New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Bowl turning and tear out question.

Posts

Bowl turning and tear out question.

#1

Bowl turning and tear out question.

Barry Irby

>When I turn bowls with the pith of the tree oriented at about 90 degrees to the shaft of the lathe, I get tear out patches near the rim and opposite each other. I am using a bowl gouge with the Ellsworth grind on it. The patches are the end grain I think.

Does anyone have a way to beat this? What tool or technique might work better?

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#2

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

Don Henthorn

>Check out Bill Grumbine's video for a couple of cuts that will largely mitigate this problem. At least on the outside of a bowl. By holding the cutting tool at an approximately 45 degree angle to horizontal in a shearing type cut you can also help greatly with the interior of a bowl. Just go easy until you get the hang of it. Of course someone may answer who who knows what he/she is talking about. (-;

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#3

JL

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

JL

>End grain tear out and bruising. Make sure your gouge is nice and sharp. Follow it up by shear cutting with more of the side of the gouge as opposed to just the tip. Shallow cuts are best. Hopefully someone will chime in with a better description - I can show better than I can describe. Other alternatives are using a sharp scraper (though some people frown on the use of scrapers). I have a nice heavy half round Crown scraper.

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#4

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

John K Jordan

>Sometimes I soak the problem end grain with a sanding sealer, then continue cutting.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#5

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

john Lucas

>John

I do the same thing. Actually all 3 suggestions are useful. Your actually cutting up hill on the grain at 2 places when doing a side grain bowl. For this reason try rotating the gouge to get more of a shear angle, take light cuts, and toughen the wood with sanding sealer, CA glue or whatever. Usually just rotating the gouge to find the best angle works but some woods will just fight you and leave alittle fuzz at these two spots.

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#6

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

Ed Kelle

>This is kind of a basic question, but does using sanding sealer have any effect on the wood as far as when applying an oil finish when done? I have had some issues before when I have used thin CA to seal some small cracks, it sort of stained the surrounding area a bit even though I rubbed some dust on it. And I could not seem to sand out this stain after, even though I tried to use as little glue as possible. So it was still slightly visible after applying the oil finish. I'm probably doing something wrong, so I'm just wondering if I am going to run into similar issues with sanding sealer. I am using cherry most of the time, don't know if that has any bearing on the matter.

Any insights would be appreciated. Thanks

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#7

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

Barry Irby

>If you use thin CA it will soak deeply into the fibers (especially end grain) and seal them. This will prevent them from absorbing the oil of the finish and will most likely be a different color than those not treated with CA. I find this effect to be minimal with lacquer. Also,there is less effect if you use medium or thicker thickness CA to make the repairs of cracks. It does not soak as freely into the fibers and tends to stay in the crack. The crack is going o show anyway. On some pieces, some of us accent the crack or "defect" or you could say, "celebrate" it by intentionally filling it with bark or coffee grounds and CA or even brass fillings or turquoise and CA. Filler is limited only by your imagination and bank account. Gold anyone?

I think "Trick" here is to use something to stiffen the grain that will blend with whatever the finish is going to be.

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#8

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

Russ Fairfield

>There are a lot of things you can do to eliminate grain-tearout on the inside of a bowl.

You can use anything that will fill the grain. Plain water will work in some cases. Johnsons Paste Wax or Trewax are good options that won't interfere with most finishes.

There are also several things you can do with tool technique. There are only two ways to cut the wood, either a shearing cut, or rippong it apart. The objective on end-grain is to make a cut that shears across the graain rather the plow through it.

Using your existing tool, rolling the tool until the flute is facing in a more upward direction will make more of a shearing cut and there will be less tear-out. One way to get the cut started is to hold the flute upwards whehere the tool is riding on the bevel, but isn't cutting. Then roll it into the cut until it starts to cut. This will be more prone to a catch, so it will take a lot of practice to get it right. And it helps to grind away the sharp edge at the heal of the bevel.

The best tool option is to go all the way and grind a convex bevel on the tool. It will solve the problem if you are willing to grind and learn how to use this gouge. Another option is to use a continental-style spindle gouge. I have photos of both being used in the Grinds Library. Either will solve the

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#9

Thanks Everyone

Barry Irby

>I appreciate the time everyone has taken to help.

Russ, this goes to show how little I know about finishes. I would have bet a bunch that wax would have ruined any chance with most any finish. I would also have thought the dish washing detergent some people are soaking in would have hurt the finishes, but apparently not.

I have the Ellsworth grind on a bowl gouge. I make the cut you are describing. The flute is nearly vertical and I roll the left wing into the inner surface of the bowl. I works swell, but not perfectly. I still get a small patch of tear out on each side. Is this a case of none or less than a lot if you do it well?

Incidentally, is the famous Push Cut that is making the rounds?

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#10

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

John K Jordan

>>does using sanding sealer have any effect on the

>wood as far as when applying an oil finish

I don't think so, but when I use it I usually just put it all over the piece which would eliminate any one spot looking different. I also used other things on tearout such as oil itself and wax (I use Renascence wax). And I agree with the need for very sharp tools.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#11

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

Ed Kelle

>Thanks Barry, I will use the thicker CA from now on and see how that goes. I tried some sanding sealer yesterday and that seemed to help a bit also. I used water based sealer, so I will have to wait and see how it reacts with an oil finish later.

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#12

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

Ed Kelle

>Thanks John, I will treat the entire surface next time. Yesterday I just hit the end grain areas, but it did seem to help.

Just another question, you mentioned wax, did you mean during the turning process as opposed to the sealer, or did you mean as a finishing process to fill in any tears?

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#13

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question. Russ?

Ruth Niles

>Have you ever used or seen Stuart Barry's negative scraper or scraping grind? I watched him use it, grind it, passed it around, I held it, inspected it; came home, tried the gind (simple enough) it didn't work like it did for him. It's supposed to be the easiest for doing the shear cut with the gouges (which is what I do now).

Any thoughts?

Ruth

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#14

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question. Russ?

Russ Fairfield

>We always forget that there is a learning curve behind everything we see being done at a demonstration. Someone can show us a tool or technique, and they can sell us the tool, but they can't give us the years that it took for them to learn how to use it, or the ability to duplicate and maintain the profile that they were using.

To answer Ruth's question, yes, I have ground and tried the negative scraper. And, like Ruth, I have never been able to make it do anything for me. It is less prone to catching on the inside of a bowl, and that would make it a better tool for a beginning woodturner.

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

#15

Re: Bowl turning and tear out question.

Bill Crommett

>ED: I have found that when filling a crack with CA and dust that a quick shot of spray lacquer over the area will prevent much of the CA from discoloring the adjacent wood.