Design development
JamieDonaldson
>I wonder how many WC turners practice design development by actually working out the bugs with waste turnings? This is a subject I will be discussing during my "Bowls from Logs" demo at AAW Symposium next week.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Design development
JamieDonaldson
>I wonder how many WC turners practice design development by actually working out the bugs with waste turnings? This is a subject I will be discussing during my "Bowls from Logs" demo at AAW Symposium next week.
Re: Design development
JamieDonaldson
>Here is the Mk II version- Evolution. Still have more to work out, but making improvements.
Re: Design development
Keith Tompkins
>HI Jamie! This question is right up my alley!!!!! In fact I've been doing a similar demo, and teach similar methods in my classes. There are several things I do before I produce a piece. First I usually make a rough sketch of an idea before I forget it. Later, I will refine the drawing.....I make miniature examples of the finished product, these mini's are known as maquettes. These enable my to visualize how elements within the turning may work together, and I am able to quickly make another to observe the result of subtle differences. Most of the things I've posted on WC were my maquettes that I went ahead and finished. This appears to be exactly the approach you are taking.
Another thing I do is to make a clay model. This works well on something like my rose pieces.....It helps to visualize overall composition, the relationship of each component to the others, such as base, stem and the blossom. If one of my drawings pleases me a great deal, I may make a cardboard template in order to duplicate it precisely...a hollow form would be a good example.
Your concept would also work well for those making hollow forms with finials.....the finial (always) seems too big and unrefined. Making a few examples and seeing how they look would be a great design aid.
Good luck with the demo....btw, neat pieces!
You two Rock
tek-Brunswick, Ohio
>I'm finally getting to the point where I'm actually planning what I turn. In the beginning I would chuck a chunk of wood up and see what the biggest thing I could get out of it was. Now I'm starting to draw what I want to turn. I've done some practice pieces, but they weren’t meant to be practice when I started on them. Please keep throwing up design ideas and techniques! They really help!
Tom
Re: Design development
Jim Pugh, Ohio
>Jaimie,
One of the things that need to be considered, and I am sure both you and Keith do....is to figure how the wood is going to be chucked during each step. Once I have an idea in mind, I sketch each step of the process and look at how I can hold it each time. That prevents me from getting to step 3 and having no way to hold step 4. DAMHIK.
Re: Design development
John Lucas
>Jamie I started doing this years ago because I couldn't afford to waste a good piece of wood so I would put scrap on and test it out. I didn't do that one day on a big piece of holly and blew it up trying to hollow through an off center neck. Now I run test pieces a lot.
I find it really beneficial for insidep-out turning because it's difficult to see how the shapes will affect the 2 planes that intersect. I'll glue up some 2x4 pine and test the shape to see if it will work.
For my art pieces I usually will make some sort of macquette out of styrafoam, cardboard, pipe cleaners etc just to get an idea of how the sizes and proportions of the piece will work. I don't always do this but when I do, the final results are almost always better.
Sounds like you and Keith are doing some great demo's. I wasn't pleased with my last demo on design. It needs lots of work but then that's why I'm here listening and learning.
Re: Design development
Joe Flemig
>Jamie,
I do this occasionally. I go through all the steps with scrap unitl I have the process figured out. I've got myself down dead ends a couple of times, but then I just wasted a 2 x 4 or whatever.
One thing to keep in mind is that some woods will work well with some tools, but not others. I sometimes plan to scrape a piece knowing that I'm turning a very dense wood at the final. However, scraping will not work on the scrap piece. Always need to keep in mind the techniques needed on the intended wood including sanding and finishing.
Joe Fleming - San Diego