Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

poplar cracking??

Posts

poplar cracking??

#1

poplar cracking??

DWFII

>I have some blondish wood that was represented to me as maple when I got it. The guy who told me it was maple is a tree trimmer/cutter but he's a little strange (although he's been spot on in identifying woods in the past)--"distracted" is perhaps the better word. but I'm beginning to think it isn't maple. (Wally Dickerman thought a finished bowl from this wood might be pine but there's no resinous smell when turning and I think the bark is wrong.)

In any case, it seems soft and easily tears when scraping. But worst of all, it seems to want to tear itself apart. I have cut rough blanks and sealed with liberal coats of anchorseal but everytime I look at the blanks (maybe a couple weeks apart) there seems to be a new crack even though I fill all cracks with thin CA. Bottom line is this stuff is probably the most unstable wood I've come across ( barring fruit woods).

Is poplar or cottonwood known for being unstable?

I know it's tough to idnetify wood without even a photo of the bark or leaves, much less the wood itself, but anyone have any ideas?

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: poplar cracking??

#2

Re: poplar cracking??

Roger Smith

>I do not know if I can help. However, cottonwood has a very distinct odor and is ultra-light (as in weight) compared to other woods. The cottonwood that I had turned was not bad to crack. I have never turned popular so I cannot answer about this. Most popular I have seen hsd a green tint in the heart wood.

Hope this helps.

roger

remove 29 for email

Re: poplar cracking??

#3

Re: poplar cracking??

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>In my experience poplar doesn't crack any worse than other woods. One thing to keep in mind is that green wood sealer is only a temporary solution to cracking. I try to rough out sealed pieces in 2 to 3 weeks or as soon as I see the blanks cracking thru the sealer. If you just happen to have way more blanks than you can get to I suggest you also place them in a plastic bag. They may mold but it should turn off.

Re: poplar cracking??

#4

Dick Hines

Re: poplar cracking??

Dick Hines

>Was thre a light green color to the wood? If so it was poplar. Poplar is also light when dry. And has a odor. Not a bad odor but one that is hard to forget.

Re: poplar cracking??

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: poplar cracking??

Brad Vietje

>I agree. I suspect the High Desert is a bigger factor than the species of wood.

Safe Spinning.

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: poplar cracking??

#6

Re: poplar cracking??

DWFII

>I didn't notice any gree whatsoever in the wood. But it does have a very slight...not bad but sort of "stale"...smell.

I have maple, locust, and apple that I have Anchorsealed and have not yet had the chance to turn into rough bowls. None are as bad as this stuff for cracking. In fact the locust and the maple are pretty stable.

I'll see if I can get a photo of the bark...will that help?

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon