Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

Posts

The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#1

The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Lots of nice new features on the lathe - but it still has the same retarded spindle lock as the current model. (for those of you unfamiliar - the "lock" is spring loaded and requires a hand to keep it in that position) A Powermatic engineer had the poor fortune of introducing himself as so to me at the AAW trade show last week. He appeared to truly never have heard of a single complaint about the lock, so I asked him to pretend to do a few things on the lathe that required a locked spindle and he soon realized that 3 hands were needed and that the lock was mostly worthless. We discussed the common means that woodturners employ to modify that crappy lock until he agreed that it was a significant drawback to such a fine machine. I also questioned the cast spindle lock collar that I hear of breaks occasitionally (mine did too). We agreed that a machined collar would be stronger but that the cast iron would break before spindle damage occured, probably.

I also talked him out of trying to market the threaded indexer (which I don't really like either) as a spindle lock as it takes about 30 seconds to screw the locking pin in, and then 30 more to get it out.

He was concerned about starting the motor with the lock in place, so I showed him what happened - you immediately heard the noise and pressed the stop button, lasts maybe a second, and the belt slips. No big deal. He seemed to be concerned about that anyway and said he could rig a stop circuit so the motor couldn't be turned on with the lock in place. OK, but will it ever show up in production? Who knows.

The spindle lock, in my opinion, is built poorly. It consists of a threaded hole on the inboard side of the spindle right next to where your faceplate or chuck will reside. It offers probably 6 positions, but I did not count, BUT, it is too close to the spindle to offer significant accuracy and the diameter of the spindle collar that the locking pin screws into is probably 3" in diameter, offering very few positions. But it is something we asked for and it does now exist.

If I bought the "B" model I would still be complaining about both issues (as I am now with the "A")

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#2

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

John Lucas

>Mike I thought the trap door in the tailstock was worth the purchase price.

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#3

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

Steven Roxberg

>Mike,

Thanks for your comments on the 3520B. It's a lathe I will seriously consider when I upgrade and your comments are excellent.

Luckily, I'll have to wait a year or more before upgrading so maybe the changes will be in place.

It was also nice getting to meet you at the show.

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#4

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Mike,

I'm turning on the General 26020 and the spindle lock is the same. Spring loaded. I'm assuming they did that for the same reason...so you don't accidentally start up with it locked. I often times use the indexer pin to lock my spindle if I need that "third" hand. Is this a no-no? Am I screwing up my indexer? I rarely use it for what it's designed for.

Jen

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#5

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

Joel Hunnicutt

>I always have done the same thing with my woodfast. I don't think it creates any problems, unless you have something really stuck on there. In that case, I break out the spindle wrenches.

Overall I really like my 3520. I argee the spindle lock and the lack of space between the headstock and the front of the spindle are it's worst features.

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#6

I agree Mike

Jay in TX

>Mike,

I agree but I had waited long enough for an upgrade. The story stick attachment is nice, as is the trap door John mentioned; neither was a deciding factor in my purchase. I couldn't rationalize in my own mind an additional 2 months wait time for initial production of the "b" as it will still be limited by the factors you mention. I've not needed indexing for my work yet; but as I see it, the machines that have the indexing function that I'd consider desirable are either too much for my budget or lack other features I based my decision on. Hopefully your chat with the engineer will be the harbinger of discussions with the design group leading to more desirable products for our successors.

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#7

I don't I can wait for the 3520C

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#8

Re: I don't THINK I can wait for the 3520C

Ron in Drums PA

>I'll leran this computer stuff soon!

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#9

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I don't see the spindle lock as a problem since the fix (removing the lower bolt) is so easy. The lower banjo is the feature I like best on the B.

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#10

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

Rick Allen

>Hi Jennifer

Most indexing plates for lathes are can be damaged by the forces you would use a spindle lock for. The good news is that the damage is to the indexing system in that the indexing hole used can become elongated if contiualy used as a spindle lock. If you don't do any indexing work then it doesn't matter.

General was aware of the practice of using the indexing pin as a lock. They have quite a beefy indexing system so you should be able to use it without any issues.

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#11

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

John Lucas

>Rick

I agree and dissagree. When I got my Nova Comet in doesn't have a spindle lock only indexing. I called the company and offered a suggestion. They had already adopted my suggestion because of others complaining about the potential weak point. They added a hex nut shape to the spindle so you could use a wrench. The chief engineer said that you would never break or wear out the indexing because of the pin size. Well I've had that lathe for about 8 years now and really put it through it's paces. I've never used the wrench. The spindle lock still works perfectly and when I changed bearings last year I inspected the holes and could not tell one from the other so none of them are elongated or damaged in any way.

I'm not saying you can't damage them or the pin but I've hogged on that thing a few times when a chuck would get stuck on the lathe.

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#12

Re: I agree Mike

Keith Newton

>My old PM had a 64 tooth indexing spindle lock that was spring down and rotate to lock up. 72 would have been a better number because it is divisible by more numbers.

I like your idea for the brake lever. I already use one of sorts that I clamp on with a hand-screw. I apply enough pressure that I can rotate it with both hands without loosening it.

I have put marks on the edge of my faceplate every 15* and have a removable pin that I insert for reading or indexing to those marks. This allows me to divide the work by 2,3, 4, 6, 8, 12, and 24 without stepping away from the work. If I need another number other than these which would fill in some of the missing numbers above like 9, 10, 15, 18, and 20 options, the arbor pully is a cogged 120 tooth 19" diameter. This drops my index down to 3*

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#13

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

Earl Eyre

>Gary said: "I don't see the spindle lock as a problem since the fix (removing the lower bolt) is so easy."

I must have missed something. I have a 3520A and solved the lock problem by drilling holes on either side of the button and slide a nail through it. But I haven't heard of removing the lower bolt? What does that do? It it's a better solution I'll do it.

Thanks,

Earl

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#14

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

Russ Fairfield

>Removing one screw, and loosening the other, allows the plate around the button to be rotated over the button to hold in IN

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

#15

Re: The new Powermatic 3520B (gripe)

Earl Eyre

>Thanks. That's too easy! LOL I'll try it.

Earl