New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

Posts

'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

#1

'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

Arch

>Are there objective differences or just strongly held personal preferences about the shape of deep fluted gouges? Do different shaped flutes work best for different applications? Limit your opinions to deep flute shapes aka bowl gouges, altho IMO not a descriptive term. Omit discussing bevels, edges, grinds, steels, or handles and whether milled or forged.

Sometimes I'm the last to know, but what I would like is a list/chart of the different brands of deep flute gouges with their shapes, their reasons for being and the unbiased opinions of experienced turners who have used several. If this info already exists in one place, please tell me where.

Many TIAs, Arch

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

#2

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

John Trant (Baltimore/DC area)

>I like the V flute as my primary tool becasue it shears nicely (like a very small skew chisel), but I prefer the U shape (and a short bevel) when I get down to the transition between the sice and bottom of the inside of the bowl. With this said, I have turned bowls and platters with a single gouge of either shape.

My $0.02

John

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

#3

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Arch,

My opinion: I like U shaped flutes (Like Sorby) for cutting with the wings and shear cutting. They see seem to evacuate the chips from the flute better than those that are more V shaped (Like Glaser and P&N)which seem to get packed up with chips during these same operations.

It seems to me that the V shaped gouges are better suited to cutting with the nose of the gouge, or very light shear scraping where you are producing "Feathers" of wood.

Just my opinion.

Mark

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

#4

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

john Lucas

>Mark took the words right out of my mouth. perhaps I was using it wrong but I had trouble with the chips clogging the flute on the V shaped gouge. They seem to role out better on the U.

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

#5

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

Russ Fairfield

>A good question. There are some strong feelings about which is the best flute profile, and I have seen woodturners almost come to blows over this question.

You ask for objective reasons? Never. We learn to use what we have, and then stand around and argue that that it is the only way to do it

I believe in equal opportunity among flute profiles. There is no "best" shape. Each has its advantages for different turning situations. The "U" shape clears the chips better. The "parabolic" is the most adaptable to tool profiles with a smaller tip radius and a long side-grind. The "V" is the only flute shape available with the most wear resistant tools we can buy, and that is reason enough to use the tool for abrasive woods and bark, regardless of the shape of its flute.

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

#6

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

Duane C.Leach

>It has ben my experience that the wider U shaped deep flutes alow the chips to flow out more easily in any direction. On the other hand the narrow flutes clog up frequently, but they are stronger. Less steel was removed to form the narrow flutes, that means more mass. Also with the deep narrow fluted gouge the cutting edge can be shaped almost straight, and that for me alowes a cleaner shear cut.

If you are in doubt, test drive both styles, see what works best for you. Keep this in mind, what works for me or Joe the pro may not work as well for you.

In the end it comes down to personal preference. Becasue their ain't no such thing as the perfect tool.

I hope this helps.

Happy turning.

Duane

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

#7

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

Lowell Converse

>Methinks Russ is right again. I suspect that any of the turnere in this thread could pick up a sharp bowl gouge of any flute shape, or even grind, and turn quite well with it.

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

#8

Prefer "U"...

Peter Teubel

>I purchased a Glaser with a V shaped flute. I liked everything about the gouge except for the flute shape. Clogged up too easily. Ended up selling it. I prefer my U bowl gouges.

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

#9

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

Rick Allen

>Hi Arch

I have a colection of 7 different brands of 1/2" (5/8" diameter steel) bowl gouges. All of these gouges are sharpened using the same Sorby jig with the same jig setting.

A friend and I had the same question. So we mounted a hunk of curly maple on the lathe, tured it up and tried each of the gouges in turn. My friend has a very specific angle of attack when he uses a bowl gouge while rideing the bevel. I am more of a hunt for the sweet spot bowl gouge user.

After trying all the gouges we had eliminated 3 of the seven as being less desirable. He prefered 3 gouges and I prefered 3 gouges. 2 of the gouges we both prefered. On inspection of the flutes we determined that the shape of the flute had no bearing on our preference.

Thanks

Richard

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

#10

the next question

GaryG in MD

>Rick,

You left us hanging. Which two BGs were the ones you both preferred? The fact that the shape of the flute wasn't the deciding factor makes this question even more interesting. Clearly there is something about these two that provides the qualities you were both looking for. And the answer is.....

Gary

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: 'U's, V's & 'parabola's. Deep into flutes

Brad Vietje

>I almost always agree with John, and so I do again...

I think we can all agree that a "U" shape clears the curly-Q's better, especially with wet/green wood, but a "V" shape, or real small radius tip is hard to beat for getting the smoothest cut on real hard, dry wood. The tiny radius produces less resistance to cutting the wood, and less vibration. Th narrow-tip geometry allows a tip radius like a 1/4" gouge on a 1/2" or 5/8" shaft, so it can work real well. For the same reason, all other factors being equal (shape, bevel, sharpness...) I think I can get a cleaner cut off a 1/4" gouge than a 3/8", 3/8 better than 1/2", etc... the larger gouges sure are superior when reaching very far over the rest, though.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT