New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

shape critique needed

Posts

shape critique needed

#1

shape critique needed

Jim Davies, Clayton, NJ

>Far from done but the shpa is what i am questioning. Do not try to guess the wood, it is alabaster stone. I should have mention the base needs to be, and will be smaller. I left it this wide because of all the hard defects in this type of stone. Don't want to chance snapping it off while hollowing it out.

The widest area is about 1/3 down fron the curved area near the top instead of from the overall size of the piece. I guess this is what I am questioning. Should I change the shape and go 1/3 from the top or bottom ( overall size) when doing this type of shape?

Jim D.


img

Re: shape critique needed

#2

Steven Antonucci

My 2 cents- and not even worth that!

steve antonucci

>I think I agree with your assessment that removing ~1/3 from top or bottom would be a good thing. The overall height of the vessel in proportion to the curve right now is odd. I think you could save the size by narrowing the neck by 1/2, and the opening by 1/2, making a more "grecian urn" like style. (And of course, the foot to match...)

2 cents give or take a penny...

Steve

Re: shape critique needed

#3

Re: shape critique needed

GeeSeaWhy

>It does look "wrong", doesn't it? The widest area appears to be just about halfway up. If you try to move the wide point down you end up with a long slender neck, which may not be a great idea in alabaster. I'd go for reshaping the bottom half to move the wide point up, then make the curve towards the neck tighter and bring it in as far as you dare. That would give you the option of losing a little off the top if necessary to improve the proportions.

Good luck,

Graeme