Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Box Scrapers

Posts

Box Scrapers

#1

Box Scrapers

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I've been making a lot of boxes lately. I've been using some straight and some round nosed scrapers in them. I haven't tried the scrapers sold as box scrapers. Are they a worthwhile investment? If you do use them which brand and size do you prefer?

Tom

Re: Box Scrapers

#2

Re: Box Scrapers

Joe Herrmann

>I would think that you can modify the scrapers you are currently using a lot cheaper than buying new ones. The most important modification in my opinion is to shapren the left side edge of the scraper, not just the front.

Joe

Re: Box Scrapers

#3

In addition to Joe

Jay in TX

>Sharpen your leading edge slightly out of perpendicular, 88 - 89 degrees instead of a 90 degree (square) edge. You're only focusing on finish cuts at the point of using the tool, so the added mass and rigidness, and less grinding are beneficial. A light touch/grind on the side of the tool is all that is needed at that point instead of resharpening both edges. Is that clear...?

Re: Box Scrapers

#4

Re: Box Scrapers

John Lucas

>I've been making a lot of boxes and goblets lately and what I like it a round nose scraper that's 1/4" thick or slightly more if the boxes are big. Follow Joe's advice of sharpening the left side as well as the front. I have started sharpening mine at about 80 degrees or slightly less. I feel I get less tearout but they do have to be sharpened a little more often. for that reason I hollow out most of the piece with a Bowl gouge layed over on it's side so the flute is at about 10 oclock. This varies with the way the wings are sharpened. After I hollow out most of the box I switch to the scraper to clean up the sides.

Re: Box Scrapers

#5

Re: Box Scrapers

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Thanks guys. I've been modifying some of my scrapers like that already. King Hieple is in our turning club and he showed me most of those things. I was wondering about the Kelton Box Scrapers and the ones with a relief area ground behind the left edge. I'm sharpening mine at about 80 or 85 deg. I use my 1" x 42" belt sander for that. I leave it set up with a Klingspor sharpening belt on it. I think it’s a 240-grit belt. I put a coarse blue zironia belt on it when I want to shape a tool. I don't have to change the setup on my 8-inch grinder as often that way. This forum and the local turning clubs sure are great resources.

Re: Box Scrapers

#6

Re: Box Scrapers

RonZ

>As Joe said, just modify a square scraper. I have a Sorby and a few others but they're just OK. I had a Ray Key one by Henry Taylor and it was OK until I took my course with Raffan. I personally found his the best. It's a regular square scraper, preferably thicker than usual, with a unique grind. The front is ground 70 deg and the side about 80deg. Keep in mind that he sharpened my tools all by hand/eye on the grinder and I'm now trying to interpret angles etc. So I can duplicate it. The top left with the top of the tool facing you is a sharp corner, and bows slightly up and then tapers down on the right slightly. In short, slightly rounded on top with bias to the left.My Ray key scraper is now ground this way and it has cut my box making time in half using Raffan's technique. If you don't understand what I said then I'll try and get a picture to you.

Re: Box Scrapers

#7

Re: Box Scrapers

RonZ

>BTW, on a 3" box for example, I'll clean out the middle to depth with the spindle gouge cutting away from the lathe at 2 o'clock. Once I have about an 1 1/2" hole down the middle, the above scraper is used to clean out the leftover mass to desired thickness and then the bottom and siides are touched lightly to clean any junk.

Re: Box Scrapers

#8

Re: Box Scrapers

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Thanks Ron! I'm pretty sure I'm following what you are describing. What width scraper do you find the most useful? I like making boxes and I think they are turning out pretty nice. I would like to refine my technique. Learning to make them a little quicker would be nice too! I finally practiced the Raffin technique of hollowing. I really struggled with it at first. Then all of a sudden I got the feel for it, and badda bing badda boom it works for me.

Re: Box Scrapers

#9

Re: Box Scrapers

John Lucas

>Don't know about Ron but my scrapers are about 3/4" wide and 1/4" thick. Except for my big bowl scraper which is about 2" wide and 1/2" thick. I don't use it for boxes though.

Re: Box Scrapers

#10

Re: Box Scrapers

RonZ

>The scraper I had at the course was 1/2" thick and 1" wide. The Ray Key that I converted is 1/4" thick which is fine, too. My preference goes to the thicker size to add stability. Also, a very important point is if you have the video, make sure you watch how he holds the scraper. The handle is tucked under the right arm so if there is a catch, you're in control. Up to a certain depth, it's quicker than finding a forstner, chucking it up and slowly drilling in being careful not to burn the wood.

Just wait until I get time to post my first hollow form Raffan showed me how to do. I used only a 1/4" bowl goug and one of is 1" bowl scrapers [gloat]. :-)

Re: Box Scrapers

#11

Re: Box Scrapers

Ron in Drums PA

>I use a half round scraper 1" x 3/8" thick

What I'd like to add is this:

I round over the bottom left edge of the scraper. There are times I will lift up the right side of the scraper while cutting.