Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

I DID IT!

Posts

I DID IT!

#1

Keith Tompkins

I DID IT!

Keith Tompkins

>I mentioned in last week's chat (before I lost my connection) that I was working on an article. The subject is form and design. I have a new-found respect for anyone who writes for a living....I struggled to make my point, second-guessing myself constantly, rewriting things over and over. Now, only two more articles to write! Should be a piece of cake! (arrggh) I now cannot imagine how ANYONE could ever write a book.

Any writers out there? Any tips you care to share? Are there any wood turning subjects that you would be interested in writing about?

Re: I DID IT!

#2

Re: I DID IT!

Ben Aragon

>Keith,

I've heard said, "there are no good writers just good editors". From your posting I've read you have an abundance of great information to pass on. Find a good editor and write away. I can't wait to read your articles.

Ben

Re: I DID IT!

#3

Re: I DID IT!

e

>the secret to good writing, espeically technical articles, is that after you've completed the piece, hide it for at least a month.

it is amazing how the passage of time can give you a new perspective--usually leaving you to wonder, "who wrote this crap?" ...

and then you realize "oh, me!".

ah, what we do for love.

Re: I DID IT!

#4

Re: I DID IT!

Spence in Rhode Island

>I can really connect with what you are saying Keith. I've been trying to write an article on hearing impairments and the woodturner for quite awhile now. Seems no matter what I do it comes out sounding like I'm writing more for AARP than the AAW. I'm about ready to throw in the towel on this one. Good to hear that you got it done and look forward to reading it.

Best Regards,

Spence

Re: I DID IT!

#5

Re: I DID IT!

Barry Irby

>I wrote a book. Actually a reporting system for Home Inspectors 280 pages. Took the pictures, too. No plot or character development. Still, I understand why they said that only one in a hundred thousand people ever finish a book. Many start, few finish.

I would suggest that you write a good outline. At least a list of bullet points. Expand from there.

I read a book once on underground houses. Again, not a mystery novel, no plot, no characters. What I liked about it was that it started with a sentence that explained what the book was about. Maybe it was a paragraph, but it was very short and you knew where it was going and what it was about. That paragraph was expanded into the first chapter. Each paragraph in the first chapter was expanded into a chapter in the book. How many times have you read something where you did not exactly understand where the author was going and your thinking was off track. When you finally grasped what he was doing, and the light went on, you said to yourself, I wish I had time to go back and read it again, I would understand much better.

You are not writing a mystery. Make what you are doing and why clear from the beginning.

PS. In my report system I broke it down into chapters with a matching report page for each chapter. Roof, Exterior, Structure etc. The idea was that I would report things like Damaged and leaking Gutters on the roof page of the report, and Negative grading on the Exterior page, Water standing in the crawl space on the structure page, Condensation in the attic, etc. I thought this would lead people to understand that the house had a water problem and that it was all interrelated. Nope! They don't get it. When you point out all these problems and symptoms they just stare. When you finally say, Therefore, I conclude you have a water problem, they are startled and say, "What makes you think so?" They just don't use their logic to say If This then Than.

Re: I DID IT!

#6

Re: I DID IT!

Pascal Oudet

>Hi Keith,

I have written 6 articles, all woodturning related, about making a particular piece.

I first fully write the text, choose when I want a picture to illustrate what I'm saying, then go to the shop,

and turn the piece and take many pictures (~150 to keep ~20 at the end, sometimes variations of a particular picture, sometimes just another part of the process I did not originally intend to photograph).

Writing the text before turning allows me to come back and say "hu, if I'd done that earlier that would help the explanation here", I've just to insert a line of text and that's it.

Easier than to restart the process while at the lathe !

I sometimes rewrite some parts of the text several times to get my point clear.

Usually while turning I also slightly modify the text.

then the most difficult thing for me is to fit everything within the limits the editor gives me. usually I have 2000 characters more than needed (8000 instead of 6000 for 3 pages), and a few pictures to.

It usually takes many rereading to get to the result, and the help on my wife (and another reader) is very usefull. no tricks, just time.

I've never wrote a "theoretical" article.

Pascal

Re: I DID IT!

#7

Re:Where will it be published?

Keith Newton

>Pardon my ignorance, but i don't take any turning magazines, but would like to read your thoughts. So where do you plan to publish it?

Re: I DID IT!

#8

Re: I DID IT!

John Lucas

>Spence don't give up yet. I have an article on how my friend makes his candlesticks and I just can't seem to get it done. I rewrite it or reorganize the photos. It just ain't workin' yet. I promised myself I would finish is this week. It's only been in the works for 2 months. I chastise myself when I do stuff like that but sometimes you just gotta sit back and look at it a while.

Re: I DID IT!

#9

Re: I DID IT!

John Lucas

>Keith I like -e-'s advise. Sit back for a few days or longer and then reread it. Don't do this too much or you will rewrite it everytime you do it. It does make it easier to find sentences that don't make sense or don't come arcross as clear as you would like. The other thing I do when I have time is to have someone else read it. They don't know all the woodturning terms and sequences but they often point out unclear sentences or stupid grammatical errors.

I'm looking forward to your article. After doing a demo on form I got home and whished I had done almost everything differently. That's a demo I really really need to work on to make if flow better.

Re: I DID IT!

#10

Re: I DID IT!

Bill Crommett

>Regarding technical instructions: I have often raged at the engineers who tell how to assemble a complicated piece of equipment. The trouble is that the engineers write instructions for engineers and not for the consumer. If only they would show the secretary out in the front office how to assemble the project and let her write the manual in language that the consumer could understand. I feel better, now. I have been wanting to say this for many years.

Re: I DID IT!

#11

Re: I DID IT!

Russ Fairfield

>An old editing trick. Errors in spelling, punctuation, and syntax will become more obvious if you read the article BACKWARDS. I am serious. Try it.

Re: I DID IT!

#12

Congratulations

Sam Simpson

>Hi Y'all,

Congratulations Keith, it's a big hurdle.

I've done some writing and lecturing and learned most of my skills from my Dad, who was a professor of woodwork technology. Consequently he wrote and lectured a lot on the subject.

Apart from rereading and rewriting there are a few techniques that can help hone ones skills. First the old adage "tell them what you are going to say, say it, and then tell them what you just said." Also, I have always found it useful to take notes during a question session that follows a lecture. What folks ask, is what wasn't made clear. This technique can be used with writing. If you have someone read your article and then ask you questions about it, you will find out what might need to be tweaked.

I remember my Father sitting at the dinning table and reading his lectures out-loud when I was just eight years old. The lectures would be on metallurgy or saw-setting or some other subject way beyond my comprehension. But he would be seeking simple responses. If an eight year old asked about a certain technical term, then it must be an important piece of information to make the lecture coherent. The lecturer then has to ask himself, does my audience know that term, or is that something I should explain?

So, testing is probably the most important thing. Asking those close to you to suffer the trials of a new woodworking article is probably the best thing one can do. So long as all comments are taken seriously.

I have often thought that the best technical books are those who's chapters are written as a set of separate but complete lectures. This allows for complete comprehension before moving on to the next chapter. I have never liked the idea of referencing other chapters to seek answers on a technical aspect. If sharpening is covered in chapter two and finishing in chapter eleven, so be it. But whatever chapter one is currently reading should be whole and complete without needing reference to the other chapters. Simple statements like "using sharp tools, proceed as follows" and "finish as appropriate" should be all that is needed as a tie in.

Regards Sam Simpson.

Re: I DID IT!

#13

Re: I DID IT!

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Keith,

Congratulations! I would love to see this article - please let us know when it comes out.

You've received many fine suggestions. I like Russ's suggestion of reading it backwards - I've done that myself, and it works. A good editor helps a lot. They can really clean up a lot of small problems.

Lately all my articles have been on penturning, since I write a column for Fred Holder's More Woodturning magazine. Over at Penturners.org I learned how to do editing, and helped a lot of their articles get finished. Just try to be clear in what you are saying, and allow your personality to come through. After reading your posts here I'm sure you'll be fine.

If you do want somebody to bounce it off of, drop me a note, I'd be happy to help.

Scott.

Re: I DID IT!

#14

Re: I DID IT!

Ed in No.VA

>Writing is like turning the more you do the better you get. Try writing a monthly article for your club news letter. that monthly dead line keeps you writing. Illistrations are great even drawings, I have done three books, the best was on how to make charcoal. It was intended for african charcoal makers who are illiterate for the most part. I partenered with an illistrator who drew a picture of each step in the process. It was used all over the third world and worked regardless of language or literacy difficulties. Yes set it aside and let it age. Get an editor that you can work with, use outlines, and practice practice practice turning er writing.

Ed

Re: I DID IT!

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: I DID IT!

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks for the great advise, everyone! I can see why most articles are technical in nature....they are much easier to write. It seems each time I wrote about a design concept, it contradicted what well known turners have been saying on the subject for years. I wanted to make my points without offending anyone. My main objective is to allow turners to look at the process of turning and design from a different perspective.

I sure picked a challenging topic for an article.....thanks again!