Re: AAW Symposium topics
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
>Hi Jamie
Well, if you are miffed by negative comments on the AAW, I am sure that I am one of those who have caused you offense, since I made some very pointed comments on the AAW earlier on. I will try to clarify some of what I wrote, since this seems to be an occasion where I was not completely understood, or at least understood as I meant myself to be.
First of all, I do not doubt that your experiences with or perceptions of the AAW are accurate. They are your experiences. In the past I have written of my own experiences with people representing the AAW in various venues - mini symposium, demonstration, etc. While I am not adverse to hyperbole in some of what I write, if I am going to criticize something, I try to be as accurate as possible. You see, I have been snubbed personally, I have been in groups watching a world famous demonstrator(s) talk down to the people in the group in an arrogant and condescending way. I have talked with numerous others who have experienced the same thing, but of course that is hearsay.
On the other hand, virtually every local chapter meeting I have attended has been filled with really great people, friendly, talented, etc. I have been demonstrating since 1995, and I have met many of the big names in turning. Some of these folks have been as down to earth as they can be, and some have not. Like John says, I think people need to be involved at the local level, because that is where things really happen. When our local club started up, I loaned my mini lathe for a year until we had the money to get our own. That meant schlepping it back and forth 40 miles each way for every meeting, being the first in and the last out. I was our newsletter editor twice, and did the initial set up our web page. Then there are the demos I have done, not just at our club, but at many others besides. It has been fun, and while it is a lot of work, I do not see stopping any time soon.
I have been critical of the journal because I think it went way too far towards the art end of things. That is nothing more than my opinion. I also posted (both here and on another forum) when I thought the journal came out with an excellent issue.
I have never been to a national symposium, and I do not know that I will ever go. I am not keen on crowds of any sort, and to be honest, I do not know that I want to spend the money it costs to go somewhere that is going to be an awful lot like what I read in the journal. Again, this is my opinion.
I get numerous emails every week from people who are just starting out and who want advice on what lathe to buy, tools, wood, etc. Virtually every single response I make recommends that the person search out a local chapter of the AAW. So you see, I am not really anti AAW, but I am very much anti some of the attitudes which I have personally experienced. It may be that we have different expectations, or different thresholds of tolerance for certain things, but for you to be miffed at someone like me having a bad experience and reporting on it makes as much sense of me being miffed with you because you had a good experience and reported on it.
Think about it this way. I derive a significant portion of my income through teaching and through the sales of my DVD. It is doing so well that there is going to be a second one filmed as soon as we can get everyone together to do it. What would it gain me to alienate people in my business demographic for no cause? In my previous posts, I mentioned that I had not gotten a lot out of the AAW, and that what I had experienced was a lot of elitism, to use your word. I did not say that it was universal, but it is there, and it exists in some people who would probably deny it if accused by name. Regardless of that, and regardless of your experience, this has been mine. I am truly sorry if it has caused you grief, but I did not post about it just to stir up trouble. I posted to express my frustration with some of the things I have encountered. We are not all the same, and we are not all going to be happy with everything that goes on, but if we are not allowed to express our opinions on the organization for fear of someone else becoming angry, then what is the use of even talking about it at all?
Bill