New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Or..improving by NOT practicing

Posts

Or..improving by NOT practicing

#1

Or..improving by NOT practicing

Mike Schwing from Md.

>As a contrast to Keith's post about practice making perfect, (not to say that any of that is incorrect!), I have some contrary evidence from life experiences that have convinced me that some skills actually improve while we are NOT practicing them. I'm curious to know if anyone else shares this.

I know in my heart that when I take a few months off from swimming, upon returning, my stroke has improved! Without doubt, it seems as if my brain has been practicing while I have not. The first few thousand yards in the pool are always amazing to me in that regard. My wife claims to have experienced the same thing.

I can claim the same experience with water skiing, as well was with bowl turning. After a few months of carving with no real turning time, I can return to the lathe and notice that my hands have somehow become more adept at working the gouge than they were before the break. It is almost as if they're working on their own, showing off for me at what they've been doing while I was working on other things. Same thing with the hollowing tools! I can with all honesty say that I'm a much better turner now than I was before I stopped turning in order to do months of carving and painting. It is one of the more amazing things about being human that I have noticed.

Anyone else?

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#2

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

Ed Kelle

>Yup, that has happened to me also. Mostly with sports, basketball and hockey. Though I just got back doing a little cycling after 2 years and this definitely does NOT apply. hufff... pufff...

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#3

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Mike,

This is a quite common occurance with any activity that is based on "Muscle Memory".

In my former life, I was a member of the U.S. International Shooting Team. I was quite common for someone to come back from a week or two off, and have a personal best result on the first day back. I have also had it happen when I was really tired.

Simply put, the reason this happens, is that assuming that you do things right most of the time, your muscles forget the mistakes and do what naturally what they have been doing right most of the time. I.e. you are on Autopilot.

The trouble usually comes the next day when we concentrate really hard to try an duplicate the great result from the day before - your mind gets in the way and short circuits the autopilot.

Mark

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#4

It's motor memory

Clem Wixted

>Mark is right, again!

Motor memory is very strong. That's why you don't forget how to ride a bike. (Conditioning is another matter :-))

My first time playing golf after a long layoff, I do pretty well (at least the first few holes). It's when I concentrate that I goof up.

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#5

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)

>It is not just motor skills that get a boost from a break; your mind (creativity, ability to focus, etc) also receives benefits from a little down time. I think we have all experienced the situation where we come up with a solution to a problem when we are NOT thinking about it. It has been know for decades that "all work and no play makes Jack a dull boy". "Dull" doesn't refer to his inability to entertain himself, but rather it refers to his mental and physical shape. As in, "not sharp". You don't think corporate America would allow us to keep "paid vacations" if there was not a benefit for them do you?

John

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#6

Re: So . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>If I take a year off from turning, when I come back my bowls will equal Stockdale's, and my hollow forms, Ellsworth's?

Hmmmmmm. Don't think that's gonna work for me, especially for somebody for whom swimming = "staying alive when in water" and the broad side of the barn makes a good target only from the inside with a shotgun.

|;-}}}}}

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#7

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

John K Jordan

>Same with piano playing, as long as the recess isn't TOO long! For me, the creative part (improvization) usually improves with a break. However, the very difficult technical moves get rusty, especially if the break is extended.

BTW, the muscles seem to never forget even if the brain forgets. There are some things I can play as long as I don't try to think too much about them.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#8

Re: So . .

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>It will only work if you were turning somewhat near Stockdale or Ellisworth levels before the break.

Mark

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: So . .. I'm an expert at a LOT of things !

Brad Vietje

>That's just great news ! WOW, this changes my whole outlook on life ... I ought to be a certified expert at a whole range of things like paragliding, Indy car racing, cardiac surgery, and even aircraft design -- heck, I haven't practiced those things at ALL !

Only problem is that I'm only an expert until I actually TRY one of those things -- then I'm right down there at the bottom with the other beginners.

So THAT's why most know-it-all's actually know nothing at all...

Safe Spinning ; )

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#10

sort of

Shawn - in ID

>As everyone is demonstrating, there is a lot of anecdotal evidence for this 'phenomenon'. So, go figure, there has been a good body of classic research into it as well. The results, in a nutshell, are that you are 1) forgetting bad habits that were developing (hopefully before they become ingrained) and 2) more focused, refreshed and happier being back (i.e., you perceive yourself as having more enjoyment after a layoff and therefore tend to be more focused and thus perform better). While that all sounds good, the down side for extremely high level performance (e.g., sport performance) is that there was something wrong in the training program to require a layoff to 'bring you back'. When training/practice programs are designed optimally, those who do not take the layoff (but have the more tuned program of training) will be significantly further along (and enjoying things even more) than those who take time off and feel what you are describing. So, well designed practice makes 'perfect', but less well designed practice makes for diminishing returns and/or the need for a layoff.

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#11

Re: Sheesh . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Everybody's a critic.

So you mean that a little (time off) is good, but more's not even better? See, I figured it'd take about a year of intensive abstinence . . .

M

|;-}

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#12

Re: So . .. I'm an expert at a LOT of things !

Russ Fairfield

>As an old jazz piano player, I know for a fact that the music got better, and my improvisation got better as the night wore on and the quantity of alcohol became greater.

If I can become a better woodturner by sitting and watching TV, I can become even better with a few martinis.

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#13

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

Raymond Overman in SC

>Mike,

As others have noted, muscle memory. I know that when I was weight training in my younger years I went on a cycle of 12 weeks on / 2 weeks off. When I came back on the cyle I'd be able to lift almost as much as I did when I stopped. Within a week or two I had usually surpassed that previous personal record and would continue increasing throughout the cycle.

Unfortunately my lifestyle dictates when I'm taking time off from my woodturning and not a set schedule. When I was weight training I was young and single and didn't have to schedule / ask permission to go to the gym. That's not the case now for my woodturning but I'm happy to sacrifice for the rewards I get from my wife and little girl.

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#14

Re: So . .. I'm an expert at a LOT of things !

Jim D.

>Yo Brad! Careful, I represent that remark!

Jim D.

"Only problem is that I'm only an expert until I actually TRY one of those things -- then I'm right down there at the bottom with the other beginners.

So THAT's why most know-it-all's actually know nothing at all... "

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#15

another view

woodspinner/ Bill Hale

>Practice does not make perfect it makes permenant. If your skills are not good practice will not be the best even with a lapse of time

Bil

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#16

Re: another view

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>We used to say "Practice does not make perfect - only perfect practice makes perfect". In other words, you can get pretty darn good at doing something wrong if you practice it long enough.

Mark

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#17

Joe Fleming

Re: So . .. I'm an expert at a LOT of things !

Joe Fleming

>Russ,

I'm always better after a few drinks. Just ask me. :-)

Joe Fleming - San Diego

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#18

Re: another view

Raymond Overman in SC

>Along those lines, you can use a skew chisel to hollow end grain if you're persistent enough and don't know better but I wouldn't suggest it. DAMHIKT.

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Or..improving by NOT practicing

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Mike, You are right, sorta. Even though you may take a break, you go back to something you are familiar with. Something you already know how to do. The break allows you to come back fresh. There are times when I can't seem to do anything right.....I'd be better off doing something else.

The next day, I'll be back to normal again. However, what I'm really referring to is practicing something that you're NOT too good at. Say you learn a skew technique in a classroom setting. If you don't practice at least a small amount each day, you may lose the ability to use the technique, or never gain the confidence to try it on an actual piece.

A good example....a student only used scrapers for his bowls...after a two day class, he was pretty good with the bowl gouge. When I ran into him some time later, I asked how his turning was going. He was having a few problems with the gouge(didn't practice), and had reverted back to scrapers.(not a criticism)

Another example....a student in a spindle class was spending 45 minutes on each bottle stopper he produced; a major problem since he was selling them on the craft circuit. His technique was causing tearout on the end-grain portion of his pieces, requiring lots of sanding. I showed him a skew technique as a way to minimize sanding. His recent stoppers...under three minutes.