New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Grinding Wheel Selection

Posts

Grinding Wheel Selection

#1

Grinding Wheel Selection

DaveL

>First i want to thank Mr Tindall for his latest articles on Grinding Wheel Slection and evaluation. I wrote a tool sharpening lesson for our woodturning club about 6 months ago and i was amazed at the lack of information available about grinding wheels and picking the right one for sharpening HSS.

While researching the subject I visited the Norton and Radiac websites and both sites state that the wheel speed is a determining factor in selection of the wheel hardness. Unfortunaltly there does not seem to be any guidance stating which hardnesses should be used for different speed grinders.

1. Can someone explain the relationship between wheel speed and hardness of the wheel bond and how to select the proper wheel for a specific speed grinder?

2. Has anyone performed testing of grinding wheels on slow speed grinders?

Thank You,

Dave

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

#2

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

Mark Kauder. Phenix City, AL

>Dave,

The speed of the wheel and the hardness of the wheel have no relationship. The relationship is between the hardness of the wheel and the hardness of the steel. The harder the steel, the softer the wheel you need.

Carbon steel (hand chistles and hand plane blades) will do well with a harder wheel, but need caution (and a slower speed)to keep from burning/de-tempering.

HHS used in most turning tools need a softer wheel - normally in the H-K grading range.

Mark

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

#3

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

Paul Porter in Phoenix, AZ

>Dave,

Oneway makes grinding wheels for both fast and slow speed grinders. You ask them what the difference is.

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

#4

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

Kevin Clay

>Grinding speed and wheel hardness should be related. The faster a grinding wheel goes the harder it behaves. Think of a buffing wheel to understand how this happens. If you have a wheel that you like and you are using it on a high speed grinder, it will behave softer on a slow grinder. It will also behave differently if you use a smaller grinder as obviously smaller wheels have lower surface speeds. Since grinding wheel hardness in hand grinding operations is purely subjective it is impossible to say what everyone will like. Our grinding wheels get harder if they are designed for slower speeds.

As far as I know nobody has really studied grinding wheel behavior for hand grinding as hand grinding is not exactly a repeatable phenomonom. We have done a little bit of testing regarding wheel speed and the temperature that the tool gets and wheel speed makes suprisingly little difference. If you think about it though it makes sense. A slow speed grinder takes twice as long to remove the same amount of material so you have twice as long to put the heat into the tool. The biggest factor to keeping a tool cool is to keep the wheels properly dressed.

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

#5

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Thanks Kevin.

ref your last statment: I assume by dressed you mean keeping it un-clogged with metal/debris. Keeping it true and flat should have no real effect on keeping the metal cool.

Mark

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

#6

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

Kevin Clay

>Right that's exactly what I meant. Just fyi dressing actually refers only to the operation performed on the face of a wheel that improves its cutting action. Trueing is what makes the wheel round and flat. Both terms have become pretty interchangeable even thought they have different meanings.

regards

Kevin Clay

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

#7

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

DaveL

>Kevin,

Thanks for the info. After reading your explanation i assume that the wheel speed also effects the wheels friability exactly opposite of its effect on hardness. That being said do you feel it is more important to select a wheel based on hardness or friability?

Thanks again,

Dave

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

#8

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

Kevin Clay

>Hardness and friability are the same thing.

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

#9

Re: Grinding Wheel Selection

DaveL

>Thanks

Dave