New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

which buffing wheels to use

Posts

which buffing wheels to use

#1

which buffing wheels to use

ben d

>Have never used the buffing system such as Beale. I am building up my own system and want to purchase the buffing wheels seperately. They are listed Linen, Linen flannel mixed and flannel. These are available at about $17 ea. and I am a bit stingey and want to save some $$. I have found the flannel wheel for about $6 but have not located the other exact same wheels. With all that said are there substitutes for the linen and the linnen and flannel mix.?? If anyone has used different texture wheels and they work well what would they be.??

Re: which buffing wheels to use

#2

Re: which one? Get the Beall

DaveZ

>Ben, make sure you look closely at this. I am of the opinion that the small amount of money you can save here, will be greatly outweighed by the aggravation of assembling it. Will it work the same? Also if there was any significant savings to be had, someone else would be selling it and we'd all have that link in our favorites, lol.

One thing more that I remember from when I had those same thoughts you're thinking now, is be aware of the width of the wheel you are pricing. Alot of "metal" buff wheels are thinner, and you might need 2 or more to equal the Beall width.

Re: which buffing wheels to use

#3

Re: which buffing wheels to use

Russ Fairfield

>If you want to save money, make your own discs. They will work as well as anything you can buy.

Get some bleached denim cloth, wash it twice to get all of the sizing out, cut out the disks and punch a hole in the middle of them, stack them on a 3/8" bolt between two fender washers, clamp it together with a nut, and hold it in a Jacobs Chuck in the lathe.

Do this 3 times and you will start thinking that $17 apiece isn't so bad after all.

Re: which buffing wheels to use

#4

I bought mine from......

W.C. Turner

>www.caswellplating.com/buffs/

works fine for me.

Re: which buffing wheels to use

#5

Re: I bought mine from......

DaveZ

>Hi WC, Which buffs did you get from there, how much did you save and was it worth it?

Re: which buffing wheels to use

#6

Re: I bought mine from......

W.C. Turner

>Caswell has a buy one get one free. I got the cotton, & the flannel wheels. I bought 4, & got 4 free. I also bought 2 of the large buffing compounds. Total of my order was less than $55.

When I can get 2 wheels for less than what one costs from other sources, & twice the amount of compounds for much less, that's a bargain for me.

Saved about 1/2.

Yes, definately worth it to me!

Re: which buffing wheels to use

#7

Re: 50%cheaper???

DaveZ

>Yes the wheels are cheaper, but they are half the thickness, so you would need two to equal one beall. Comparing apples to apples, from Caswell, here's what I get if shopping against Beall (all #'s approx)

Total of 6 1/2" x 8" wheels------- $26.25

2 coumpounds regular size--------- $12.00

Shaft Adapter----------------------$12.00

_______

$50.25

They didn't have the wax so add

in for it--------------------------$ 5.00

________

$55.25

It looks like the savings from the $70 Beall price is somewhat less than half, somewhere around $15. The Beall go on and off effortlessly and there are no loose parts to keep track off i.e. washers and nuts. Another advantage is that the bowl buffs screw right on as well.

It is also true, that there are coupons and sales available quite often, so it is possible to get that price down on the beall, as much as 15-20%. Which, effectively nullifies that $15 savings by assembling your own. Now this scenario might be off a buck or two, but my point really is, especially when considering that this is not an everyday purchase and has some longevity, that the savings is small. Small enough to be eclipsed by the ease of use over that time frame.

Re: which buffing wheels to use

#8

Re: 50%cheaper???

W.C. Turner

>Sounds to me like you're still trying to "justify" your expensive Beall purchase.

Re: which buffing wheels to use

#9

Re: 50%cheaper???

DaveZ

>Nope. In fact, when looking at all the other expenditures involved with woodturning, the Beall purchase goes relatively unnoticed.

I was just trying to show the fallacy of saving 50% by cobbling together your own system for a $10 saving, regardless of anyone's bold claims. So I made my case and you countered with......what?

Thank you for proving my point.