Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

What do you think is the most important.....

Posts

What do you think is the most important.....

#1

What do you think is the most important.....

Terry Daniel

>feature of a lathe? Is it the power, the swing, the length? For me it is the banjo and toolrest. I hate it when the toolrest slips and the end strikes the edges of a nice burl. DAMHIKT! I'll take a poorly machined morse taper; I'll take a spindle that is threaded a bit wrong; I'll take a tailstock that doesn't lock solid; but I won't accept a toolrest that moves. What are your peeves?

TD

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#2

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

john Lucas

>I hate a tailstock that moves. My powermatic locks down solid but my old Nova 3000 did before I worked on it. My old Delta did and my old J-line. My Nova Comet has always locked solid. I have yet to use a Jet mini that didn't slip a little.

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Terry, My pet peave is poor engineering in general. I got into a Volvo SUV this morning, a vehicle I'm not used to. The upper corner of the door curves outward to a long point....I was looking down at the handle, the edge of the door hit me in the temple. You won't believe the bump on the side of my head. I would fire the moron who designed that thing instantly.

Many lathes have design flaws that could have easily been corrected before production. What may be acceptable in a mini lathe, such as a tailstock or banjo that creeps, should never be encountered in a big expensive machine.

My General needs more vertical movement in the tool rest....why this problem persists on these machines is beyond me. I KNOW they are aware of the problem. How long will it take before they address such a minor thing? (I am actually very pleased with the lathe otherwise)

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#4

The best thing about my lathe..

Mike Schwing from Md.

>hands down, the best single feature of my lathe is the automated voice that warns me when I have failed to lock down the banjo and turn on the power. Thank goodness for that little feature, or I would have, countless times, started working only to have the toolrest slip into the workpiece. I only wish they could add it to the tailstock.

Probably the most frustrating thing about that POS Delta 1440 I had was the banjo. It required a hammer blow or two to keep it in place.

Aside from things that don't slip, stability is my most desired feature.

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#5

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

john Lucas

>One of the things they lost when the Powermatic 2035 was moved to Tiawan was a tool rest lock that worked. In the earliest models they had a brass bar that was pushed by the tool rest locking screw. this worked great. Unfortunately in that model they made the locking screws hollow with a brass pin and spring in them. Heavy handed people kept breaking them off so they changed to the lever they have now. It worked great but when the 2035A came out they had removed the brass locking plate. Bummer. Just too much expense to manufacture I guess.

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#6

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Since I simply expect power and spot-on alignment in a big ($) lathe, I think the critical area is the tool holder and bed complex of parts. It's not enough to have the banjo stay put, it must also move easily and accurately when "asked", and the holder must lock the tool rest where I put it. I look for real beef in the tool holder and its parts and in bed with accuracy and consistency in milling both the top and under side of the bed and the banjo. Put a post in the holder and see if that shaft is a dead-nuts 90 to the bed when the banjo's locked down. Cheezy toolrest holders and bed flex is an obvious major source for vibration in the cut.

M

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#7

Tailstock lock

Jorge Castaneda

>John,

How did you fix that?, it is one of my gripes about the Nova 3000, the banjo does not lock solid either and the belt pulleys creep...

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#8

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

JamieDonaldson

>Keith- General has really missed the boat on several changes that would have made a very good lathe even better. Rude Osolnik sawed off the bed to make a shortbed 260 many years ago, and General could have produced a similar bowl lathe to a whole new market! I guess they're stuck in their old molds.

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#9

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

Denis Lalonde

>Tailstock lock is probably the most aggravating thing on my General 260, otherwise a good lathe..

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

Brad Vietje

>I'm with Keith, as usual. (And sorry aboout the bonk to the head -- that's Ford for you ! When they bought Volvo you could be sure the Q.C. would drop. I've owned 5 Volvo wagons, and have nearly a milion miles of Volvo driving on the three in the yard now.)

As for lathes, overall fit and finish and quality control do cost more, but I think many turners would appreciate the difference. On a beginner's, or entry-level lathe, we have come to expect a little slop in the machining, but the manufacturers could offer a premium version of each model at $50.00 more for those who cared, or just increase the overall quality of all the machines, and raise the price of each unit $25.00 or so.

I'd agree that beyond overall machining tolerances, the locking mechanisms (both banjo and tailstock) are the most aggrivating and dangerous shortcomings of popular lathes. I've ruined enough eggshell-thin pieces, and damaged enough bark edges due to sudden lurching motions of the poorly-machined banjo, (read: AAARRRGGHH!!!) that I realize I'm fighting a losing battle with a run-of-the-mill Jet 1236 (with a not-quite flat banjo, and not-quite parallel bed top and bottom), and need to get a more precise lathe as soon as I can afford one.

I would be really aggrivated to find these shortcomings on a high end, professional quality machine, and will not tolerate these shortcomings on my next lathe.

Safe spinning (and commuting !)

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#11

Steven Antonucci

I'd just about knocked myself out on a 99 Intrepid

steve antonucci

>I thought it was just me!

The corner of the door has not only caught me in he head, but in the shoulder, which made my arm go numb. Sorry to hear it happened to you, glad to see I'm not just a big dummy...

As far as lathes go, I hate the following engineering "faux pas":

1.) Pivoting head lathes (like my Nova) that do not automatically realign after pivoting the head. If you make a pivot lathe, add a double ended morse taper to the kit.

2.) "Fixed" handles. No matter what, I end up getting jabbed in areas I'd rather not be jabbed. How hard would it be to have some kind of quick release (like a bicycle wheel?)?

I could go on, but you're all probably bored by now...

Steve

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#12

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

Bill Crommett

>The biggest gripe I have with my General is the course threads on the tool post lock. Why they couldn't use a fine thread that would alow tightening the tool post without banging the locking handle with the tool at hand ?

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#13

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

Bill Crommett

>Dennis: I had the same problem with the tailstock until I took a hint from one of David Ellsworths videos and let the locking plate under the ways get a little rusty along with what Ellsworth calls "a nice patina" on the ways.

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#14

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)

>The short answer is "whatever is bugging about my current lathe". If I wanted to do vacuum chucking, a solid spindle would bug the heck out of me.

In general, we should demand good workmanship, quality control and design features so that the tool functions properly. On a table saw, the fence, the miter slot, and the blade better be perfectly parallel, otherwise it is not worth buying at any price. For a lathe, vibration must be minimal, the centers must line up along the length of the bed, the cams must lock, and must allow easy movement when unlocked. Otherwise, it is just taking up space in my overcrowded shop. All of the other features of "special" lathes such as swing, power, mass, variable speed motors, length of bed, etc are features for which we pay extra.

The long answer to the question is "it depends on the purpose of the lathe". The most important feature of my bowl lathe (Vega 2400) is power and swing. For everything else I turn, the ease and smoothness of speed control is most important since I quickly transistion from turning (fairly high speed) to sanding (at a much slower speed), to applying finish (first at a very low speed then at high speed ot buff). Again this is assuming the lathe (my Nova 3K) is properly set up so that it is in alignment, has good (excess) power, and is vibration free.

My $0.02

John

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#15

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

David Galloway

>This has been a very interesting thread. I have an old PM3520(0003) and the tailstock has become ornery through the years. It does not have a hole through the quill and so it requires "busting" out the fitting with a roughing gouge. It drives me crazy.

Also I demand that the banjo move quickly and locks down securely. I have tweeked mine, with Elsworth's help, and now don't think much about it.

Terry thanks for the thread!

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#16

I like everything about my Oneway 1640.

Barbara Gill, RemlikVA

>There is nothing I would change. My pet peeve with my Nova 3000 was the tailstock. It was underbuilt and would not stay in alignment.

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#17

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

Barry Turner

>For me, it's things that are out of character. Quality that does not measure up to the price paid. Things that don't fit. Not literally, but design-wise. For instance: a tailstock handwheel that looks like it belongs on a lathe selling for several hundred dollars less, castings that are not well-machined and smoothed before painting, levers and knobs that are obviously of poor quality, too many plastic parts. I'm much more likely to cull a lathe or other machinery because of poor fit and finish, than for other perhaps more important reasons. Just because you pay high dollar doesn't always mean you get good design. A certain high-end lathe has a very poor layout of locking levers for the banjo and toolrest locking. They bump into each other. Poor design that detracts from an otherwise excellent machine.

No matter what I buy, whether it's a claw hammer or a lathe, it has to "feel right"in my hands. (Drives my wife nuts.) If it doesn't feel right, I'm not going to use it. Sometimes you regret spending too much. You never regret buying higher quality.

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#18

Oh, Those Beloved Intrepids

Barry Turner

>You touched a nerve! I have to drive one of those SOB's to Frankfort on Monday and again on Tuesday next week. I find these vehicles extremely difficult to get into and once I'm in I can't get out. And I bump my head on the damned window sill! Thank goodness it's a company car or I would call the tow truck and have it hauled to the salvage yard.

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#19

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

Barry Turner

>A friend of mine bought a Grizzly 3 HP shaper a few years ago. Overall, he was pleased, but didn't stop until he had replaced every threaded knob on it. He said the threads were rough and obviously of poor quality. It was a minor thing, but it drove him nuts!

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#20

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

echo8287

>My biggest complaint with anything that is designed is>>>>>>>>>>>>>Make the person or persons that designed it, use it for a month for the purpose it was intended. This includes installing it,working with it,watching it work,using the written (so called)instructions that come with it, etc. If manufacturers used this simple principle everyone would benefit greatly. I see some of the biggest pieces of crap(no pun intended) from the plumbing products I have to install these days than ever before. What is bad is that some companies will take a product that is an excellant product and because of cost saving reduce it to junk to compete. This goes for many products. It won't be long before I have to get out of the plumbing business, because I cannot guarantee a single decent product.David

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#21

Re: I like everything about my Oneway 1640.

Carole in VA

>Barb, do you happen to know if that has been corrected on the new Nova DVRs?

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#22

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

Ruth Niles

>Jamie,

After the problems I had with my first General (reeves drive, yuk!), and calling General in Canada so often, I asked "why haven't you" regarding a few minor improvements. They indicated they sell so many lathes to schools and for commercial use that making changes just for hobby turners really isn't cost effective right now. That doesn't mean they won't eventually "see the light"!

Ruth

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#23

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

vicmarc.fan

>I think the most important thing about my Vicmarc VL300 is the massive use of cast iron and the wide stance. I used to judge speed by holding one hand on the bed and increasing speed until I felt vibration.

This lathe is so rock solid it is scarry how fast it will turn without vibration on a big out of balance chunk of wood.

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#24

Re: I like everything about my Oneway 1640.

Barry Irby

>Carole, I have a Nova DVR and someone said to me, "they used to have a crappy tail stock that wouldn't stay in alignment and wouldn't stay in place, but they fixed it." I have no idea what they did to fix it or even if they did, but mine seems fine.

I do wish the banjo was a little sturdier. It's fairly long because the lathe will turn 16 inch bowls, and it's fairly light, so it moves easily when I want it to, but sometimes when I core a big heavy blank, it wants to walk a little. OTOH on some of the even bigger lathes the tail stock and banjo are so heavy they are a nuisance. One of our club members had Oneway make him an aluminum banjo. I was scared to ask what that cost.

Be happy for you to turn on mine anytime, but it's a long ride. Have you thought about buying a reconditioned one from Tim Geist, the rep for the company in West Virgina? I think you save a third or half. He has refurbished chucks, too.

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

#25

Re: What do you think is the most important.....

Tim Grenville-Cleave

>Well said Barry ... In my poor and humble opinion "you gets what you pays for" Quality is not cheap! I bought a Hegner HDB200XL (German Manufacturer) Castings are good quality and heavy enough for the lathe, welding is very good, all things that are supposed to lock do so and stay locked. Perhaps my only gripe is power ... standard is 3/4hp upgrade is 1hp (3 phase motor running on a 13A 240V supply, If you haven't already guessed I am in the UK) Yet the Lathe has the capacity to turn a 15in bowl before swinging the headstock !!! and a 39in capacity for spindles etc. All that said ... the speed controller is exellent 0 - 3000rpm in three stages.

Wow just thinking about a log ... 15"dia 39"long spinning at 3000rpm thats going to be one hell of a pen!!

For build quality and finish I would put my Hegner up against anything and will give the top end lathes a run for their money!!

(I do not want to be responsible for starting another Colonial war, so I shall now shut up !!) To the community as a whole thanks for so much ... tips, hints and inspiration!! Long may you all continue to turn and teach