New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Louisville.....

Posts

Louisville.....

#1

Keith Tompkins

Louisville.....

Keith Tompkins

>I have decided not to attend the national symposium this year....just too busy. However, my application as a demonstrator in Louisville, KY. goes in the mail tomorrow! These are the topics I have proposed....of course, there is no guarantee my proposals will be accepted....

1. Woodturning form and design. I've been doing this demo for almost two years. It's been very well received, I've been invited back several times after this demo.

2. Turning the Rose: A new demo, the first time I've shown how I make one of these.

Do these sound like good topics to you?

Re: Louisville.....

#2

Re: Louisville.....

john Lucas

>Keith I'm saving my money for Louisville as well. I guess I had better decide if I want to try and be a demonstrator and get that in the mail. I've had too many pans on the fire this year and keep getting behind with things.

Re: Louisville.....

#3

Re: Louisville.....

CapeMayMike

>Keith,

I sat in on your Form and Design last October in Albany. A very worthwhile and thought provoking presentation. It opened my eyes to some things and gave me lots to think about. I'd recommend it to anyone interested in opening some doors and broadening their thought process.

Re: Louisville.....

#4

Re: Louisville.....

Duane C.Leach

>Hi keith.

The design and form are great topics and will make a great demonstration at the symposium. All the folks here liked your demo on it.

Making the rose might be to small an item for some folks to want to learn how to do. But maybe if you made a larger version of it it would draw more intrest.

Good luck

Duane Leach

Re: Louisville.....

#5

Re: Louisville.....

Ruth Niles

>Keith,

Both sound very good to me. I missed your demonstration in Albany last year but heard all good comments from those who did attend your demonstrations. I'd love to see how you do the rose and form and design are always of great interest.

Ruth

Re: Louisville.....

#6

Re: Louisville.....

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Keith,

I plan on coming to Louisville next year, what ever you teach will be fine with me, it will be my pleasure to meet you and sit and learn.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Louisville.....

#7

Re: Louisville.....

Bruce Wiseman

>Keith,

I partly agree with Duane, I enjoyed your form and design discussion when you were in Indy and would attend it again. (I'm a slow learner!) Where Duane and I differ: I would also enjoy a demo on the rose. I think it is a natural progression from the form discussion on spirals generated out of the golden mean and it is thinking outside of the box...er..bowl...or whatever.

Regards,

Bruce

Re: Louisville.....

#8

Re: Louisville.....

RevDoug

>Keith, I am a member of LAW (Louisville Area Woodturners) and have every intention of being there. I would like to see both of these. Your roses have interested me since the first one that I saw. Your contributions to the design discussions that have taken place here, and other places, have been very insightful. I hope that the powers that be accept both ideas and I will plan to be at both.

Turn 'em round

Re: Louisville.....

#9

Re: Louisville.....

Mike Schwing from Md.

>DAMMIT! Will miss you in KC. But wait till you see what I'm making for Louisville....

Re: Louisville.....

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Louisville.....

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks for the input...I appreciate it. I touched on the subject of form and design in Orlando. I was warned up front....discussions on form are risky topics; a demo at the national level that is not well received will END your demonstration career.

My demo's in Orlando were audited by two board members, and I spotted some well-known faces in the crowd.....AND the video equipment malfunctioned...no pressure at all!!!!

Sample evaluations sheets were mailed to all demonstrators; I was very happy with mine, so I'm encouraged to try a serious form and design demo this time. Realistically, this is a tough sell....basic design principles really, but out of line with what is commonly accepted as woodturning gospel. Seems this subject makes some people uncomfortable.

Duane, you are correct, the rose is very small, so I'll have to turn a larger sample for the demo, and probably include slide close-ups. I have a year to really nail down this demo.

It would be great to meet some more of my WC friends there!....hey John Lucas...hurry up, get that application in!

Re: Louisville.....

#11

Re: Louisville.....

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hey Keith,

Well It'll be fine, are the AAW board members kind of stuffy...I get that feeling sometimes when I read about events etc.

Well, I guess you can't answer that, can you??!!

:-)

Sorry, but it's a preception I get, a bit political.

take care,

Jim

I'll never be giving a talk at the AAW now, eh!

Re: Louisville.....

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Louisville.....

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Jim, I guess things can get political, but I think the main objective for an aaw symposium is to provide the best demonstrators available....it is certainly not cheap to attend one of these events. So, I imagine the proposals are well screened to weed out weak demos.

The evaluation forms are taken very seriously, and there is a "tier" system in place. Big name turners are the top tier, the rest are second tier. It's known in advance who will appear on the aaw video, for example. I guess I'll find out soon enough if I'm selected!

Re: Louisville.....

#13

Keith, Some Thoughts

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Keith,

You are a Top Tier Guy to me....

I guess part of me questions the AAW process, a big name to me does not always mean it's deserved...some time popularity clouds the vision...is there a process where Big Named people drop down a notch...can AAW members request certain techniques and methods be demonstrated?

I looked over the KC list of topics, I felt there was a serious absence of spindle type topics...and a huge focus on texturing. colouringa the like..my thoughts.

Can you give us an idea how topics make it to the listing, I would love to be able to vote for some things with my admission fee and annual fee to the AAW, somehow I feel something is missing..

Now, I' a furniture guy, granted..but really there is a huge place for turning in the furniture world...but I don't see it in the AAW schedule.

I have approached my local Lee Valley store to teach turning elements for furniture...it has been well recieved and I am putting a ciriculum together with the store rep for classes......I can see plenty of oppertunity for this...

I respect your thoughts and opinions on this Keith,

Take care,

Jim

Re: Louisville.....

#14

Re: Louisville.....

Russ Fairfield

>With all of the rejection notices I have received, I must be among the "weak" or in the 3rd tier that Keith didn't mention. Most of the time they haven't even bothered to reply.

As for the topics, I have been told that there was insufficient interest in finishing, square bowls, and spindle turning of any kind, and that design was too controversial a topic for the Symposium.

I have never understood their rejection of spindle turning. They always have demonstrations on skews, and techniques for turning pens, weedpots, Christmas ornaments, tops, and finials. Those look like spindles to me.

There are also a lot of topics that are not adaptable to the 75-minute rotation, and the AAW has always insisted that each rotation be a stand-alone presentation. I think that has eliminated a lot of topics.