New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Need some advice on this one

Posts

Need some advice on this one

#1

Need some advice on this one

Bruce Wiseman

>Hi,

I haven't been doing bowls all that long and this is something I haven't seen before. This is some quarter sawn Sycamore that I was turning. It has these open areas near the end grain simular to worm holes but doesn't quite look like them. I thought that going deeper might remove them but it seems the deeper I go the more of them I expose. Is this going to be a design feature or is there something I can do about this?


img

Re: Need some advice on this one

#2

Steven Antonucci

Looks like some kind of bug damage for sure.

steve antonucci

>choises as I see it:

1.) Superglue the "stuff" inside the holes

2.) pick it out and leave it "natural"

3.) pick it out and fill it with epoxy and stone (or metal or whatever...)

Personally, I'd probably do #1 or #2- #1 if there weren't that many (which is what it looks like) or #2 if there were lots...

Steve

Re: Need some advice on this one

#3

Re: Need some advice on this one

Les Robison

>It looks like you have a design feature in the works. If the material in the places that show in your photo are soft and punky, you could dig them out and fill with coffee grounds. Or, you could apply CA to make them solid. If you go the CA route, be sure you seal the wood first to avoid staining the light colored wood with the CA. I think the work of mother nature only adds substancially to the work of man.

Good Luck and let us see the finished product.

Re: Need some advice on this one

#4

Re: Need some advice on this one

adrien

>If the light-colored areas are filled with a sawdust-like material, that is "frass" the end result of insect tunneling. For some ist's a feature, not a flaw.

Re: Need some advice on this one

#5

Re: Need some advice on this one

Barry Turner

>I say it's a design feature...........you'd never be able to plug all those little holes without them looking like plugged holes.

Re: Need some advice on this one

#6

Re: I agree with Adrien; Frass.

Al Crandall --NE of Indy--

>I've seen that a lot. Usually it is rather firm and won't fall out. An oil finish will usually insure that it stays in place.

Re: Need some advice on this one

#7

Re: Need some advice on this one

Norm Smith

>Hi Bruce,

I like to clean out the holes and just finish as is.

Norm

Re: Need some advice on this one

#8

One man's trash.....

Barry Irby

>is another man's treasure. Someone will be asking you where you got it and how did you make that happen, or where can they get some and which way do you turn it to highlight it.

It's frass, sawdust and bug poop left behind by some tunneling insect. If it's dense as it appears to be the finish will hold it in place. You could apply the first coat or two and then soak any that appears loose with thin CA. This is now an art bowl more than a working bowl.

Re: Need some advice on this one

#9

Try filing them

Dominic Greco in Richboro, PA

>Bruce,

As the others have suggested, filling the holes seems like a good idea. Some people use sawdust and CA glue. While some use coffee grounds. With a light-ish wood like sycamore, I think I might use a "filler" with a color that compliments the wood.

While recently turning a dogwood bowl, I discovered it had a series of carpenter ant holes throughout it. Some were filled with the same kind of "residue" your seeing, and some were clean. I decided to fill them and use them as a design feature.

For the holes that had the residue in them, I used a Dremel and a ball point bit to clean them out. I then filled the hole up 90% with sawdust and thin CA Glue. The rest of the hole got a layer of powered turquoise.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Need some advice on this one

#10

Re: Need some advice on this one

leedale

>Bruce.. Got some pecan that that worms carved on, the larvae left beautifull coloring. I picked out the soft material with dental tools leaving the holes natural and open. All I have left are pictures, the pieces sold as fast as I turned them out. There was a tremendous number of holes, took as long to clean them up as it did to do the hollow forms. I am out of town and do not have a picture to post but I liked them...Lee

Re: Need some advice on this one

#11

Re: Zapp to kill the eggs?

Keith Newton

>Do any of you worry about bringing powder post beetle into yours or someone elses home? You can not kill them by treating the footings like termites.

Is there a risk of having them taking up residence in the framing of your house?

If you don't do anything to kill them, there could be some still living in there.

Re: Need some advice on this one

#12

Re: Need some advice on this one

John K Jordan

>I dig the frass out with a dental pick and wire brush and leave the tunnels unfilled. They look pretty cool. The only problems I've had were with thin spindles where a tunnel weakened the wood and cause it to break or in finger tops where they caused imbalance.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Need some advice on this one

#13

Re: Zapp to kill the eggs?

John K Jordan

>>Is there a risk of having them taking up residence

>in the framing of your house?

I don't know, but I think they look for certain wood conditions, such as wet wood. I watched a swarm once in front of my garage when processing green woood for turning. I had cut a number of blanks and put what I couldn't process into a wheelbarrow over night and covered with some plastic to slow the drying. It rained and the blocks were sitting in a few inches of water the next day. While working on a big pile of these, I noticed tiny black flying insects all around. I watched them land on the wet maple and immediately start boring little tunnels! It was fascinating. I sprayed the surfaces and the next day found dead beetles in half-bored holes and no completed tunnels. I saw no beetles landing on other green and dry wood I had in the same area and found no tell-tale holes with later inspection. I think they were attracted to the smell of the wet maple. Could different species or colonies be attracted to different types of wood?

I had a previous experience - I brought some old walnut blanks into my shop that had been in the weather for years. Many were rotted and disgarded, but some looked sound enough for practice work. One day, I noticed a hole in the end grain where a beetle was emerging. It sounds crazy, but I thought I had heard a little scratching noise and was investigating when I saw the bug! I removed the wood and kept an eye on things and found no other signs of beetles.

I suspect there are millions of powerpost beetles in every patch of woods helping the termites clean up fallen trees. If they were a real threat to dry structural wood I think we would see constant evidence.

BTW, speaking of termites - they are not just a threat to the house! They are evidently attracted to warmth in cold weather and twice have eaten into and shorted the high voltage lines (7200v) leading into the transformer that sits on a concrete pad in my woods behind the house. Both times, once before and once after I moved here, it took the power out and required a repair. I cleaned up the leaves and forest debris around the transformer and treated the ground to discourage them.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Need some advice on this one

#14

Re: Zapp to kill the eggs?

Gary Evans, Tallassee TN

>Keith,

What we're looking at here are not powder post beetles. Like John says, PBB's are tiny little guys. These tunnels are the result of a much larger beetle or other insect.

That said, I don't think there is much danger of infestation of your house or other lumber from turning wood that may have a few bugs in residence. The bugs that are found in turning wood are the ones that prefer high moisture content. The folks that trumpet the dangers of wood boring insects or termites tend to be the ones who make their money from getting rid of them. It's called marketing.

Gary

Re: Need some advice on this one

#15

Re: Need some advice on this one

Bob R

>LOOKS BANDD , LOOKS GOOD. Put in the Micro wave and the clean them out or seal then in. I thing it will look great.

To be safe send it to me. I will take care of your PROBLEMS.

GOOD LUCK Bob R West Mac Turning

Re: Need some advice on this one

#16

Re: Need some advice on this one

Gil Mitchell

>clean them out with copressed air. dust mask and safty glass are a must.

Re: Need some advice on this one

#17

Re: thanks for advice and a furthe redesign

Bruce Wiseman

>Thanks everyone for your advice and ideas. "Those the bowl goods would punish, first they make arrogant." The wood felt stable and I thought how cool it would be to turn this guy real thin and be able to see light through those holes. Well you guessed it, I made an NON captive ring out of the top part of the bowl. I think I can clean up the base and maybe make a small plate of sorts out of whats left.

Re: Need some advice on this one

#18

Re: thanks for advice and a furthe redesign

John K Jordan

>>"Those the bowl goods would punish, first they make arrogant."

They must hang out with the spindle gods. Last night I broke three in a row. "Use this nice strong wood with straight grain for that long thin spindle," said the voice of reason. "But this is such a beautiful burl, pay no attention to that unskilled wimp," countered the voice of stupidity.

JKJ in East TN