New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Walnut Bowl Problem

Posts

Walnut Bowl Problem

#1

Walnut Bowl Problem

Barry Turner

>I have just turned a small Black Walnut bowl. It's a twice-turned bowl, hollowed about 5 or 6 months ago. It's about 5" tall and about 6" in diameter. On opposite sides of the bowl where there is end grain, and also on the inside of the bowl where there is end grain, I have what appears to be tear-out. I used a very sharp bowl gouge to shape the bowl and hollow it. I cleaned up the gouge marks with a sharp scraper. I power sanded through the grits, starting with 80 all the way to 180 grit. I even stopped in the middle of the sanding process and raised the grain, let it dry overnight and started the sanding process again at 120 grit, sanding through 180 again. Still the areas of what appears to be tear-out persist. Any ideas, other than to stay away from Black Walnut?

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#2

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

John K Jordan

>There was a thread on this, although not specifically with walnut, on July 1, "Bowl turning and tear out question".

I've seen that with walnut that wasn't dry. Are you sure it is dry enough?

JKJ in East TN

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#3

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

Barry Turner

>No, I'm not sure, but I rough turned it about 4 or 5 months ago, put it in a paper bag and forgot it. It seemed pretty dry, but I'm not sure it was, given the way it seemed to want to tear out.

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#4

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

Ruth Niles

>Barry, it really doesn't matter how dry walnut is, what you are experiencing is the nature of the beast. Wipe the whole piece thoroughly with a paste wax (I use Johnson's Floor wax), let it dry (couple of minutes) then do your shear scraping. Russ has the solution and he may have posted to that post John mentioned of a week ago. Check Russ's Corner, I think the solution is there.

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#5

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

Jim Ketron

>Yep sometimes Walnut turns and finishes Nice and sometimes it's a PITA. I would try the paste wax.

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#6

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>If the wax doesn't work try wet sanding. I use Mahoneys Walnut Oil or Danish Oil to wet sand with. Others even use mineral oil. I,m leary of using the mineral oil because it never dries, though otheres do claim good results with it.

Tom

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#7

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

Darryl Hansen

>If wax doesn't do it try Deft or similar lacquer sanding sealer on the end grain then try your sanding routine again.

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#8

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem & a very long answer

Russ Fairfield

>The following are taken from a long answer that I wrote several years ago to the same question. Several of these suggestions have already been made. Consider the tool profile because it can help make a better cut, regardless of what else you do.

What happened to the "Grinds Library"?? I was going to use it, and it isn't there.

On the Walnut.

What you are seeing is not unusual with Walnut, particularly on the inside curvature. And it doesn't matter whether it is wet or bone dry. A couple problems here. First, Walnut has a tendency for end-grain tear-out anyway, particularly on wood where the growth rings are rather far apart, because the "between" wood isn't as strong as some other species. The tear-out is worse when the cut is sort-of along the end-grain and between the growth rings rather than running across them. You are in the weakest area of the wood. You could accept that this is a common problem with Walnut, live with it, get out the 60 grit, and SAND, but I don't think that is the solution you are looking for.

A "natural edge” shape of the piece will make things worse because the end-grain part would also be quite flexible, and we will experience some flutter. These things can pump a lot of air. I slow down to something about 300 RPM.

The wood problem is compounded because the curve of the wood and the curve of the tool bevel from the grinding are in opposite directions, and you are cutting on the tip and rubbing on the heel of the tool, rather than the bevel. There is no pressure right at the cutting edge to hold back the fibers so they can be cut, so there is a lot of fine tear-out. Then, the heel of the bevel rubs the wood surface and rides over and into the torn grain behind the tool. The problem is that we are trying to cut an inside curve with a tool that was designed for cutting on the outside.

You can move the supporting area up next to the cutting edge by grinding a short secondary bevel right at the cutting edge. Depending on the inside diameter it may be necessary to move the heal of the bevel back even farther. I do this by first sharpening the edge, and then extending the tool out about 3/32" in the Wolverine jig, and then making another pass to within about 1/16" of the cutting edge, and then repeating the process until I have a multifaceted bevel that is approximately on a 3-4" radius. I have never figured why there is so much concern about not having multifaceted bevels on our tools, when the only bevel that the wood sees is the one that is immediately below the cutting edge. When that one is continuous bevel along the cutting edge, it will cut fine.

If possible dress the grinding wheel to a finer grit. I use the single point with a light cut, and working it back and forth across the face of the wheel until it is totally "sparked out". This will fracture the grits on the wheel surface and leave an 80-grit wheel with a face that is something close to a 150-grit.

Honing the inside of the flute with a stone and either polishing the outside of the edge with a stone or buffing with green rouge will do wonders. The buffing will leave a polished razor edge. The buffing wheel will blend the multiple facets into a smooth continuous and polished curve between the heel and the cutting edge.

A bowl gouge with a sharp "V" or "parabolic" shaped flute is best for finishing cuts on problem wood. The "V" lets you grind a very sharp tip radius, which reduces the cutting forces on the wood, and moves the cutting area around to the side of the flute and making more of a a shearing cut. Coupled with a polished bevel, you have the equivalent of a skew cut. I like the Oneway bowl gouges because of the small radius at the bottom of the flute. The Henry Taylor "Superflute" has a similar flute shape with a small radius at the bottom.

On an open shaped bowl that is particularly flexible, I use a 1/2" continental spindle gouge or a 3/4" roughing gouge that is ground with a blunt rounded fingernail profile and about a 40* included bevel angle. Hold it on edge at 90* with the flute facing you, and the bevel riding on the wood. Then, then tip it back slightly (tool up and handle down) so that it is making a very shallow angle shearing cut across the tip and just below the center of the tool while moving it across the wood from the top towards the bottom of the bowl. This is as close as you can get to duplicating the shearing cut of a skew-chisel on the inside of the bowl.

You might also "work" on the wood, and stiffen it up with a thinned lacquer before making the finished cut. That will help hold it together for a cut. Other's will state the merits of Watco Danish Oil, wax, and varnish, but I use the lacquer because it is ready to turn in about 3 minutes after wiping the excess from the surface, and thwe wood is stiffer than with wax.

Here is a different approach that can make turning the inside curve of a problem wood or shape a bit easier. There is nothing that mandates that we turn the outside first. It's just that we have always done it that way. If we turn the inside first, the wood is fully supported for the inside curvature and vibration and flutter are not a problem. This approach means that we have to be able to see where we are going with the outside shape before we get there. With a little practice, it isn't that difficult. I would rough turn to round before doing the inside, and then go back and turn the outside of the bowl.

Somewhere in all of that is the answer to your question. If you need photos of the tools I have suggested, ask and I will look for them. They were in the former "grinds library".

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#9

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

scott hogsten

>I turn a lot of walnut and have a couple of suggestions. Walnut can be a bit difficult at times but I can nearly always get a good surface from it. Are you sure you removed all of the subsurface damage from roughout and theinitial rounding on the final turning ? In my experience this is usually the biggest problem and if it's not removed during the re-turning/shear scraping no amount of sanding is going to get it out of the wood. Make sure your tools are very sharp and resharpen frequently. Lighten up on your shear scraping, lots of passes with super fine shavings. During your initial sanding, sand the end grain areas with the lathe off. Also don't be afraid to start with 80 grit or even 60 grit if you have to. If you are truly having problems with tear out then I like to use a very dilute solution of sanding sealer to stiffen up the fibers.

Scott Hogsten

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#10

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem & a very long answer

Russ Fairfield

>Another suggestion that you might try with the tool that you are using.

It is common to turn the inside of a bowl by starting at the rim and going downward into the center. Try doing this in the opposite direction by starting the cut at the bottom center and working outwards toward the rim. The difference in the way you are holding the tool to the wood to make this cut can make a difference.

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#11

Grinds library

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Russ when I open this post of yours, I saw it in th eright hand side, Other things appear in the same spot a different timess

Jorge

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#12

How about this?

Dominic Greco in Richboro, PA

>

Last week I was asked about wet sanding a walnut bowl in order to overcome the tear out. I included links to Russ' replies as well as links to some relevant posts from the archive.

Dealing with tear out in Walnut

Maybe this can help some.

Dominic

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#13

Link to grinds library *LINK*

Shawn - in ID

>The link in the upper right portion of the lower frames appears to be on a random cycler of links - keep loading any posts and it will eventually offer the grinds link. However, here is the URL:


http://www.woodcentral.com/newforum/grinds.shtml

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#14

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

theeviltwinn

>I noticed how you said you sanded from 80 grit up to 180 grit then raised the grain and started again at 120 grit.

When sanding it is best to start at what ever grit you choose and don't proceed to the next grit until you have a smooth uniform surface. This means keep at it with the 80 grit until all blemishes are gone. If the 80 grit won't get it try 60 grit or even recut it with a tool. Switching to a finer grit before finishing with the rougher grit will only waste time and sandpaper. I brush off the piece and inspect the surface before going on to the next finer grit.

Mike

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#15

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

Barry Turner

>I agree. That's not my usual drill. I went back and raised the grain out of sheer desperation. I would have went back to 60 grit when I couldn't get rid of the tear out with 80 grit, but didn't have anything coarser than 80 grit. I didn't want to go back to the scraper or recut with the bowl gouge because I'm sure the bowl had moved. In spite of all of the false starts and stuff, the bowl actually turned out pretty well. I don't know how it did, but it did. Thanks.

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#16

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

Barry Turner

>Hmmmmmmmm. The wax thing just seems so WRONG! Doesn't it interfere with finishing later? I guess I've got to try it though. Thanks.

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

#17

Re: Walnut Bowl Problem

woodspinner/ Bill Hale

>I use the normal rough out procedure and don't worry about any fine cuts. After you are ready to do final work,

1. re sharpen

2. do very light cuts so the wood comming off looks like curly hair.

3. I use a gouge with a long fingernail grind. I hold the handle very low and use only the side of the edge. Inside cut center out and outside rim to base. Some times I need to do a little cut base to rim on the lower radius.

This is one you need to develop your own skill but above all sharp and light.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.