New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

Posts

More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

#1

More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

Barry Irby

>I jumped in on someone else's thread and posted a question on Coring with the McNaughton system. I want to thank those who answered, particularly Gary and Joe. It's gotten so far down that I wanted to bring it back to the top.

I just went out and laid out my cutters on circles I drew. I have one that "fits" a 7" circle, 11" and a 16". I say "fits" because it's certainly not exact.

Most of the 7" one fits on a fairly smooth radius but the tip with the cutter turns out about 3/16" and so does the curve at the handle end. That is, the first and last inch "flair" outward.

The 11" one follows the curve, but has a bump or bulge in it so that it touches on the inside at one point, but between that and the tip, the curve is about a 1/16" hing and then it flairs toward the handle.

On the larger one, the knife follows the 16" radius for about 2/3 of it's length and then flairs out about an inch.

It seems to me you guys are right. The arc of these knives must be a segment of a circle. The knife must be bent in such a way that the blade will follow the tip and that the blade must lie in the path cut by the tip. If the tip is 3/8" wide and the blade of the knife is about a 1/4" then I shod be able to draw an inner circle and an outer circle 3/8 inch apart and the knife should lie between them. Otherwise, the cutter or tip is not clearing a path for the shaft and it must bind.

Did I get that right?

Wonder if I some how bent these knives or did they come the way they are? I would like to look at a new set to see if they are like mine. Has anyone ever compared two or three sets to see how accurately they are bent from the factory?

Why is it important the tip align with the handle. So you know where it is or does it have to do with the cutting?

Should I try to bend mine as Gary did or should I contact McNaughton? I doubt I can bend the tip of my smaller one in tighter. I would have to straighten the curve to make the tip lie in the path. Might end up as an eight inch radius.

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

#2

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>The tip must be in line with the handle. If it isn't the blade will will twist and bind in the direction of the tip. After you bend the blade to a perfect circle, you can line up the tip by bending the blade where it already has the sharp bend or "crook" in it. My large blade was not right when I bought it and bound before I bent it. Some of the other blades have tips that don't line up like yours but I have lived with it since they are in the large set and can't be bent.

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

#3

Brad Vietje

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

Brad Vietje

>Hey Gary,

I'm not yet convinced... I own one of these systems, but have only used it a little (need a bigger lathe -- working on that !) I know the height of the cutting tip is critical -- too low and it will bind badly.

I have a friend who uses the McNaughton system all the time -- all sizes, both left- and right-handed knives (for coring toward the headstock, as well as toward the tailstock). He prefers his handles bent rather abruptly at the handle end. If you imagine looking from the handle end, he bends the handle of the standard, inboard knives sharply to the left. He only uses the handle for the largest set of knives, and holds the knife by hand for almost all cooring operations.

I think if the toolpost and knife guide are set up properly, and the handle (human) end is lifted up against the retaining pin to allow the guide to do its work, it should not bind unless an inadequate kerf is left, or if the cutter is working below center.

I don't see that the handle end makes any difference -- am I missing something ?

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

#4

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Brad,

Good point, even an eight of an inch low and I can tell the difference. It must be centered. And thinking about the tip being in line with the handle, logicaly, I think you are right. The knife is being torqued no matter where the handle is. It does give you an idea of where the tip is as you progress through the blank though.

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

#5

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

Barry Irby

>Gary and Brad, thanks again for the response and information.

I also wonder if the alignment of the tip with the sharp bend in the hand is critical? How would the tip and the post even "Know" where the handle is?

I have been wondering about the orientation of the steel itself. It seems that the "strap" or or bar of the blade might ought to stand vertical, or should it? That means the tip has to cut a path wide enough to allow clearance for the lower outer edge on the outside and the upper inner edge on the inside. If you grind away the profile of the strap to make it fit in the circular slot in the blank better, then the posts would not be as snug and the strap would roll over.

Also, what about the cutting angle on the tip? Should the edge lie on a radius to the circle or should it be skewed across the path of the cut? Does it matter?

Back before I bought my McNaughton System I invented one and talked to a machinist about actually making it. My thought was that the knife should be a section of a sphere cut out on a taper so that it was small at the tip and wider at then handle. Worked out a pivot that would swing the knife to travel on its own radius. Was going to support it with both the tool rest and tail stock. Maybe I should look at that again.

Another question. Has anyone ever cut a blank out completely and had it go flying? I have not, but have come close. What happens? I thought about bringing the tail stock up, but somehow that seems like it might be worse. Something else for it to get tangled up in and bind.

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

#6

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

Greg Jensen

>There are alot of questions so I will attempt to answer them.

Does the tip have to be in line with the shank. No, it is simply a reference to where the tip is in the bank. The force of clock wise rotation of the blade during cutting is absorbed by the pins in the tool post head.

Can you bend the shank of the handle without effecting the performance of the tool. Yes, the relationship of the shank to the blade and tip are not critical. I would caution against bending the blades because you might weaken the steel with repeated bending. If you bend the blade at the tip you can fracture the hardface on the tip permanently damaging the blade. Large blade can not be bent. It would require heating the blade which will damage the temper and ruin the blade

Blade hieght is critical. You must be at center at the end of the cut. I extend the blade completely and then check against a center reference like the point of my live center, adjusting tool post hieght until I am at center. I use a motor shaft collar on the tool post column lowering the motor shaft collar until it rests on the top of the banjo. This sets my tool post hieght so I do not have to check it ever time I use the center saver.

Can you cut the coreout loose completely? Will the core out go flying. Yes, you can cut it out completely the core out will simply fall to the floor away from you on the back of the lathe. This said I normally do not cut them out completely because I am to lazy to pick them up. I cut until the coreout is flexable then using the but of my handle I hit the coreout on the rim and it pops loose.

Greg Jensen

North American Rep for Kelton Tools

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

#7

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

Barry Irby

>Greg, Thanks for the response. Wood Central is a great resource! Getting responses from fellow users is a tremendous resource and having factory Rep's on line with us makes it even better.

I had already considered that bending any of the knives near the tip might shatter it. I use a support collar under the tool post to keep the height right. I also don't like the idea of cutting the core out completely. My lathe is against a wall with a shelf overhanging. I didn't like the idea of the blank crashing around in the confined space.

Are all the knives bent consistently? If it is important to have them bent on a radius, why aren't they? My two smaller ones are not off a lot, but they are off an 1/8" or more. The large knife is bent on a radius for about two thirds it's length and then essentially straightens out. Seems that that tends to render the last third useless, making it difficult to core large blanks. This strikes me as peculiar. The point of a center saver system is to save wood. Why make one that requires hagging away wood to use it when bending the same knives a little differently would make them easier to use and save wood?

I started making my Plexiglas aiming device to help me overcome the fear I would ruin the outer/larger bowl. I believe part of the problem is that the inconsistent nature of the bends makes the knives more unpredictable than they should be. An example would be on my smaller knife the cutting edge is out of line with the shaft and I suspect that causes the knife to sort of side slip as it goes, because one side of the shaft would be rubbing.

I was considering buying more knives or differing sizes, but have struggled with these to the point I was put off. I am distressed that I cannot bend the larger knife myself (spring steel?), it appeared to be the easiest one to "fix". I also don't like the whole concept of buying them only to learn they are not bent as well as they could be and that I should fix them to start with. Would McNaughton consider re-bending these knives better? Would they send me a different set bent better? Are the new sets improved in their shape?

I just recommended this set up to several people and I know one of them is waiting for his order. I hope his are shaped better than mine.

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

#8

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

Greg Jensen

>If you like send the blades in question to me and I will compair them to new stock. If they are incorrect I will replace them.

Sending them to New Zealand to rebend them would be cost prohibitive.

Greg Jensen

7521 Green Valley Drive

Parma, Ohio 44134

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

#9

Re: More on McNaughton Coring Questions.

Barry Irby

>Greg,

Thanks, that's a great offer. How about if I trace them and mail you the tracing? That way I won't have to be without my beloved knives while the mail lets you decide. Never know when the urge might strike me to do some important or even emergency center saving. If it turns out they are correct, you can e-mail me and toss the tracing. If some of them are wrong, I can send those to you and you can replace them. Deal?

Either let em know here or e-mail me. Thanks again.