New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

AAW Symposium topics

Posts

AAW Symposium topics

#1

AAW Symposium topics

JamieDonaldson

>I'm a little miffed about many of the negative comments posted in 2 recent threads regarding AAW. This is a member driven organization constituted to serve and support the membership, and I don't find support for claims of elitism and indifference as posted by several WC posters. I have attended 10 Symposiums and demoed at 6, and I am certainly not a famous turner. Comments also mentioned the dearth of subjects such as spindle, square, design,etc.- they haven't been paying attention to the recent schedule of demonstrations. I demoed square bowls and was featured on the annual DVD of demonstrators, and thank God for excellent editing! Design is an extremely difficult subject to teach in small doses-right Keith? If you don't see a subject you want covered, make your suggestions to a Board member, or better yet, become a Board member! Don't expect someone else to act on your silent wishes- get involved! Critic are everywhere, but active participants are much more valuable to a self- supporting organization.

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#2

Re: AAW Symposium topics

Steve Mushinski

>The AAW is alive and doing very well Jamie. There are many things I agree with on both sides of the fence. So call me in the middle. With the amount of members we have there will always be some that do not like how things are being done. I for one would like to see much more design and out of the box work while many want to see bowls. The people putting the show on do a wonderful job of trying to hit people like me the middle. A Quote I read on David Peebles web site.

"I cannot give you a formula for success, but I can give you a formula for failure - which is: Try to please everybody."

Herbert Bayard Swope

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: AAW Symposium topics

Keith Tompkins

>HI Jamie, You raise several valid points....I have only demoed at one national level symposium, and as another 'unknown' turner, was selected on my first attempt.

I have noticed one curious thing about the selection of demonstrators: If your work appears on the AAW national instant gallery video, you have an excellent chance of being selected to demo the following year. If your work appears on the video, it is an excellent opportinity for promoting your demo career.

One reason I believe I was selected was I presented a very professionally prepared proposal. I stated exactly what my program would cover, and what the audience could expect to gain by participating. I included the best slides possible....(not taken by me; professionally done.) The slides alone can be a determining factor, and reflect the effort the presenter is willing to make.

My resume included the previous demos I'd done, exhibitions and awards, and a key to slides, explaining each piece. The proposal was organized and put in a binder. I wanted the panel to think....THIS guy is serious about his demonstrations.

Yes, design topics are risky, as I admitted previously. But, the subject is something I strongly believe in. I took a salesmanship course in school; one example given on the affect of attitude...two bra salesmen were sent to a south Pacific island. One salesman returned home discouraged. They don't wear bras here....no sales to be had. The other salesman said....They don't wear bras here! The market is wide open!! Similarly, turning is the same; the design market is WIDE OPEN! Therefore, IMHO, if my proposal is turned down, I probably didn't make a good enough case for WHY my demo was important to my fellow turners.

After attending several symposiums, it is obvious to me that the board is serious about quality presentations. My sessions were monitored, as I'm sure others were. I think we need to remember, no organization is perfect, including AAW. But, the good points far outway the bad...we are all much better off because of it.

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#4

Where is this island?

Terry Daniel

>

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#5

Re: Where is this island?

john Lucas

>I wouldn't have returned from the island.

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#6

Re: AAW Symposium topics

john Lucas

>Jamie

Thanks. I was biting my tonque also. I see a lot of complaining about the AAW but no volunteers. Write your board members and editors and tell them what you want to see. They listen. They may not be able to please everyone but I think they try.

A good example is the Journal, American Woodturner. Everyone seemed to want the Journal in color. It took a while but they finally were able to do it and boy has that made a difference.

There are a lot of good turners out there. You know who you are. You should be writing an article for the Journal or doing local and regional demos. If you look in the magazine there are a lot of articles by Nick Cook, Bob Rosand and Alan Lacer. It's not because they ask these guys to write. It's because they care about the Journal and submit articles. If you submit a good article with good quality photos I'm sure Carl will give it equal consideration to the others.

An organization is only as good as it's members. I'd like to add that it's only as good as the members will tell it to be. Let your voice be heard.

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: AAW Symposium topics

Keith Tompkins

>John, you are correct...there are some awfully good turners out there. I think the thing that holds some turners back is the fact that they are craftsmen, not artists. Therefore, they feel their demos would not be given a fair chance...the fancy artistic forms and techniques get all the attention.

BUT, not all turners have the ability to teach, and get their point across. Some people you mentioned in your post are not known for their signature pieces, but for their ability to reach an audience. If you have good teaching ability, I urge you to demonstrate...it is a very rewarding experience.

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#8

Re: AAW Symposium topics, long, biased & boring

Arch

>If there ever was an 'on the other hand' thread, this is one. Whether church vestry, civic club, scout troop, sewing circle, union hall, professional association or turning guild, the refrain is always the same. Those who _will do, those who _won't don't and no faction is ever entirely pleased, even when sides are changed, as they often are. It's an inviolate fact of organizations and being critical or miffed, chicken little or polyanna won't change things. It seems to me that if WC allows it, we should be free to say it, whether in praise or defense or criticism.

OTOH, WC is an international and independent forum, and not a subsidiary, advocate nor apologist for AAW, GMC, or any other national or regional

association of woodturners. This, regardless of the stature or majority of WC members who belong to another group.

OTOH, I see no reason not to invite someone who officially represents any organization to interact with us and either clear or muddy the waters when some here think they have been put upon. We have invited the lathe makers to chat with us.

OTOH, past AAW board members did contribute to various net forums. Now they have their own forum, but if we want any time at all for turning wood we can't monitor every new forum on the block.

OTOH, forgetting the scale of things, mine is just one of many strongly held and thought to be 'very important' opinions.

OTOH, there are many loosely held 'couldn't care less' attitudes. Many here must be bored with the arguments and hurt feelings about organizations that are external to WC.

...OTOH, Arch

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#9

Re: AAW Symposium topics

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Jamie,

I appreciate your posting. I have to say I have never been to an AAW meeting so I have no idea other than what I read what happens there. As an AAW member now for two years, my only real exposure to what it is comes in a magazine 4 times a year. About 4 months ago I joined a local Turning club and have seen a bit more of the process.

But from my position Jamie, I still have no idea how to change or add my voice to a list of desired topics. Your posting does give me a few ideas, but I know I still will be searching out people to contact and make my requests.

I know that I am not alone in this, my hobby is part of my passions in life, getting the most from it is important to me. I respect your words, having been a presenter you hold a better view of the crowd than most, as well as what is required...my frustration is I am blind to it, I can't see or know what I have to do to ask for items I would beinterested in...2 years into my membership it's a frustration for me.

I will be at Louisville, I will try as you mention to add my thoughts and ideas in the mean time to some one at the AAW. I thank You for that, I want it to better for everyone as well.

I am looking forward to meeting you one day

Take care,

Jim

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#10

Re: Craft Trap

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Careful Keith! By making some distinction between "craftsman" and "artist" you'll pour gas on the very fire Jamie complained of!

Whether they be a "crafter" an "arteest" or a "dedicated academic" who only knows what he's read, the test of a teacher is the ability to organize and communicate a body of information in such a way that it can be used by the audience. It's preparation, public speaking, advocacy, and stand-up comedy all bound up in a specific point in time. There are no re-runs or re-takes, and no cutting room editors and air brushers to make you look good after the fact.

I know several people who pride themselves on their craft; woodturners, machinists, furniture finishers and restorers, jewelers, pattern makers, welders, founders, carpenters, and others. They conciously have not saught status as "artists." I've had the opportunity to know a number of artists, woodturners, furniture makers, jewelers, sculptors, painters, and architects, who took just as much pride in the crafting and making of their work as anyone else. Funny thing, those "artists" held in most high esteem the fine workman, the "Craftsman," who taught them how to bring their ideas into reality.

If there is a distinction being drawn on some level between "craftsman" and "artist," let us disregard it for the sham that it is, and discard it as any measuring stick for potential teachers (demonstrators). Give us, instead, a person with a dedication to "craftsmanship" , the clear expression of an idea, and the ability to communicate "how to" in a way that more than 10% of what they say will leave the room with the audience.

Then we shall have memorable and worthwhile demostrators.

[I'll miss you in KC]

M

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#11

Re: AAW Symposium topics

JamieDonaldson

>Jim et al- thanks for your imput. I have valued my AAW Symposium trips as lemming to Mecca! (How's that for a mixed metaphor!?) One of my concerns about public demonstrations to an audience too large to huddle about the lathe is the inept use of video - all too often the camera operator is untrained and inattentive. From my background as a photographer/teacher I have made this problem known to several groups such as AAW, and I hope that pre-symposium training will improve this shortcoming this year. Technology toys and associated applications often have a steep learning curve, and knowledge of the process is a must for proper presentation in all fields. The Instant Gallery is probably my favorite part of the experience. Nowhere else on earth will you see such an annual collection of turning talent on open display, and "amateur" turners often eclipse the production of the "stars." It was/is a great spot to enlarge my imagination and my collection by finding the early work of the stars of the future, and the sheer immensity of the gathered talent can be overwhelming!

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#12

Re: AAW Symposium topics

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Jamie

Well, if you are miffed by negative comments on the AAW, I am sure that I am one of those who have caused you offense, since I made some very pointed comments on the AAW earlier on. I will try to clarify some of what I wrote, since this seems to be an occasion where I was not completely understood, or at least understood as I meant myself to be.

First of all, I do not doubt that your experiences with or perceptions of the AAW are accurate. They are your experiences. In the past I have written of my own experiences with people representing the AAW in various venues - mini symposium, demonstration, etc. While I am not adverse to hyperbole in some of what I write, if I am going to criticize something, I try to be as accurate as possible. You see, I have been snubbed personally, I have been in groups watching a world famous demonstrator(s) talk down to the people in the group in an arrogant and condescending way. I have talked with numerous others who have experienced the same thing, but of course that is hearsay.

On the other hand, virtually every local chapter meeting I have attended has been filled with really great people, friendly, talented, etc. I have been demonstrating since 1995, and I have met many of the big names in turning. Some of these folks have been as down to earth as they can be, and some have not. Like John says, I think people need to be involved at the local level, because that is where things really happen. When our local club started up, I loaned my mini lathe for a year until we had the money to get our own. That meant schlepping it back and forth 40 miles each way for every meeting, being the first in and the last out. I was our newsletter editor twice, and did the initial set up our web page. Then there are the demos I have done, not just at our club, but at many others besides. It has been fun, and while it is a lot of work, I do not see stopping any time soon.

I have been critical of the journal because I think it went way too far towards the art end of things. That is nothing more than my opinion. I also posted (both here and on another forum) when I thought the journal came out with an excellent issue.

I have never been to a national symposium, and I do not know that I will ever go. I am not keen on crowds of any sort, and to be honest, I do not know that I want to spend the money it costs to go somewhere that is going to be an awful lot like what I read in the journal. Again, this is my opinion.

I get numerous emails every week from people who are just starting out and who want advice on what lathe to buy, tools, wood, etc. Virtually every single response I make recommends that the person search out a local chapter of the AAW. So you see, I am not really anti AAW, but I am very much anti some of the attitudes which I have personally experienced. It may be that we have different expectations, or different thresholds of tolerance for certain things, but for you to be miffed at someone like me having a bad experience and reporting on it makes as much sense of me being miffed with you because you had a good experience and reported on it.

Think about it this way. I derive a significant portion of my income through teaching and through the sales of my DVD. It is doing so well that there is going to be a second one filmed as soon as we can get everyone together to do it. What would it gain me to alienate people in my business demographic for no cause? In my previous posts, I mentioned that I had not gotten a lot out of the AAW, and that what I had experienced was a lot of elitism, to use your word. I did not say that it was universal, but it is there, and it exists in some people who would probably deny it if accused by name. Regardless of that, and regardless of your experience, this has been mine. I am truly sorry if it has caused you grief, but I did not post about it just to stir up trouble. I posted to express my frustration with some of the things I have encountered. We are not all the same, and we are not all going to be happy with everything that goes on, but if we are not allowed to express our opinions on the organization for fear of someone else becoming angry, then what is the use of even talking about it at all?

Bill

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#13

Re: AAW Symposium topics

adrien

>Bill, since no one else seems to have commented on your response, let me say I like very much what you had to say. There really are several categories of wood turning, from just the simple (right word?) turning of a piece to the intricately carved, painted and variously decorated kinds. As a very rank amateur, I can admire the intricate carvings, but know that I will never have the time or patience to try to develop such skills, so the pictures are something to admire, but the methods are beyond my ability to emulate.

(PS, if you want a criticism of your statement, leave out the d in "adverse.")

(PPS: when is the next disk due?)

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#14

I Know Where It Is!

Barry Turner

>I think I was there once. It was a private beach belonging to a fairly swanky hotel in Key West. They not only didn't wear bras on that beach; they didn't wear tops! More stuff on that beach to look at than I had eyes!

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#15

Re: AAW Symposium topics

JamieDonaldson

>And hello to you Bill- I have no specific bones to pick with you or any other specific individual, but I am miffed by aired comments based on inaccurate info or heresay. I prefer to deal with facts, and personal observations and perceptions are always subject to individual interpretations. Constructive criticism should be a positive, but negative criticism based on faulty info is not beneficial to anyone. In any group of homo sapiens will be found those that have a superior attitude, especially among groups of high strung artist types! I cannot agree with your general statement that you don't get much out of the AAW when you then state that you've never attended a Symposium- if you've never been there, where do you get the data to make such an informed decision? I don't hold the AAW to be perfect or for everyone, but it's the best organization turners have for members at all levels of skill and interest.

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#16

Re: AAW Symposium topics

Arch

>Jamie with respect, I doubt that you could be offended about even a tiny percentage of the false opinions and misinformation that's aired on the internet or even on this forum, else you would be continually and permanently upset. I wonder if you aren't mostly taken aback and "a little miffed" because, right or wrong, people whom you otherwise esteem and usually agree with, disagree about a subject of particular importance to you.

I didn't know how to say this without sounding like an obnoxious buttinski and I could be way off base.

However it comes across, I count on your good nature and abiliy to sense that I meant well.

It took me a while to hit the send button.

Best, Arch

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#17

Re: AAW Symposium topics

john Lucas

>Arch

I think you nailed the problem. Jamie and I obviously like the AAw and have gotten a lot out of it. Others haven't. That's fine. I don't like Coffee, or Beer. That doesn't mean I don't like peoople who like coffee or beer. We are kind of getting into a discussion that is like talking about politics. One group probably won't change the other but we can at least look from there viewpoint.

I agree with Bill I don't like crowds but there's just something great sitting around with a bunch of like minded individuals looking at the incredible and imaginative work of other turners in the instant gallery or discussing the merits of the latest tools to come out while walking through the vendor section.

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#18

Re: AAW Symposium topics

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Jamie

You wrote: "I cannot agree with your general statement that you don't get much out of the AAW when you then state that you've never attended a Symposium- if you've never been there, where do you get the data to make such an informed decision?"

I'm not sure why you think my decision is uninformed. I will certainly grant you that I am uninformed as to what exactly goes on at the symposium from a firsthand point of view, but my decision is by no means uninformed. The dues which I have sent in to the national organization have brought me the journal. I have not found a lot of what is in it to be helpful to me. There have been numerous articles which have, but my perception of the publication has been that it leans towards art and art turnings. That is not where my interest lies. This comment can be taken as neutral for all that. It is like saying I like blue lathes instead of white lathes. I don't read most of the regular woodworking magazines anymore either. While they provide a service for a lot of people, and while I am sure I could find at least one thing of value in each one, it is not economically prudent to buy them or a good use of my time to sift them out.

I cannot partcipate in the insurance program offered by the AAW. That is nobody's fault but the company offering it. They seem to think that people who make furniture are going to incur more liability than others. I do not really need the demonstrating insurance offered by the AAW, since my own liabilty insurance covers me for onsite work, and a demo is working on a site. I signed up as a business member this year, but no one contacting me has made mention of the fact that they did so because of that or my listing on the AAW site.

All this stuff is pure business so far. There is no real right or wrong about it. I already mentioned my experiences at some of the local goings on with big shots, and I will not dwell on that further except to say that I am very leery of paying a lot of money to go somewhere where experience says I will be treated badly by someone else, so symposiums are off my list for now. My undergraduate degree is in psychology. We call this aversive conditioning. If the rat gests a shock enough times for doing something, he will stop doing it.

I will confess to being passionate about being treated badly. No one is perfect, and I fail myself on occasion, but I have no patience whatsoever with people who have superior attitudes. I have had many, many people in my shop for beginning turning lessons who, while they have reached the pinnacle of their own profession, are rank beginners when they stand in front of the lathe. I always remind them, as with every student, that myself and anyone else they care to name started out as a beginner at this stuff. There are a lot of people who seem to have forgotten from whence they came, and it seems to me, from my experience, that it is most prevalent in the art community. I do not limit this to art turners, since I know a few other artists from other disciplines. Maybe it is an art thing. But I have no patience with people who look down on others for whatever reason, be it race, religion, or turning ability.

I guess someone could come back at me with, "Well Bill, you look down on others who look down on others". No, I just choose not to go places where those people gather, even if there are going to be a healthly group of regulars there as well. My experiences with big names at local symposia and on the internet have taught me that I will probably not enjoy myself in a big gathering. I have met numerous people in the turning world who have been very gracious and friendly. David Ellsworth and I have met more times than I can remember. I worked closely with Albert LeCoff for a long time to help him get his community outreach program off the ground. Bob Rosand has always been friendly and helpful when he has met with our club. But I am not going to waste time or money to hop on a plane, stay in a hotel, to go see someone who is going to teach me to make something and then tell me I had better not be making it if I know what is good for me. I am not going to pay money to spend time with someone who tells me that all I turn is bowls (absolutely not true, but leveled at me from time to time), and I have no need to subject myself to people who are going to find fault with my techniques, shapes, or whatever. Now don't take this last statement as an avoidance of critique. I subject my work to critique all the time, offering it to people who will not hesitiate to tell me what they think, good or bad. But, it is people who I have come to respect, and not just because they will tell me what I want to hear.

Almost all my involvement has been at the local level, and as I said, I enjoy that. There are five groups within an hour of me, and I could attend them all if I chose to do so, and I have been to them all at some time in my turning career. I think Arch has nailed it. You like these things which I don't, and it is bothering you that I don't. That does not make me uninformed, it just makes me unpersuaded. I have never painted everyone with the same brush, but I do not hesitate to offer my opinion. Again, I am not a troublemaker or a firebrand, but I am not one to agree just to make everyone happy.

Bill

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#19

Re: AAW Symposium topics

JamieDonaldson

>I was trained in the art of open debate, and I am not easily offended. A basic premise in logic is that you cannot postulate an answer until you have formulated the question, and that process opens the door for discussion. And John- I don't drink beer but crave my daily coffee fix, so we are on middle ground! I would welcome Bill G. as a worthy neighbor, and the debates would last far into the night. Something about "the unexamined life is not worth living" rings true with me, and "life is a journey, not a destination" also makes the trip more interesting. So much wood, so little time!

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#20

Re: AAW Symposium topics

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Adrien

It is not often that my lexicon trips over my colloquialisms, but you got me. Thanks for the notice on that. ;-)

The next DVD is coming out soon I hope. We are still trying to get together on a time to film it.

Bill

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#21

Re: Craft Trap

Bill Crommett

>I guess I will have to take the STUDIO sign off the garage door and let the pick-up back in during wet weather.

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#22

Re: AAW Symposium topics

Bill Crommett

>I have no business horning in here because my education was at a trade school and not associated with the "arts". One thing that is apprpriate here is to repeat what my astute wife remarked at one of the AAW symposiums where the gallery had a pot covered with beads and painted. The bowl could have been wood, clay, or cast concrete, so the beads were the primary focus. SWMBO said " What is the name of this organization; The American Association Of Whatever??

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#23

Re: Studio?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Now there's a great straight line! Don't have a pickem-up though. Does a trailer made from an old F150 frame count?

|;-}}

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#24

Re: AAW Symposium topics

JamieDonaldson

>That had to be the Symposium in Pasadena CA!!!LOL,LOL

Re: AAW Symposium topics

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: Craft Trap

Keith Tompkins

>HI Maark, I should have been a little clearer in my post. What I meant to say was some people consider themselves craftsmen, and object to the term "artist". It sounded like I was trying to categorize people, didn't mean to. Sorry for the misunderstanding. I'll miss you too!