New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Need Advice on Chucks

Posts

Need Advice on Chucks

#1

Need Advice on Chucks

Don Emmerling

>I am planning to buy a new turning chuck and do not know which one is the best for bowl, box or hollow form work. I have looked at One Way chucks, Vicmark and Axeminster. Anyone have any ideas to break by deadlock here?

They all seem adequate.

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

#2

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

John Lucas

>Don

I have always wanted to try out an Axminster. They look great. I have used the oneways and they are very nice. I bought the Vicmarc primarily for 2 reasons. One was the extended mini jaw that they make. There's are very solid. The other was the use of a standard allen key. I know losing a chuck key is not a majoy problem but I just like the idea of being able to go to the local hardware to get a replacement chuck key if that becomes necessary.

Actually I bought the extended jaws for reverse turning bowls and the chuck key wouldn't work well. The T lever hit the jaws. I took an old hex key, cut it off and welded it to a longer rod. Made a handle and I have a key that works perfect for these jaws. I couldn't have done that with any of the other chucks.

I thought the closed back would keep out the dust and it does pretty good but after 5 years of use I had to take it apart and clean it. No big deal. With the Oneway you just blow out the back every so often.

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

#3

Re: Need Advice on Chucks *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>It depends on what you want to do.

The Oneway has the strongest grip.Best for bowls.

The Axminster has the best accuracy and repeatability. That makes it the best for boxws. It has the most accessory jaws, and it is also the most expensive.

The Vicmarc is a good compromise.

You can read more about my opinions on chucks at the link


http://www.woodcentral.com/russ/russ7.shtml

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

#4

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

Steve Lewis

>Don, I recently did what you are doing now and ended up buying the Vicmarc 3 1/2 Chuck. I have used a Oneway Talon on loan from a friend and chose the Vic over it. I believe the Vic is better built but I found that it doesnt hold large vessels as well as the Oneway with it's serrated jaws. Another problem I'm having with my Vic is that if you take your vessel out of the chuck and put it back in, it never lines back up (even after marking a line) and I have to keep adjusting the piece in the jaws. This problem i'm sure exists with any chuck, but it is easier to realign with the serrated jaws. If I were to buy again, I would buy the Oneway Stronghold. Don't overlook the new Grizzley Vicmarc copy for $89.00.

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

#5

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

Rick Allen

>Boxes are often made from 2x2 stock. As such the resultant tennon diameter is just at the closed position of the Oneway Stronghold jaws. The #1 jaws aren't suitable for a box.

The talon is smaller and the closed position of the Talon #2 jaws is smaller than a tennon turned from an undersized 2x2.

So for a good alpurpose chuck the Oneway Talon is a terrific choice and great for making boxes.

For hollow forms I prefer dovetail jaws as I find them to grip tighter the more you crank down on the key. I have found that you can over tighten the Oneway chuck with the serated jaws which will make for a less secure hold as you crank down harder and harder on the chuck key.

Think about the forces that the different jaws exert on a tennon of different sizes.

The Oneway jaws have a wider range of good griping power. The dovetail jaws have a stronger grip at particular tennon diameters.

Good luck

Richard

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

#6

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Don,

I would just look at the jaws available to each of the chucks you have selected, and select the one that has the range of jaws that you are most likely to use.

Mark

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

#7

I agree

CapeMayMike

>I have the Axminster 4" and that was the criteria that I used. It's served me well doing bowls and boxes.

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

#8

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

woodspinner/ Bill Hale

>I have Vics and a Nova and like them all. I do prefer the hex adj. key, only for replacement needs.

If not in a rush Technatool is working with Woodcraft to set up a deal to sell to AAW members at a reduced prices. This may hapen in a couple of monthes or less.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

#9

Re: Need Advice on Chucks

adrien

>'sfunny, John. I have several Vicmarc chucks. the blue-handled keys were fine for smaller stuff, but when I bought the extended jaws from Packard, he sent it with a red-handled key that was a bit longer and didn't have the problem you mention.