New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Louisville, Part 2

Posts

Louisville, Part 2

#1

Keith Tompkins

Louisville, Part 2

Keith Tompkins

>In response to Jim Shaver's comments on the last thread, I started a new thread. I'll paraphrase Jim's questions: If you attended a national symposium, what subjects would you like to see. Why?

Here's my take.....as noted, the demonstrations usually involve surface treatments, segmenting, carving, or other topics not neccessarily related to turning. I think part of this is due to the fact that prominent turners will draw a big crowd. The audience wants the demonstrator to show the techniques that brought them to the "top tier" in the first place.

My problem with this is: 1. Learning lots of techniques is always a good way to expand one's horizons, but they do NOT deal with a turner's underlying problems. As a result, we see lots of poorly executed forms that are scorched, textured, pierced, etc. A closer look may reveal torn grain, sanding marks, and little regard to form.(this does not apply to anyone on this site, just a personal observation)

2. I feel that applying many of these techniques to your work could be considered "derivative", stemming from someone else's ideas. Not a big deal, unless you are attempting to develop your own style. I have been asked why my forms are not pierced, for example. Simple...Why should I pierce a particular piece? Just because it's a popular thing to do? Just because turner "X" does? I see lots of pierced pieces, and in many cases, it detracts rather than adds to the overall effect. Kinda like being in a Beatles "cover" band; no matter how good you are, it doesn't really matter.....it's already been done.

This is why I started doing the form and design demos in the first place....as a way of developing design skills AND technical skill together. If a turner has a good foundation in both, they will progress at a much faster rate. On the other hand, if one set of skills is weak, its often a long, slow progression.

That is why I like "pure" forms, even though I tend to make elaborate pieces. Stripped of all of the fancy techniques, the form remains. A piece should succeed or fail based on the form.

What demos would I like to attend? Threading....lots of fun. Photography....you've seen my photos. ... Promoting your work...maybe I should GIVE that one. LOL!

Last,Jim asked: should AAW members have a say in who gives the demos, and the topics covered ? Ultimately, we probably do....a bad evaluation pretty much takes care of that....Your thoughts?

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Russ

Keith Tompkins

>Russ, you are definitely NOT a third tier turner! I think the problem is related to the "cool" factor. Spindle turning is out of favor at this time, although we both know how important spindle turning is. Sadly, if the panel has to choose between spindle turning and prismacolors, spindle turning will lose.

Design is a risky topic, to be sure. How did I convince the AAW to let me do a design demo in the first place?(2004) At the national level? I received a phone call about my design talk, they were interested, but skeptical. NOBODY succeeds in a talk on form. Why do you think your demo will work?

This is what I said. The AAW board is striving to bring woodturning into the larger field of ART. If you in intend to do that, then someone had better start paying attention to what the other craft and art fields are doing. Do you think you can ignore the basics of form and design, and still elevate the status of turning? I don't think so. We as turners are ignoring what other craft and art forms have taken for granted for thousands of years.

Concepts of design will be commonplace in turning instruction in a few years, whether you believe it or not. I intend to be a part of that movement. I guess it worked.

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#3

Re: Russ

Ruth Niles

>I was going to respond to Russ's post in the first "Louisville" thread but decided to do it here.

First, Russ, your demo on finishes and glues at last year's Totally Turning Symposium in Albany was one of the most interesting I've ever attended. If you remember, people were coming into the room for the next demo and we didn't want to let you go!

Quote of what Russ posted: "As for the topics, I have been told that there was insufficient interest in finishing, square bowls, and spindle turning of any kind, and that design was too controversial a topic for the Symposium."

Last year at the Provo show, Tommy Sorensen, professional spindle turner (architectural reproduction artist!) had 4 demos and they were all filled; I stopped in for each. There are an awful lot of "working turners"; making table legs, porch posts, chair spindles, etc. Not everyone who has a lathe is aspiring to be in Del Mano. I know I'm preaching to the choir!

Personally, I like the Instant Gallery, meeting and talking with all the turners, the Vendors area (THE most fun place!) and after the show sitting down and having a beer with fellow turners.

Ruth

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#4

Re: Russ

Russ Fairfield

>Ruth,

Could it be that the folks at Provo are more in tune with us woodturners than the AAW??

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#5

Re: Russ

RonZ

>I think you're right Russ. While I haven't been to the AAW symposium, I get their videos. This is one reason why I prefer many British articles, demos, and instructors.There is more of a focus on tradtional turning, especialy spindle vs the US.

I see what Keith brought up as a local [Israeli] problem, too. Many people would like Delahon, Escouleon, Priddle, etc. yet their basic turning skills need serious help and I wonder when many of these turners would ever implement what they would learn from these turners. IMHO if you want a performance, buy a tape. When I was at the Utah symposium this year, my decisions to watch a particular turner was based on the thought 'will this be applicable to my work or work that I plan on doing and is it marketable.'

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#6

Re: Russ

Russ Fairfield

>Keith,

I think that the AAW is only interested in butts in the seats. Every demonstration I have ever been to or given on design concepts had a very enthusiastic audience. Yes, the numbers of people were smaller, but large numbers of people has nothing to do with the amount or quality of information exchanged. One person who learns something is far better than a room full who were only entertained.

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#7

Re: Russ

Russ Fairfield

>I have long suspected that any reluctance to talk about design and form is more about arrogance and status than anything else. If the ability to "see" good form is something we either have or we don't, that is the implication that there is a special class of artists with a unique ability. Heaven forbid that design and form should ever be taught to the masses. Next thing, they'll be wanting to take over.

I am always amazed by how many of the elite among woodturners see no connection or relavance with pottery and other art forms.

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#8

Re: Russ

Phil Powell

>Russ,

I've been traditional potter for more years then I want to admit to. I'm now

making the jump to woodturning after retirering from teaching. To say that

there is a similarity between the two crafts is an understatement. My bowls

are highly influenced by pottery froms that I've made and marketed for so

many years. Bowl makers could learn a great deal by picking up a pottery

book and studying the photos. Pottery is, maybe, the oldest craft known and

little has changed. Forms are refined, technical information is expanding, but

forms and designs change so little. Someone much more respected then me

once said, "Form follows function".

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#9

Re: Louisville, Part 2

John Lucas

>I think the AAw is stuck trying to please too many people. I went to as many of the "art" or design type demos as I could and they were never full. I also went to one on getting work into galleries, it wasn't full. I won't say that the AAW is just trying to fill seats they are simply trying to put together demos that the masses want.

Lets face it the greatest majority of turners want to have fun and make a nice piece and really don't want to listen to a guy talking about the Golden Rectangle. I know that sounds negative and they really go want to improve thier work they just don't want to sit through an art appreciation class to do so. I do enjoy it and know other who do but I think we are in the minority. It's already been said but spindle turning and classes on pure technique don't do well either.

I went to furniture society meeting several years back and they not only fill the deep philosophical discussion demos but there is very spirited debate and discussion. This never happens at local symposiums. When you look at the critics sent in to symposiums there are always 2 compaints. There's too much time spent on fancy techniques and painting, and There's too much time spent on basics with not enough fancy techniques. How do you please both. It's tough.

I think mainly we just have to make ourselves heard and hope that there are enough of us to bring out demos like Keith is talking about.

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#10

Re: Russ

Dave Fuqua

>The pottery to turning comparison is extremely interesting to me. Both involve spinning a material, shaping it inside and out, using different methods of finishing (or none at all), and involve specialized tools that the artists can buy or make thier own. The results vary widely and whether you like some particular style, shape, glaze, etc., often is a matter of personal taste. I suspect they have their own preferences for glazes, types of clay, etc. that turners have for which woods they like, finishing techniques, etc.

I think it would be great if we had some turners who had also done more than a little pottery work, or even some ceramic artists post something on the similarities between the two. Just a thought. . .

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#11

sharon in topanga

Re: Wood turning and pottery

sharon in topanga

>I am a very beginning turner, and have not actually made pottery, other than when I was a kid many moons ago. However, when I first turned a bowl, I was immediately struck by the similarities between the two art forms.

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#12

pottery book suggestion?

Bob Elliott

>Phil,

Could you suggest a pottery book?

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#13

Re: pottery book suggestion?

Phil Powell

>Bob,

I of my favorites is a book by "Lucy Rie" she's an old time

English potter. She made potts for years. Her book is

mostly photos and the forms translate almost straight

accross. I'll dig up the book's the name. Right now everything

is packed in my garage. Just use her name to find the book.

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#14

And You're Not Going to Kansas???

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Ruth,

You sound like my kind of Symposium goer! Next year in Louisvile we'll have to introduce ourselves, do some gabbing and have that beer!

: )

Jen

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#15

Re: pottery book suggestion?

Phil Powell

>I was thinking about the book question. Barnes & Noble or any equal

book store will have several books or pottery that could be useful to

a turner. There are many more titles with great photos besides "Lucy

Rie". I'll have a look in my collection.

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#16

Brad Vietje

One is additive; one subtractive

Brad Vietje

>Pottery is an additive process .. you add and shape the clay until you have what you want. Turning is a subtractive process -- you remove all the wood that isn't going to be part of the finished form. Of course, many woodturners add pieces together, as in segmented work and stacked laminations, but then they go and remove wood again to achieve the final form...

turning may not be additive, but it CAN be addictive !

Otherwise, very similar in many respects.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#17

Re: One is additive; one subtractive

John Lucas

>Brad I had that very discussion with a ceramic artist the other day.

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#18

Re: Musing about design and all that

Arch

>Down thru the years, the organizations that I've belonged to that flourished, followed pretty much the same path. At the beginnng a small group with common interests later became larger and multi- faceted. The few began doing the things that the many didn't want to do re operating the association and making it prosper. Although they enjoy 'running things' they are needed and we are glad of them, but we reserve the right to gritch, which is inevitable. "You can please some of the people some of the time, but not all of the people all of the time" applies to AAW, but the pendulum always swings and can make room to seat all of us in diverse demos. AAW, of course, is about much more than filled seats.

Certainly without acceptable forms and pleasing designs, woodturning cannot mature and become accepted as 'object art' and it's a 'performing art' only in the eyes of other turners. How many of us spend time and money acquiring good tools and learning great techniques only to rely on hope to turn fine objects.

We are a very generous and sharing lot, but I've noticed that the 'craft' is more generously shared than the 'art' I, for one, applaud Keith, Russ and others here for their attitude toward teaching and learning good design.

OK choir... end of sermon...you can wake up now.

Ponderously, Arch

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#19

Re: pottery book suggestion?

Mac

>Take a look at "Ceramic Form" by Peter Lane.....excellent source book. Got mine on Amazon for roughly $20 I think....enough pictures to keep you busy for years....

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#20

Re: And You're Not Going to Kansas???

Ruth Niles

>Jennifer, I'm going to miss seeing a lot of friends, especially Molly, in KC, but I just couldn't do it.

Tenn, next year, 2 beers, you got it!

Ruth

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#21

Re: Louisville, Part 2

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Kieth,

I guess making every one happy might be impossible, but while working out sid etoday I started to think, does teh AAW have any Special Interests Groups? My thought was that if SIG's did exist in the AAW, perhaps we might be able to get some imput fromm the paying membership in what they want to see, rather than to have what I see today.

Honestly, when I looked at this years list of presentations I blocked off a few that I must see, and the rest were a process of elimination of which was the elast interesting. I can say of the 12 or 13 sessions, 4 were relavent to me. I think what Ruth wrote might give me better cause to go to Utah, but I will give Louisville a shot.

My turning club is excellent, but I know I feel like the spare tire when it comes to my own turning interests. The direction I see in turning and what teh AAW seems to be promoting is leaving me behind in what I'd like to achieve. I respect those who are in the mainstream of this process, the work is simply outstanding...the people are all top shelf!

Take care,

Jim

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#22

Re: Louisville, Part 2

GeeSeaWhy

>Design and form is too controversial a subject for a demonstration?! Not unless it degenerates into a fistfight. I would rather take part in a lively discussion of design than sit politely through a presentation on another way of decorating turnings. Such demonstrations always look interesting but when I get home and try it two things happen: first I find that it isn't as easy as it looked and second my first efforts are very derivative because I can't think past the particular designs demonstrated. The only way to really learn how to use a technique is practice, preferably on pieces that would otherwise be rejects. And demonstrations of basic tool use are not terribly useful either - no matter how hard I try to pay attention, I get home and cannot remember exactly what the demonstrator was trying to show. For me, the only way now to improve my technique is one on one instruction until it finally sinks in.

Keith, I'll see you in Albany.

Graeme

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#23

Re: Louisville, Part 2 (too long response!)

Ruth Niles

>Graeme, you expressed my sentiments exactly. I really don't care for actual turning demos because you can't see what the turner is doing, you're sitting in front of the lathe, he's turning from behind, so you watch the tv monitor (better to watch a video at home you can stop and/or rewind). There is no way you can learn their turning techniques unless you held the tool and they stood behind you with their hand on yours for angle of tool, pressure of cut, how they "slightly roll" the tool or whatever.

I believe 90% of the audience just want to see that demonstrator in person and watch them make chips fly (me included, we are so easily entertained!). I love to watch Allan and Stuart Batty turn, they are so relaxed with the lathe and tools, funny guys and really know their stuff.

Last year I went to the Orlando Symposium, I had a LOT of fun and paid $0.00......... I didn't register for any rotations or the dinner/auction. Now I was visiting my sister in Orlando so no room cost either. I enjoyed every minute, every day just as much as I did in RI where I paid full amount, attended every demo/presentation I could and tried to absorb the Instant Gallery in between. In Orlando I went through the Instant Gallery unrushed and whenever I wanted. I learned techniques, about new tools, jigs, etc. because that's where the pros gather between their demos and love to talk shop. The vendor area can keep you busy for 2 days! I learned a lot more there, watching professional turners demonstrating products and techniques where you can stand behind them, ask questions, some even hand you the tool and let you use it while they give tips. This is another area where you can talk casually to any and all the turners. *note: I am not suggesting this for everyone, someone has to pay for all those demonstrators and I will be paying and attending rotations in Louisville; especially Keith's. : )

Please don't get me wrong, the carving, dying, piercing demos are interesting but, personally, I'd rather learn any technique I'm interested in adding to my turnings from a class, book or video.

Please remember all of this is My opinion and not to be taken seriously!

Ruth

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#24

Ruth, I think you mean KY :D

RevDoug

>

Re: Louisville, Part 2

#25

Re: One is additive; one subtractive

RevDoug

>I have a friend in NC who is a profesional potter. Has been for 25 years or so. He and I had this discussion the last time we were together. We both had to admit that what the other does is difficult for us. In other words, he cannot see a bowl in a log. He couldn't even imagine how in the world I even get started. I, on the other hand, cannot picture a clay piece in my mind and then mold a lump of clay into that shape.

One thing that we did agree on was that he has more shots at getting it right than I do. If I go through the side or bottom it is over for that chunk of wood. He has the opportunity to add some more clay, or even start over. Even his scrap clay can be added back to the reserve and put to use later in another piece. My scrap is destined for the compost pile and ultimately the garden.

We also agreed that too many woodturners, and potters alike, pay little if any attention to shape. In fact, he was amazed I knew anything about shape, design, golden mean/triangle, etc. It a fun discussion with a friend, someone from another art form, a proven artisan who had definate ideas on design and usable form.

Turn 'em round