks - -regardless of what system of drying I use. Phil

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#20

Gracias Eduardo!

Jorge Castaneda

>That is a good article.

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#21

Alky Master

Jorge Castaneda

>Hi Dave,

I'm glad you chimed in, your 3,000 miles away diagnosis makes sense, athough I've read everything I found about soaking in alcohol, I did not get the point you are making now of balancing tensions, more stuff to keep in mind, Leaving the bowls soaking 3 days is easy enough, so I will do that too.

Surprisingly, the bowls distorted little so far and they weight quite a bit less than when turned, I think I will explore too finish turning at once and then just sand after the soaking.

Gracias!

Jorge

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#22

Re: Boiling will help but I don't like to do it.

Jorge Castaneda

>William,

I have to do some research to be able to identify the species, when I made the clearing for the house, there was a big old cherry tree hollow and full of ants, about 18" in diamater in the main bole, I had it milled anyway and part of it became the kitchen counter and the rest went into beds. Cherry trees keep just popping like weeds around here and the ones that I left when the clearing was made, are about 25' tall but only 4" thick, so I have no hope to see them as thick as the mother tree, or perhaps these are a different species, the wood is not very red, more greyish and they smell like cough syrup. The cherry I used for these bowls came from a wood chopper from Syracuse NY, the heart is very red and it smells nice but not as strong as the wimpy local cherry.

Thanks

Jorge

Re: Cracks on cherry bowls

#23

Thanks Phil

Jorge Castaneda

>