Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

Posts

Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

#1

Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

Jonathan Spool

>I am looking to purchase a captive ring tool, but after seeing the one Jimmy Clewes uses on his newest DVD, that has an awesome hook on it with a unique grind, I thought I'd ask around!

Jonathan

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

#2

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend? *LINK*

Fred Holder

>I'm not sure what captive ring tool Jimmy Clewes is using. I personally have two different sets: one three piece set by Robert Sorby and a single piece tool from Crown Tools.

I've had the Robert Sorby tools for about 15 years now and I suppose I prefer them because I generally reach for them when turning captive rings on wedding goblets or baby rattles. With the Sorby tool you have a bead cutting tool to shape the top of the ring and then a right hand and left hand tool for the undercutting. This is more expensive than the Crown tool, but I've found it very effective over the years.

The Crown tool is a hook tool that is ground on both sides so that the one tool can undercut on both sides and supposedly also cut the top of the ring. It does work and you have only one tool to buy.

Many people simply use a skew chisel to make captive rings. I've done this on very small rings in good dense wood. If you are not proficient with the skew, get a ring cutting tool.


Fred Holder's Domain Site

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

#3

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

Ruth Niles

>Jonathan, I made my own from files. I'm not concerned the files will break because when turning captive rings, you're not exerting a lot of pressure as you would if you used files to make a bowl scraper. The price is right!

Ruth


img

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

#4

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

john Lucas

>I made mine from an old screwdriver. I would suggest making them from old planer blades. They are HSS and will hold an edge longer than a screwdriver and won't be brittle like files.

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

#5

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

Stuart Johnson

>Ruth, What did you use or how did you grind the shape?

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

#6

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

Ed in No.VA

>Ihave one Sorby and two home brew reground from Harbor Freight HHS turning tools.

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

#7

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

Ruth Niles

>Stuart,

I used a grinder at a friend's machine shop, it was small and rounded. Ok, I didn't use it, he let me watch him use it!

Ruth

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

#8

Re: Which captive ring tool do you recommend?

Jonathan Spool

>Thanks everyone,

I really like the profile of the tools Ruth made, although I doubt I have the proficiency to make mine come out like that!