We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I am investigating getting the Kel McNaughton system for coring bowls and am wondering which would be the best approach for me to take. Should I get the standard set, the large set, or the complete set(both standard and large)? If I were to get just one set, what advantage would that set have over the other, or will I really use both sets if I get the complete set? I have the Powermatic with a 20" swing, so I do have opportunity to use the large set. Any advice or insight is greatly appreciated.
I would say get them both. That is what I have, and I use both sets frequently. If you hold off until the next time you pay me a visit, we can do some fooling around with them here.
>It is my understanding that the large blade with the standard system is the same as the medium blade with the large system. If this is the case, I can buy the large system along with the medium and small replacement blades for the standard system and have all the components and save about $35.00. I do want to work with them more when I come up to turn with you again. The more turning I do, the more frustrating it becomes to waste such good wood.
>Bill and Anyone else with the McNaughton coring system. I set one of my knives up and put a piece of Plexiglas in the chuck. The Plexiglas is about thirteen inches by six inches. I clamp it in the chuck jaws so that it is horizontal and centered across the bed of the lathe. I have a line on it that represents the bottom of the bowl, about half an inch out from the chuck jaws. By positioning the gate for the McNaughton system, I can run the knife in and out and see where it goes through the clear Plexiglas. I can make the diameter of the bowl blank and the thickness or depth. Then I can lock the gate down, switch the bowl blank in and the Plexiglas out and core with some confidence I won't ruin the blank.
Now for the question. I notice that at least one of the knives does not follow a radius as it slides in. That is, for the knife to work, it has to follow a curved path that it cuts for itself, a section of a circle. My knife does this for about the first two thirds of its length and then starts sliding or translating to the side. Is this knife bent improperly? Do they all do this? Or have I managed to mangle it in some of my early brutal attempts at coring before I developed at least a little finesse?
>hello, wonder if it would be possible to post a picture of the plexiglas setup. Can't seem to get this pictured om my head. Thanks for your time. Kenny
>Yes, the largest knife in the standard set starts out in a smaller curve then straightens out to a larger curve. I think they all are this way since they are pictured in the catolog this way also. I just layed mine on a radius and bent mine to that radius and then bent the crook in the blade so that the tip of the cutter lined up correctly with the handle. It don't bind like it did. The standard set can be bent but the large set can not be bent since they are made of spring steel.
>Pardon the quality of this quick picture. I laid a white trash bag over the ways of the lathe to reduce some clutter in background and hopefully make the Plexiglas more visible. The chuck is on the left and the cutter is entering from the lower right. The blue tape allows for removal of setup marks. Actually, this would be a great place for those white board markers that wipe off easily. You could mark the width or diameter of the blank and the depth and then wipe it off for the next one. Everything is slightly tilted in the picture, but such are the tribulations of working alone and in a hurry. This allows me to sketch bowl and see the path of the knife. My gaol is to get the biggest core possible but not to ruin the big outer bowl. That's the one I'm really after and the rest is gravy.
>Thanks Gary, think you just answered my question. The curve is not consistent and the knife really does change it's path as you get deeper. This means you have to cut out a wider path or the knife binds. That wastes wood and the point to these systems is to save wood, not waste it.
I'm not much of a metal worker. How did you actually bend yours and what did you use as a pattern? Did you just draw a radius with a compass? Did you heat the steel or just bend it?
I find that the cutters work best if you cut a slot just the width of the cutter and keep the speed fairly high on the lathe. If you widen the slot, the shavings start to go around the knife in stead of rolling out and the clog and bind, unless you cut a huge slot, wasting more wood.
My goal was to set the gate so that the cutter was against the posts in such a way it could not cut out the bottom of the big bowl, but would leave my almost exactly a half inch. By making the bottom of the big bowl as thin as I dared, that left the core as big as possible. What happens is that the knife won't follow the path because it is bent with two curves and the core turns out smaller than I wanted.
>The problem you are referring to,in my opionon,is not related to the blade curve. It is caused from pulling the handle of the tool to the left when coring trying to help the blade around the curve. This in a No No. Push strait forward between the posts on the four pin head. The blade will come around by itself. When you pull the handle to the left you flex the blade causing it to bind in the kerf half way down the core out.
Try not pulling to the left on the handle when coring. Also make sure to back off on the forward pressure applied to the blade when half way through the coreout. The grain direction changes at this point from Side grain to end grain. The pressure need to maintain a cut changes from alot at the begining to having to hold the blade back at the end.
>Bill, I don't think Masonite will work, because the knife slides under the Piece of stuff. If it's clear, you can watch the path of the knife. If it were solid you can't Really see where the knife is going.
>I use the method Greg suggests in his post as this is the correct way to use this tool. But the problem we are discussing is the large blade in the standard set being bent incorrectly from the factory. It starts out at the tip in a smaller curve than it ends up at.
To bent that knife to a curve that is consistant, I put it in a vise and bent it by hand and with a rubber mallet with no heat. I put the knife on the "Layout Template" that is in the "Woodturners Catalog" and kept bending and checking untill it matched the circumfrance I wanted. You could also just make a circle with a compass. Be sure the tip of the cutter is in line with the handle when you are done.
>Geometrically speaking, the blades HAVE to be portions of a circle or they won't work. The only slop in the system to allow for blades that are not part of a circle are:
The width of the kerf from the cutter
The width of the kerf caused by multiple cutting passes which might widen the kerf.
A couple of years ago, I placed all 10 of my McNaughton blades on the Craft Supplies template (large, standard and mini). All are circular.
I would follow Gary's suggestion of laying the blade on a circle template to see how out of round it is. I would guess that the blade is flexing in the cut instead of bent incorrectly.