We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I have a number of large pine trees waaaay too close to the house (10 - 15ft) with hurricane season coming up. The man is here to take them down (uses a bucket truck)and it cost $2000 for 8 trees. Actually he is giving me a deal at $250 a tree because my Mom and I are repeat customers, but still...I keep thinking of my lathe fund which seems to always get depleted as soon as I am nearly at the point of being able to purchase my dream machine. :((
Carole, who is back to saving the pennies all over again.
>Tree removal people pay the highest insurance of anyone. Their liability is high as well as their workmens comp. If the trees can be taken down without a bucket truck by using a cable to pull the trees someone not insured can do it a lot cheaper but then you are at risk.
>Holy cow! I guess I AM getting a deal! They could not be taken out without a bucket. I'll tell you though, I don't know how ANY of those guys can still hear...that big chipper thing is soooo loud and they don't wear any ear protection at all. I have had to put plugs in my ears just to go outside and watch from a distance.
>Carol, I have a HUGE ash tree that really worries me a bit. It is right outside my bedroom (it's really bad Feng Shui! Ha!)
and when the storms roll through I just pray it doesn't come down. I had it deadwooded and cabled together up top about 8 years ago because the estimate to take it down was $3000.00. Somebody would have to climb to get it down. There's no room for a bucket truck. Ugh....it sure would make a lot of pretty bowls though!
>Your right Terry. As a rock climber I have a lot of ropes and Jumar's and have removed a few trees on my property and for friends. A lady asked me to remove a huge walnut tree that was hanging over here house. I thought I could sell the good wood and keep the smaller limbs for myself. I was 95% sure I could cut it up and not damage the house but thought insurance might be good idea. I could not believe how much it was. I declined to cut the tree because I also couldn't find anyone to buy the wood and I couldn't risk any possible damage to the house.
Even though that may sound like a lot - that really is a great deal. Tomorrow (weather permitting) I am having 3 trees removed for $1200 (some simple math puts that $400 per tree).
Take comfort in the fact that your house will be that much safer and, if any or all of them happen to be deciduous pines, there will be that much less to clean up in the fall.
If they are also removing the wood you do not want that is unfortunately a very good deal. I have myself cut a number of yellow pines around my house with ropes and wenches, however I recently had to have a dying oak cut that was leaning toward my deck and house. I was uncomfortable doing it myself. To have it felled only (I did the clean up) was $175.
>No personal safety gear whatsoever! Chain saws going like crazy and not the first sign of safety glasses, helmets, chaps or anything. In fact only one guy has on gloves. They sure seem to know what they are doing though. (knock on wood!)
>$2000 for 8 trees doesn't sound too bad from a fully insured company -- especially if they haul them off. Granted, $2K is certainly a hit on the lathe fun front. Too bad they are just pine. Can you come up with a way to make, say, 40 pine bowls and sell em for $50 each? Make those trees work!
I had a pair of "ant infested" oak trees quoted at $1200 each. Fortunately (or not) Isabel took them out for me. They didn't hit the house, nor did they appear very infested. Only one small limb of one tree was affected.
>On the other hand, what's the deductable on your house insurance? Insurance companies won't take them down for preventative maintenance, as it'll open Pandora's Box for other trees to be trimmed/cut. Might be cheaper to let one fall and let the insurance company take care of it, AND get you a new roof.
>We had a storm go through here 10 days ago and I spent 9 hr. with a chain saw in my yard and next door yard. ( At one time I made a good living with a chain saw). I hear ests. of $8500. to 14 K for tree removable only. No chipping stumps. The price doubled for one person when they said they had to get their car out to the road.
>Carole, I do home inspections for a living. I was at a house today and they had a HUGE oak tree in the front yard. The quote was $2000 to take it down. It was bigger than the house. Makes yours look better.
I did an inspection for a family moving hear from India. There was a huge tree just in front of their house. They drove me nuts over the inspection, calling me ten times or more, double checking every detail. About a year later, they called me and mysteriously insisted I meet them at the house the following morning a 10 AM Sharp. I went there and a micro burst storm has dumped the tree on their house, smashing 2/3's of it flat to the first floor. It had been a 2600 SF two story house. Almost nothing was left except the fireplace on one end and the garage on the other. I walked around and stared and was almost too stunned to say anything. I asked the father why he had called me. We were standing behind the house and he pointed sort of up under the ruble and said, "do you see that white thing? That was my daughter's bed. We left on vacation and decided to stay one extra day. That was the day of the storm. Had we come home on time, surely she would have been killed. We are the luckiest people in America and we wanted to share our good fortune with you."
>Yep, you're right Barry. I had my oaks taken out two years ago, just before Isabel I believe. One of them was less than 6' off my patio. The rest were less than 20' from the house and most were big double or triple trunks. I cried when I went into the back yard that evening. I still have some more that should be removed but they will have to wait a while. It's strange that I feel such sadness now that those trees are gone. They have been friends since I have lived here, whispering in the breezes and shading me from the afternoon sun, providing homes for squirrels and birds, but they also produced a tremendous amount of stress when the big storms headed our way. Still...
>After Isabel, there were people (probably neither insured or trained)going around removing trees for absolutely exhorbitant prices...and not just trees that were on houses. I remember thinking after hearing about some of the rip-offs, that "what goes around comes around" and praying that it was true. Most people were doing their darndest to help one another out in a crisis without so much as a thought for compensation...except for those bloodsuckers. Sort of like the 4 wheelers that go out in a storm and charge $200 to get someone unstuck in the snow! When it snows here, I throw the strap in the truck and try to help anyone I can for free before the "suckers" can get to them. I'd just like to come across one of THEM stuck!
Same here, I can't count the number of people I've pulled out of the snow, out of the sand at the Outer Banks, and even one poor guy's truck out of the river when he backed off the boat ramp (and the water was rising from Norris Dam!)
But it comes back around. This summer I got one of my jeeps stuck in the sand, stucker than stuck, up to the axle stuck. I dug and jacked and dug and got more stuck! I was about to do the old "bury the spare tire" as an anchor for my winch when along came a guy and pulled me out with his winch, easy as pie. You bet I'll help the next guy who needs it!
>We are fortunate to have 5 large trees near our house. They provide a nice cool shade in the summer, and a comforting sanctuary for birds and squirrels year round.
They also dump leaves and detritus in our yard and pool. But our oaks and the cedar elm were here long before this house was built. I hope they are here a long time after I am gone. One can replace a house, but it is almost impossible to replace a 100 year old tree.
However I also understand why people cut trees down to protect their houses. I recently removed a massive limb off our silver maple - the limb was making the tree lean towards the house. Hopefully the maple will donate that limb and persevere without it.
We keep our trees trimmed and healthy with the intent of making them strong enough to make it thru the yearly thunderstorms.
>I think you just explained why they are so cheap. Downing a large oak in St. Louis with ropes or bucket is easily $2000 for the good folks. Cheaper "tree care" is available from guys with a pickup and chainsaw. The expensive guys are smart in every way and use all the right safety gear.
My urban log recycling business deals with tree care firms of all types and price ranges. When I needed a tree dropped, I went for the high end guys. There is way too much that is scary about the quick and dirty types.
Just one story: A condo association in the ritzy part of town needed two trees removed from next to the building. They hired a guy with a truck and two saws who hires day labor when he has work (not particularly trained). He is usually low bid. He asked our truck to be there to remove the log immediately since ritzy parts of town aren't too keen on logs laying around. A rope got stuck and the log ended up swinging through a brick wall and glass window. When the owner got out of the shower, she was not pleased. The tree laid there for a week since we only haul logs and when the trunk is in a living room, it is still a tree.
>If all I had to worry about was thunderstoms, the trees would still be there, but there is a big difference between a summer thunderstorm (though they can be wicked) and CAT 3-5 hurricane. Even Isabel, which was not even Cat 1 when it hit here, made me wonder if those trees were going to make it. A lot of others didn't.
>Dunno, but they are fully insured and have been doing it for years (same 5 man crew). I just found out that they all used to work together on the logging crew for the local saw mill before they ventured out on their own, so that must be where they got their training. I know these trucks, the big chipper, the dump truck and insurance are not cheap but I would think if they screwed up more than once their insurance would be prohibitive.
>Quote "I keep thinking of my lathe fund which seems to always get depleted as soon as I am nearly at the point of being able to purchase my dream machine. :(( "
Isn't that the truth! Every time i get close something else needs my secret Lathe money!