Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

before and after critique

Posts

before and after critique

#1

before and after critique

ken chase

>I don't remember who critiqued this piece but the comments were

appreciated and I made changes in response to the criticism and

now post the before and after photos. Thanks again for the help


img

Re: before and after critique

#2

Re: before and after critique

john Lucas

>Ken

Much much better. I would still make the tip portion of the finial a little more graceful but that's a huge improvement over the old finial. Nice job.

Re: before and after critique

#3

Steven Antonucci

Try this experiment...

steve antonucci

>I agree with John that a more delicate finial would be appropriate, but I also think it might look better with a different shape. I covered the top of the finial, so that only the ball remained, and I think that it's more in scale with the size and shape of the form. Just imagine that the top of the finial is your ball, and not a point...

Steve

Re: before and after critique

#4

Re: thanks....will do!

ken chase

>