Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Working on form

Posts

Working on form

#1

Working on form

Roger T

>Howdy all,

Longtime lurker here, but going to the 2005 Symposium and being able to talk with other turners has given me rise to start to contribute to the group.

Today I was attempting to work on the forms of some hollow vessels. The first form on the left had a catch and I ended up having to cut the small neck off of it. Or it would have been similar to the other 3.

While I believe that all 4 forms are very similar in nature, they each have pluses and mimuses. I am looking for fair and honest criticisms.

No attempt has been made on these to remove tool marks, or sand out at all. Tell me what is good and bad about the pieces.

Thanks much everyone.

Roger


img

Re: Working on form

#2

Re: Working on form 

Roger T

>


img

Re: Working on form

#3

Re: Working on form

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Hi Roger. I had a great time in KC, too. Form is a tough thing to judge, as we each reflect in our comments our own personal preferences for the way we'd like to do it ourselves. My comments will be no different in that light, but I'll try. Apologies in advance if I sound like a prick. I have a difficult time being very honest and not sounding like an ass, it is not intentional.

I like the widest diameter profile of the first one very much. The majority of the profile is consistent. When viewed from the side as you have pictured it, the form seems to vanish into thin air at the top. When I look at it, I want there to be more of it above the widest diameter, so I would have tried to extend the form by not closing in the radius above the widest point quite as tightly. It looks a little also like the bottom of the profile has a little bit of a "belly", it could be drawn in a bit more.

I'm not too fond of the second form. It has quite a few sudden direction changes that if smoothed out would work together a bit better. Think of holding a string in two hands and moving your hands up and down, close and far apart - you'll see no interruptions in the forms the string makes - those kinds of profiles I like.

The third piece is a very difficult form to achieve and you've done a good job. I would probably have removed the foot and tucked the bottom in but this is still a good job on a tough form.

The little guy on the end is nice, too, I would like to see the bottom profile a bit more consistent and more of a curve to it towards the bottom.

I like the opportunity to critique a form without any sanding or finishing work, it really does allow a more honest assessment of the form. Thanks for holding these up for us to look at.

Re: Working on form

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Working on form

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Roger, here is my take....the first form appears to be flat on the top, which does not tie in to the rest of the form....my eye wants to continue with the form, and nothing is there. The second form is confusing, it appears to have two seperate points of interest, one below center, and one abrupt one near the top. I would recommend one, clean continuous curve, similar to the third form. The third one is something I like, I have no problems with it at all....I wouldn't change a thing.(except sand it, finish it, and put it in a gallery!) From the photo, the foot on the last piece looks a big too big. You are certainly on the right track!

Re: Working on form

#5

Re: Working on form

e

>hi roger!

DON'T listen to Mike! -- he's never been a 'prick', and is one of the nicest guys around. And he's got great advice!

one suggestion in helping you with form is to pass on suggestions from photographers on improving your pictures(john Lucas may want to jump in here).

first: try raising the height of the camera so that your aiming downward onto the top 1/3 of the object. it appears that this higher perspective provides a better view of the outline for the eyes.

next: my old eyes need a great focus -- nothing that can distract from the form -- i can't see a blurred outline on the old laptop. everything starts just looking like cooked vegetables.

and finally, it appears that some of the objects have flat-spots (but this might be me). one suggestion from David Ellsworth that works for me is to close your eyes and let your fingers feels the curve. more often, you'll feel the flat spots before your eyes see them.

congratulations on your exploration of form -- nice work! check out ceramic and glass art; asking yourself why you like/dislike something is a great tool!

Re: Working on form

#6

Re: Working on form

Ed in No.VA

>3&4 are the best. 1 the largest diameter is too close to the top. 2 the largest diameter is centered, should be slightly higher. you have an ogee at the top that is hard to get right but this one is not bad. The side looks to be straight toward the bottom. Now this is all turner talk. Finish them and put them up for sale price by size and see what goes out the door first. You might be surprised.

Ed

P.S. Schwing doesn't know how to be a prick.

Re: Working on form

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Working on form

Brad Vietje

>Well here's my 2 cents...

I think we're unanimous on the first one -- either a gentler curve, or something more on top.

I'll differ with the group (so far) on the second -- to my eyes (and low-rez laptop while travelling on biz), this isn't so far off as others have suggested. I'd work on the abrupt change of curvature that seems to separate the lower curve and upper "deck", which seems a little too flat to me. If that transition were changed to a smooth curve, I'd probably like this one the best; I have a few in the works not too dissimilar from what would result from smoothing this curve.

The third is nice, but to me it seems a little bulky up top... -e-'s suggestion of shooting the pic from a little higher might cure that for me, and show off the nice form better.

I like the fourth better than the third, as I think this one has a better profile in the upper regions. I agree w/-e- again -- a better photo would make the critique easier, but these side-by-side comparisons are very helpful -- thanks !

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Tucson, AZ -- but really from Thetford, VT

Re: Working on form

#8

Re: Working on form

Barry Turner

>i DON'T LIKE THE FLA TOP ON # 1. # 2'S curves just don't flow. I like # 3 and # 4 much better. The curves flow better and have more "life".

Re: Working on form

#9

Re: Working on form

Roger T

>Morning gang,

I want to thank you all a bunch. This is exactly the kind of comments that I was looking for. Concerning the first 2 pieces. The first piece was a casualty of war. While hollowing it, I had a bad catch while undercutting the top. So rather than loose it, I simply parted off the top, (since I figured I was just working on basic body form) or it would have had a neck and top similar to the rest.

Piece #2, was the first piece I turned yesterday. This and #4 were actually the ones I thought I had did the best on. But after everyones comments, and holding the last 3 pieces up together, I can now see where the top radius leading into the top should have been.

Piece #3 was a casualy also. I had the basic form pretty well done, and had started hollowing when the piece snapped off. So rather than toss it in the garbage, I just grabbed the belt sander and tried to level the bottom into something it would sit up on. Thats why the foot doesnt look right. Thats why the neck dont look right either. Never got to refine it as would have been done with a completed piece.

Piece #4 was probably the toughest to work on. Seems to me the smaller the piece the more difficult it is to pull everything together. Removing a 1/16" of material can and will drastically alter the shape of the vessel.

All in all it was a good day in the shop. None of the pieces will ever make it past the garbage can but all give me a good direction to shoot to.

Again thanks all for taking the time to look these over. I really appreciate it.

Roger