New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Opinions for bowl finishes wanted-Longish

Posts

Opinions for bowl finishes wanted-Longish

#1

Steven Antonucci

Opinions for bowl finishes wanted-Longish

steve antonucci

>The other day, my wife asked me to donate a bowl to a local charity event for a family in our community. I went through my collection, and took out 2 older pieces (which were so-so) and one recent piece, which was up to my current standards (however, my wife hated it- she has an aversion to spalted woods...)

So the event was a silent auction, and apparently, people like my work. Not meaning to brag, but my bowls drew more bids than they should have, and sold for a very nice donation to a worthy cause. As a result of the bidding war, many people did not get the bowls, and decided to approach my wife, who began to overcommit me, er, um, I mean take orders on my behalf.

One of the orders was for a bowl "just like the one from the auction"- which was a piece of spalted maple from the woods by my house. Power company cut the tree, and I saw the black lines running through the stump, and ran out to buy a chainsaw... 5 years ago. So I went back into the woods, and cut a bunch more of it, some a little soft, and refinished an older bowl to make a salad set.

So now my question:

Normally, my bowl finish is mineral oil and beeswax (easy, looks good, cheap), but I'm afraid that it may not hold up to a good vinegrette. Aside from that, the bowls are spalted maple, and I'm afraid that staining from a dressing might shorten their lifespan.

The bowls have been alcohol soaked (killing all organisms?) and wet sanded with mineral oil. What would you all recommend for a day-to-day usage finish? All opinions wanted.

Steve

Re: Opinions for bowl finishes wanted-Longish

#2

Re: Opinions for bowl finishes wanted-Longish *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>It isn't what you put on the wood, but what isn't there that is important; and that is SMELL.

“Is the wood and finish safe for food?” This is the most often asked question by the woodturner, but the least asked question by the customer. Customers are smarter than we give them credit for being. They will let their nose tell them the difference. If a bowl has an odor that is offensive, they won’t buy it. The corollary is that a bowl with a pleasant or appetizing odor is an easy sale.

Any remaining odors of paint or stinking wood will kill a sale immediately. Our saying that that it is safe to use and that the odor will disappear with time won’t rescue it.

Other than that, anything that will flake off, such as a lacquer, is not good for the inside of the salad bowl. There is nothing wrong with eating the lacquer flakes, it is getting them stuck between your teeth.

And your wife is right, spalted wood is not a popular salad bowl. That and the other things that I think make for a good salad bowl are discussed in the linked article


what makes a good salad bowl

Re: Opinions for bowl finishes wanted-Longish

#3

Steven Antonucci

An educated consumer- still wanted spalted maple..

steve antonucci

>I tried to talk her out of spalted maple, but she had her mind set. My wife also won't eat out of cherry, walnut or any other bowl I make since she can't run it through the dishwasher- c'est la vie.

Steve