Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Posts

To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#1

To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Eric Kuehne

>Good day,

Well I have finally narrowed the field to the Supernova 2 and Talon chucks for my Jet 1236 and am now sitting on the proverbial fence. I understand that they are both fine chucks but am trying to understand the specific differences between them.

I am aware of the following:

While both chucks require a dovetail in the piece when use in expanding mode the Talon doesn't appear to have this requirement when used in compression mode. Do either or both of these require special tools to make the dovetails?

The Supernova 2 uses a hex key whereas the Talon seems to have the gear integrated into the wrench. Both systems seem acceptable to me. I'll spare my mechanical engineer's analysis of their merits.

I will be using these mostly for bowl and hollow forms. Any advice, opinions or info would be much appreciated.

Be careful out there.

Eric

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#2

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

ben d

>I have the super nova and like it fine. As far as cutting the dove tail a skew is the perfect angle and all you have to check is the depth. Tne nova owner manual covers that. Enjoy

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#3

Brian McKearney

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Brian McKearney

>While I don't own either chuck (I have a Vicmarc), one thing that you might investigate and consider is the direction in which you tighten the chuck. My first chuck was one of the original Nova chucks with the two bars, and as I recall, it tightened in the opposite direction than I would have expected - this may be a European standard? Perhaps others on the board can provide more info as to whether both chucks tighten by turning the key in the same direction. While not a show stopper, it is something to get used to...

Brian

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Brad Vietje

>I've used them both, and both are great chucks. Whether or not a dovetail shaped foot is needed depends on the particular jaw set in use at the time. Both chucks can be used with a number of different jaw sets for differing needs -- the Supernova-2 has a wider range of jaws available.

Oneway's profiled jaws grip very well, but they aren't great if you intend to take the piece off and re-chuck it later; dovetail or "smooth" jaws are better for that, in my book. The standard #2 profiled jaws from Oneway are excellent jaws that can grip round or square stock well. The Oneway "dovetail" jaws are their smooth jaws. While the idea is that a properly sized and shaped foot can be held in these jaws witthout marring the finished foot (usually with a layer of cloth between wood and metal), this only works if you want a foot the same size as the fully compressed jaws -- pretty limiting. In practice, a set of dovetail or smooth jaws can hold green or dry wood very well, as long as the tenon is correctly sized and shaped. There are no special tools needed, just a little practice.

The 50mm standard Nova jaws are also very versatile. I have not used the new Nova bowl jaws, which are much beefier than the old standby 50mm jaws -- these may be a standard option now, also.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Brad Vietje

>Oneway is "Righty-Tighty, Lefty Loosy", in other words, tightens (jaws in compression) with clockwise twist of the key, while the Supernova tightens CCW.

Just to tick off the thousands of dedicated Oneway fans out there, I'll submit (tounge in cheek) that since the Nova scroll chucks are the original, Oneway must be backwards !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#6

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I have the Talon and it has worked fine for me. You don't need a dovetail in either expansion or contraction uses. The jaws have ridges and grooves that grip the wood. The Super Nova 2 is a larger chuck and may be more appropriate for larger work. The smaller size of the Talon can be an advantage, because it doesn't block as much access to the work. You can't go wrong with either chuck.

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#7

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Bruce Wiseman

>I own the super nova 2 and like it alot. It does turn backwards compared to the Talon but there is an engraved arrow on it showing which way to tighten. If it is the only chuck you use it won't be a problem. I wonder about the weight difference and the stress on your bearings? I believe the Talon weighs less but I don't have the specs in front me. I cut the dove tail spigot with the bowl gouge in sort of a side shear cut. With just a little practice you can cut a pretty good dove tail and not have to stop and switch tools.

Good Luck

Bruce

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#8

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Gordon Seto

>Both are fine chucks. The biggest advantage Teknatool over Oneway is that all Teknatool jaws (except the 5" powergrip jaw) fit from the small Midi to the massive Titan chuck. With Oneway, the jaws are not interchangable between Talon & Stronghold. You have to have separate jaws for each chuck; I think that's not cost effective.

Various jaw sets are not essential, but sometimes they are convenient to have. I like the long nose jaws which give clearance to the bottom of work piece.

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#9

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Barry Turner

>I have a SuperNova with several sets of jaws. It seems to function just fine. I've never had any problems with pieces coming out of the chuck.

Oneway Talon and Stronghold chucks do seem to have a mighty loyal following pf satisfied customers.

In spite of this, I intend to purchase a SuperNova II simply because all of my jaws will fit either the SuperNova or the SuperNova II.

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#10

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Rick Allen

>Hi Eric

Just to keep things confused. The Oneway talon jaws will fit the Nova chucks. The range of solid grip for the Oneway profile jaws is much greater than any other jaws by any manufacture. So you can have the benifits of the Oneway Jaws design on a Nova chuck.

The Nova chuck can not be used on a 33mm Oneway lathe spindle. So if you think there might be a Oneway lathe in your future know that a Nova chuck can not thread onto the 33mm Oneway spindle. You can get a Nova chuck adaptor for a Powermatic or Stuby. You can of course get a spindle adaptor to mount 1x8 threaded accesories onto a 33x3.5 spindle.

The Oneway chucks have provisions for locking their chucks onto the spindle. I have seen a chuck dismout from a running jet mini after a catch. I have only seen this happen once. It was a sight to behold and more than a little scary. The simple set screws that Oneway provides for on their chuck spindle adaptors eliminates this as a posiblity. If you move to a larger lathe with dynamic breaking and reverse this issue of unintended dismout become more of an issue. I have had my 5 1/2" Vicmarc chuck start to dismount more than once from dynamic breaking when a large work piece is mounted in the chuck. I now much remember to set my dynamic breaking to slow when using my Vicmarc chuck. Some will say that there is an easy fix to the issue. If it is so easy then why don't Vicmarc, Nova and Axminster do it.

Thanks

Richard

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#11

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>The information in the linked article may be helpful. I have heard others recommend the Nova chuck body because it is cheaper, and the Oneway face jaws for their holding ability.


http://www.woodcentral.com/russ/russ7.shtml

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#12

Brad Vietje

Re: Slight Clarification Needed

Brad Vietje

>As Rick suggests, a very handy feature of the Oneway chucks is the locking screw that can be used to prevent the chuck from locking onto, or coming flying off of the spindle -- but only if that spindle also happends to be made by Oneway.

The Oneway lathes and chucks are part of a very well designed system, but the chucks, when used on other lathe brands lose that particular advantage. Of course, I also take Rick's comments to suggest that other lathe manufacturers could machine a little groove in their spindle shafts to accept the lock screw, and make turning safer, and he's absolutely right.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#13

Brad Vietje

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Brad Vietje

>Russ,

Thanks for the article -- I'd like to see an update that includes the Supernova-2 and the Titan someday. haven't used the Titan yet, but the S-N2 is a very fine chuck.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#14

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Russ Fairfield

>Brad,

I agree that it is about time for someone to do a thorough side-by-side evaluation of ALL of the chucks available in todays market. The last one was by the late Steve Blenk in the old American Woodworker Magazine at least 10 years ago. Since then, the manufacturers have improved their products, and there are several new chucks available. There are also a couple economy chucks introduced to the market in the last couple years.

My observations of the chucks that are included in my article are from those I have used at club demonstrations, other woodturners shops and studios, and what I have purchased for my own use. When I get to use one of the new chucks, I will rewrite the article to include it. So far, none of the clubs where I have done demos have had one of them, I don't need any more chucks for myself, and none of the manufacturers have offered one of their new models for an evaluation.

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#15

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>Ed, I find it interesting that no one ever says anything about the range of jaw movement from fully closed to fully open. The Oneway (which no one has mentioned yet) and the Talon have a much greater adjustment range which I find to be quite valuable to me. Also, the small size of the Talon compared to the SuperNovas doesn't mean it has less strength. Now, go get whichever chuck you finally settle on and be happy.

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#16

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Walter Ahlgrim

>Just to confuse things a bit more the Super Nova 2 is available with its body directly threaded at 33M to fit your Oneway, if you sure one is in your future.

Nova inserts are available with a set screw in 1 1/4 X8 part #ILNS and with out set screw #IYNS. This set screw line up with a groove in the spindle of there DVR.

Does Oneway provide a set screw on every insert or just the 33M ?

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#17

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Rick Allen

>Last I heard the Oneway insert did not provide set screws for all of the different sized inserts. The holes for the set screws are found in all of the inserts.

The folk lore I heard was that Oneway used to include set screws in all of the inserts but they got a call that the chuck wouldn't tread onto a Jet mini spindle. It was determined that the set screws in that insert needed to be retracted and then the chuck threaded on easily. To keep that from happening the folks at Oneway stopped including the set screws for some of the insert sizes. However, if you call, e-mail, snail mail or talk to Oneway at a trade show they will be happy to send you set screws.

The implication that the Oneway chucks are designed with extra features that are only of benefit when using a Oneway lathe is false. You don't need a grove for the set screw to be of benefit. Most all lathe spindles are made of steel which has been hardened. The set screws which can be used with Oneway chucks will provide safety from accidental dismount on most any lathe.

By contrast the Vicmarc chuck solution to prevent accidental dismount works only on Vicmarc lathes. I was speaking with the good folks at Robust lathes this past weekend. They are Vicmarc distributors. I asked if the spindle on their lathe would take the Vicmarc locking collar. He did note that there was a grove for the Oneway set screw. He also mentioned that he would look into the Vicmarc solution and perhaps incorporate that into future spindles.

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

#18

Re: To Talon or Supernova 2, that is the question

Eric Kuehne

>Thanks one and all for the input. I guess the main thing I have learned is that I pretty much can't go wrong with either solution which is a serious comfort.

Russ, I have read your article a couple of times and found it to be a great primer. An update would be great. I hope you get the opportunity to try some of the new chucks.

I like the idea of the set screw locking feature. One sure way to prevent marring the spindle would be to replace the stock screw with a nylon tip version. I think my local hardware store carries them. If not, I know they are available from McMaster-Carr.

The Talon seems to have a little more adjustment range. I compared the numbers and they work out like this.

......................Compression.........Expansion

Talon................1-5/8 - 2-7/8..........2 - 3-3/8

Supernova2.....1-25/32 - 2-7/16.........2 - 3

(Seems that the only way I can this spaced right is to include the dots.)

With all that said I'm going to go with the..... Oh, I think I need to agonize about this a little more.

Eric