Re: Any Musicians? OT
Lloyd Johnson
>I'll add my $.02.
There's quite a bit to consider before making a choice of music software. First, what will be the input device(s). If a midi instrument such as a keyboard will be used, Band In A Box is a good, low-cost solution. Finale would also work well for either capturing midi instructions or entering them one-at-a-time on a music score. However, if there is a need to work with audio, where music will be captured in realtime with mics, an audio program such as Sound Forge is needed. The third option is very trendy right now and that is loop-based processors. This let's you take a library (and there are thousands of them, many free) of audio loops and use software such as Sony's Acid or Adobe's Audition that allows you to create an unlimited number of tracks containing repeating loops. The loop process let's you create songs at your keyboard without ever connecting to a midi device or microphone. Most of the music you hear on the radio today is loop-based. I hate it, but then my dad hated my music when he was my age. The last option that is used in conjunction with midi-based software is 'sample' software. When a note is played, a digitized audio sample of an instrument playing that note is sounded. I have done some orchestra work with samples that you would be hard-pressed to know if it was memorex or the real thing. Much of today's movie soundtracks are done using software samplers.
I mostly use Cakewalk Sonar which combines midi, audio, loops and samples in a single product. There are a few other packages that are similar to Sonar. These all-in-one solutions are extremely powerful and each company has both professional and hobby versions. It is great to have midi, audio, loops and samples available without having to switch programs. You'll find, though, that the audio portion isn't as good as Sound Forge, the looping not as good as Acid, and so on.
So the trick is to first decide the type of music to be created and the competency (both musically and technology) of the performer. A high schooler will probably be immediately attracted to looping which gives immediate results.
A little warning, though - Garage Band is very powerful and very easy to use. All of the PC software is very powerful.
One more warning - whatever you get will be just the starting point and unfortunately, there is no ending point - kinda like woodworking or woodturning. So be careful when going down this path. There's no way out.