New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

padauk toxicity?

Posts

padauk toxicity?

#1

padauk toxicity?

GaryG in MD

>While I'm at it, I might as well ask the same questions as for the bocote in my other post.

The tables disagree on padauk. I suspect that there is an error in one of them, but I don't know which. One says that its toxicity is "low and rare", while the other says "extreme and common". They can't both be right.

Which way is it?

Gary

Re: padauk toxicity?

#2

Re: padauk toxicity?

Verne

>Gary, I have "serious" reactions to the "rosewoods", i.e. cocobolo, etc. I am not, however going to give up the pleasure of occasionally working with some of these woods. As a result, when I turn anything that is even possibly "toxic", I wear Tyvec coveralls, rubber gloves (with the cuffs pilled up over the sleeve end) and a Triton respirator. I specifically chose the Triton in that with the helmet, face mask, full shroud and positive pressure, I can be secure in my "mini" hazmat suit. While it looks cumbersom, it is really easy to work in and it does work quite well as I have had no problems with even cocobolo now. When disrobing, I make sure to turn things inside out as I remove them. One caution however, If you need to clean up, vacuum and empty your vacuum, etc., BEFORE getting out of the garb!

As for Padauk, I personally have had no reaction working with this wood.

Re: padauk toxicity?

#3

Re: padauk toxicity?

Jim King-Iquitos, Peru

>Gary: Over the last 20 plus years I have worked at least a couple hundred species of tropical or "exotic woods" and never had what you could call an allergic reaction. I think trying to predict what wood or anything else will cause a reaction to anyone is about like forecasting the weather a month in advance. I have seen reactions to some species by individuals and the person or persons working with the same wood next to them have no problem what so ever. I think we can all be allergic to most anything at different times and the best medicine is common sense and dont live in fear of new things. It appears that everyone selling wood feels the need to put a disclaimer on thier site warning of the dangers of working with wood. I certainly think that most finishes on the market are more dangerous than wood not to mention the piece in the lathe spinning at a few hundred rpms. I have to agree with the person that said sweating and wood dust dont mix as we have a lot of practice with that, washing off the sanding dust regularly will certainly help eliminate itching.. Just a jungle opinion.

Re: padauk toxicity?

#4

Re: padauk toxicity?

GaryG in MD

>Hi Jim,

Thanks for sharing your great experience. I understand what you are saying, and it is encouraging. I certainly agree about the dangers inherent to many finishes.

The key is being careful. The trick is to know when to be EXTRA careful. My questions about bocote and padauk are meant to give me a better feeling for when I have to take extra precautions, like wearing gloves, etc., which I normally don't.

It looks like bocote definitely requires extra measures. I'm still curious about padauk though, because the literature is contradictory.

On a personal note, I always look at your posts when they appear. I really enjoy seeing your woods and what you're doing with them. Your recent description of your turning procedures was very interesting and very instructive.

I was curious about several things. Do your turners mainly use gouges or scrapers? It's hard to tell what that very long-handled tool is. Secondly, I assume that you must make new screw holes when you remount your blanks back on the faceplates after boiling and sun drying. Does that ever lead to problems? Many of your woods are very hard; do you drill pilot holes first?

One more question: Your covered bowls are very nice; are they functional or primarily decorative?

Keep up the good work!

Regards,

Gary

Re: padauk toxicity?

#5

Re: padauk toxicity?

GaryG in MD

>Hi Verne,

As you imply, there's two ways to do it -- properly, or not at all. Given my history of very nasty allergies (I've "permanently" lost my sense of smell due to extreme congestion), I'm afraid I fall more in the camp of those for whom the simplest form of safety is to avoid certain well-known problem woods like cocobolo and other rosewoods. But I do want to have SOME fun, so I'm trying to determine which middle-of-the-road cases I'll tackle (with extra care). I'm trying to get consensus information on things like bocote and padauk for which the literature is deficient or contradictory. Thanks for your thoughts.

Happy 4th,

Gary

Re: padauk toxicity?

#6

Re: padauk toxicity?

vicmarc.fan

>I picked up three pieces of podauk 17 X 17 X 3 and turned platters out of them. My comment is after 2 months I am still finding red dust everywhere in my shop. I had my bandsaw connected to my dust collector and used the collector when I sanded but there is still all this dust. I didn't have any reaction to the wood but it does make some dust as you turn so I took a good shower after each session. I wear a Airmate unit when I turn after a spalted maple session where I became sick from the dust. The padauk turned and finished very nice and I am looking for some more of the stuff.

Ron

Re: padauk toxicity?

#7

Re: padauk toxicity?

GaryG in MD

>Hi Ron,

Thanks for the info; very interesting. I'll keep that in mind if I get some. I'll record your experience as a 'no' vote for allergy/toxicity. ;-)

I got some zebrawood, and I'm going to be looking for goncalo alves; they seems to be relatively problem free for exotics.

I've got some spalted maple, and I'm going to be very careful when I turn it -- I really don't like the idea of those molds and fungi getting in my lungs.

Gary