New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Musing about Bullshit

Posts

Musing about Bullshit

#1

Musing about Bullshit

Arch

>Probably many of you have read this clearly written and thought provoking little book, "ON Bullshit" by H.G. Frankfurt, Princeton Univ. Press. If not, consider buying ($5 to $10, used or new) or borrowing a copy. It is an easy read, but you'll gain by rereading. I think Frankfurt's philosophy is pertinent and _on topic for many turners who post to turning forums, especially pg. 20-24. I'd like to share my copy with friends, but I want to keep it for a while. It won't make me a better turner, but, IMO it wlll make me better able to recognize the better turners. :)

I won't take umbrage whether you agree or disagree, YMMV, but I'd sure like to know your take about this essay.

Arch

Re: Musing about Bullshit

#2

Re: Musing about Bullshit- Humbug!

albertabob

>I have $20.00 in my pocket!

gd&r

Bob

Re: Musing about Bullshit

#3

Re: Words also, are in the eye of the beholder

Arch

>Hi Bob,

Thank you for your lone response out of three hundred and sixty nine views. You may or may not have $20 in your pocket, but your humbug is "short of a lie". The rest of you can look it up in the book. Probably you won't and I don't blame you.

Seems unlikely that the restrained response to my thread was due to my choice of words. I was careful not to offend anyone's sense of gentility with distasteful words: vulgar words that suggest the truly obscene like, rape, poverty, molestation, terror and hunger. Instead I mentioned an excretion without which no turner or no bull can survive for long. To keep the posting short, I elected not to mention several other four letter words that reflect activities essential to our happiness and survival.

In my efforts not to offend I avoided using some less acceptable synonyms for bullshit that were mentioned by the author. Words such as hokum, drivel and quackery. I even avoided using unacceptably coarse and pretentious substitutes like shucks or shoot.

So the underwhelming response must have been due to other causes such as the time taken to respond to new and answerable questions. After all the imponderable isn't fascinating or is that just more humbug? I said I'd take no umbrage. I hope you took no offense.

Arch

Re: Musing about Bullshit

#4

Re: Words also, are in the eye of the beholder

Larry

>Arch,

Probably no response because noone else has read the book.