Re: Working on form
Mike Schwing from Md.
>Hi Roger. I had a great time in KC, too. Form is a tough thing to judge, as we each reflect in our comments our own personal preferences for the way we'd like to do it ourselves. My comments will be no different in that light, but I'll try. Apologies in advance if I sound like a prick. I have a difficult time being very honest and not sounding like an ass, it is not intentional.
I like the widest diameter profile of the first one very much. The majority of the profile is consistent. When viewed from the side as you have pictured it, the form seems to vanish into thin air at the top. When I look at it, I want there to be more of it above the widest diameter, so I would have tried to extend the form by not closing in the radius above the widest point quite as tightly. It looks a little also like the bottom of the profile has a little bit of a "belly", it could be drawn in a bit more.
I'm not too fond of the second form. It has quite a few sudden direction changes that if smoothed out would work together a bit better. Think of holding a string in two hands and moving your hands up and down, close and far apart - you'll see no interruptions in the forms the string makes - those kinds of profiles I like.
The third piece is a very difficult form to achieve and you've done a good job. I would probably have removed the foot and tucked the bottom in but this is still a good job on a tough form.
The little guy on the end is nice, too, I would like to see the bottom profile a bit more consistent and more of a curve to it towards the bottom.
I like the opportunity to critique a form without any sanding or finishing work, it really does allow a more honest assessment of the form. Thanks for holding these up for us to look at.