New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

self critic

Posts

self critic

#1

self critic

john Lucas

>I find one of the best things you can do is what I call self critic. You have to be your worst critic. I thought I would try a new shape for me. A larger foot that merges with the bowl. I liked it to a point. I find turning a bowl or vessel upside down helps evaluate problems. To me the foot is too big on this one. I think the bowl would have more lift if I made the foot a little smaller.

Look close. You'll see the curve that comes from the foot toward the lip changes about a 1/3 of the way down from the lip. I don't like this. I want to the curve to be smooth. It can change in shape but in this piece I have created 2 curves that meet at the 1/3 point. It's hard to see something like this when on the lathe and in this piece it's also hard to feel. I didn't notice it until I got it completely off the lathe and had some finish on it.

It's not bad enough to trash obviously. In fact it's already sold but I wanted to shoot it so I could explain the process I go through with each piece. I'll know to look harder at this kind of thing next bowl.


img

Re: self critic

#2

Re: self critic

john Lucas

>I forgot to mention the lip. don't ignore this. I tilted the rim in slightly. I think that was good on this bowl but I don't like how sharp it is on the outer edge. I don't know if rounding it over very slightly would have helped or hurt. I'll look at that on the next bowl.

Re: self critic

#3

Re: self critic

TomW in SouthJersey

>To me it looks more pleasing upside down. On the right side up picture it does look like the foot is too big or else there is nothing on the top to offset the base. I don't have any idea what if anything you could put on top to offset it.

However, the grain and finish are beautiful. I like the sharp lip. I think rounded edges sometimes look like what happend during sanding and not intentionally designed.

But - what do I know.

Tom

Re: self critic

#4

Re: self critic

john Lucas

>Tom Sounds to me like youknow a lot. I agree that if you round an edge it needs to look like you did it on purpose not from poor technique.

Re: self critic

#5

Re: self critic

Brian Gray in Sandusky, OH

>John, I like what you have there...

I think that you need to look at this in one of two ways....

1) Utility bowl that will be used a lot

2) Decorative bowl that will be on a shelf, and not really used.

If it's a utility bowl, I think that you are right on...If I had to force a critique, it would be maybe not a narrower base, but a shorter base...if the bowl is 4 inches high, make it 3 3/4" high, and take the waste off the bottom. I can picture your bowl that way perhaps a little better.

If it's decorative, and will be seen and not used, then go to town with the base....do whatever you want to...

my 2 cents...

Re: self critic

#6

Re: self critic

Barry Irby

>Aha! an chance to pick, pick, pick with reckless abandon!

First, beautiful bowl and great piece of wood just as it is.

If it is a working bowl, the engineer in my says the base if about the right diameter, but too tall. I rolled it up and down on the screen to "crop" the bottom. If it were mine, I would put it back on the lathe and cut the bottom off until I had it a low as I could. I think it will look better and sit better and be a little "tougher".

As an art bowl I would make the foot substantially smaller. An inch or more off the diameter.

Question: wonder what happens with the ogee shape? Doesn't an ogee start vertical and end vertical? I'm not sure that is "necessary" or always true.

On the rim, I like the tilted in rim. I think it makes the bowl look larger and it makes it look like the salad dressing would drain in rather than out after I spilled it. It also makes the wood look thicker, so you have to be careful with it or it can ruin the appearance of a nice thin bowl. It's also easy to "fix" later if the bowl warps, as in turning them green. You can true up a rim with a sanding pad in the drill press if you must.

Re: self critic

#7

Re: self critic

Ruth Niles

>John

Apparently someone thought it was fine enough to purchase!

As to the foot's transition not what you wanted (that 1/3 you mention) I've found if a close my eyes and run my hand down the outside shape and concentrate, I can feel flat spots and where a curve stutters instead of flows. I do this while the turning is still on the lathe and it works best if you shut the lathe off, especially if you're going to close your eyes! : )

You just needed to cut in a little more at the 1/3 mark. But like I said, "someone" thought it was perfect or they wouldn't give you their hard-earned money. Unless it was your Mom: Mom's are like that! : )

Re: self critic

#8

Re: self critic

john Lucas

>Barry

Glad you enjoyed diving into this one. You bring up a good point about the Ogee and I'd like to hear what others think. An ogee on a spindle is quite a bit different than a ogee on a bowl. On a spindle it starts and ends usually with a fillet or partial bead or revese V. With a bowl is starts and ends with air. That means you have to decide how your eye flows out of it. I'm not sure they have to match each other but would be interesting to see. I think the foot should probably end perpendicular to the table it sits on, but it would be interesting to see other angles. If I have time (and maybe the skill) I'll try to change it in photoshop so we can see it both ways.

Re: self critic

#9

Re: self critic

john Lucas

>Ruth

As you know I'm single right now so closing my eyes and running my hands over softly rounded objects is about as much excitement as I can handle. I learned the technique of running your hands from the lip to the base from my friend Joe Looper(who I think learned it from Ellsworth). I try that and usually succeed but this one is really subtle by feel.

I can see my neighbors strange looks when I'm sitting there with my eyes closed gently stroking a new bowl and a smile on my face. They already think I'm strange with the pink flamingos in my front yard.

Re: self critic

#10

Re: Pink Flamingos? In Tenn.? hmmm

Ruth Niles

>

Re: self critic

#11

I Think it's the Ogee

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>If I remember correctly, a classical ogee flows between two parallel lines. As you said, those lines aren't in a bowl turning, but the eye follows the curve and establishes those lines. In your bowl, the top line seems to point out at about 20 degrees and the bottom curve's line is more vertical.

Ruth's comment about scrolling the pictures up and down worked very well for me -- I got it to clip both the top and bottom pictures the same amount. Just above the background shadow on the bottom picture seemed to be about right. And the line that the bottome of the ogee was flowing into was parallel with the top's projected line.

You're also right about having a change in the shape of the curve about 1/3 of the way down the bowl, but it's so smooth that it's hard to detect.

Re: self critic

#12

Re: self critic

Barry Irby

>John, I've been thinking about the ogee. I think they usually occur between parallel lines and also roll ninety degrees in between. I was trying to apply an ogee to something, Can't remember what, but it would never look right until I made it conform. May not apply to a bowl and maybe all ogees are not created equal.

I have made some bowls similar to this and I struggle with the inside VS the outside. I want the inside to be "hemispherical" and not ogee shaped. But I also want the wall thickness to be consistent. That reduces the Ogee to being a foot and much less prominent that yours.

Re: self critic

#13

Re: self critic

john Lucas

>Barry

I settled for the inside being a hemisphere and did not worry about the bowl thickness on this one. This bowl has been drying for almost 2 years so eveness of thickness was not an issue although the only place it's really thicker is right at the curve of the ogee, and of course the feet. The bottm was rounded as a convex to match the inside.

I was really happy with the inside. It is absolutely perfect with no bumps, undulations or uneveness of any kind. That was due mostly to tool control. I was playing with Stewart Batty's push cut and reallly concetrated on letting the tool do the cutting. Consequently there was no tearout at all with a super smooth finish and by using my body to control the handle of the tool was able to get a perfect shape. Not having to use a scraper and starting with 220 grit prevents the bumps associated with sanding summer winter wood or sometimes just hard and soft spots in the bowl.

Re: self critic

#14

Re: Pink Flamingos? In Tenn.? hmmm

john Lucas

>Ruth

I move in on a Saturday. Got up about 5:30 am to go to the carwash to clean my friends truck and trailer that I borrowed. When got back about 6 I had a dozen pink flamingo's in the yard. Still haven't found out who put them there but it's a great landmark when giving directions to the house so I've just left them. The neighbors probably think I'm gay because all they ever see are fellow turners (who are mostly men) coming over to see me. I'm going to have to invite more women turners over.

Re: self critic

#15

Re: self critic

Darrell

>I really think the bowl is fine like it is. The shape could be altered as you said by making the rim slightly less wide to change the curve but I'm not sure it improves the looks of the bowl. Maybe the 2 different curves make the bowl more interesting. Here's the photo altered on the left side to make the curve more rounded--I don't think it is a great improvement.


img

Re: self critic

#16

Re: self critic

Barry Irby

>John, I have got to try this push cut. I've been reading about it. Where can I get the details?

Have you seen the altered picture Darrel posted? I agree with him, I think the bowl looks slightly better but not enough to change it now.

I like to undercut the rim slightly on a working bowl. Just a 1/32" maybe, almost can't see it, but it makes sort of a thumb groove on the inside of the top lip. Makes the bowl much more comfortable to lift.

I have been working on a bowl today that is very strange or at least the blank was. I will post it when it is far enough along.

Re: self critic

#17

endless

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>you wrote: "On a spindle it starts and ends usually with a fillet or partial bead or revese V. With a bowl is starts and ends with air. That means you have to decide how your eye flows out of it."

Bingo! While my bowl making experience is in clay and not wood, my very well trained teacher made this indelible impression on me: your eye needs closure. If the foot has no punctuation and the lip does not either, it looks more like a component than a complete piece. Beads, flaring in or out, or other treatments as you mention will be more satisfying than none.

I like the curves and the wood though.

Re: self critic

#18

PS, Sand Paper

Barry Irby

>You mentioned that starting with 220 helped prevents the lumps and bumps....

This may be a case of using sandpaper like you bought it with someone else's money. I'm sure you know that good sharp sand paper has less tendency to sand out the summer wood that old dull stuff. OTOH, less sand is probably better, period. And I don't enjoy sanding, other than the results.

I've got a post floating around about trying to avoid the tear out inside a bowl, mainly to avoid the sanding. I can power sand it out in a few seconds, but it leaves me with that little dip in the interior. It's always a trade off. If some Improved technique or tool would reduce sanding then I'm ready to try, unless it adds hours and only cuts sanding slightly.

Re: self critic

#19

Re: self critic

john Lucas

>Barry

I'm not really sure how to describe the push cut. I may not be doing the same thing that Stewart does but it looks similar. My gouge is definitely not sharpened the same as his. I will try to take some photos later today or tomorrow. I have to work on a commission piece and my son is here so he can push the button. Bascially it is done with the flute a little up from the 9 oclock position when on the outside of the bowl. His gouge is sharpened by hand at 40 degrees. I think I remember Mark Kauder describing the sharpening technique below.

I also think the main difference is the pressure on the cut. Most people push the cut. Force the cut sounds too harsh but this is sort of what many people do. Use a sharp tool and then try to pay attention to how gently you can be. I try to let the tool cut with just a little pressure and this is often a fairly slow cut especially as you approach the middle of the bowl. Forcing the cut even slightly produces ridges and some tearout.

A good cut is smooth and almost polished much like the skew leaves behind. I started experimenting with this years ago when cutting coves. I always had to sand spindles because the skew cuts were so smooth and the coves were rough. I wanted the coves to match and finally figured out it was the speed of the cut. Even though I thought I was cutting the wood with the spindle gouge I was apparently forcing it to cut and the surfaces just weren't as clean as the skew.

Re: self critic

#20

Re: self critic

Ruth Niles

>Darrell,

I think you're right about the bowl looking better with the top more rounded. Now I can see a flat spot on the right that was so apparent in the original photo.