New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

nat edge advice please

Posts

nat edge advice please

#1

nat edge advice please

ken chase

>This is my third nat edge bowl and as illustrated in the attached photo parts of the piece are thinner than others. On both the other bowls I needed to do a lot of sanding to even the thickness. Is this standard procedure for this kind of project ..or am I lacking the necessary skill with my tools? To me the irregular shape explains the problem but I'm not sure of my conclusion.

Thanks


img

Re: nat edge advice please

#2

Re: nat edge advice please

Mike Schwing from Md.

>The answer is simple really - you are not turning the walls to even thickness. The lack of a continuous rim at the same diameter gives you away as it shows the rim thickness through different parts of the bowl. Normally one would only have such an indicator with the entire rim at the max diameter, and that is easy to turn the same thickness all the way around.

There is a bit of an optical illusion involved that can be frustrating with these natural edged rims, but I assure you, the problem can be solved by practicing turning to even thickness on normal edged bowls. I bet if you go back and measure the wall thickness on your finished work you will notice they very much resemble the wall thicknesses depicted on this natural edged one. Even just an 1/8th of an inch looks like a huge difference on a natural edged bowl, but on a regular one, you cannot use your eye to judge wall thickness alone at any point other than the standard rim.

Use calipers if you need to! Eventually you'll no longer be fooled by the illusion and you'll be better at turning to even thickness. It just takes time at the lathe and a desire to do it that way.

Re: nat edge advice please

#3

Re: nat edge advice please

Sam Dean

>Mike has a good point; practice is the only answer. If I do some realy thin stuff from light colored wood, I'll put a light behind the spinning piece to judge the thickness. That only works for about 1/8" or less.

One thing that I do on occasion (which is not safe and I'm not reccommending it) is to look directly down on the piece from above while the wood is spinning. That allows me to see exactly how thick the wood is and follow the exterior profile to an even thickness.

Thanks,

Sam

Re: nat edge advice please

#4

Re: nat edge advice please

scott hogsten

>In addition to the very good advice you already have received I would reccomend that you bandsaw a couple of formal rimmed bowls to check your wall thickness. I know the thought hurts but if you turn a green wood bowl to finished wall thickness and don't bother with sanding or finishing the foot you aren't out much time or wood. Take a good look at your wall thickness and the transition area around the foot.

Scott

Re: nat edge advice please

#5

In addition

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Since the part of the rim farthest away from the center is thicker than the part of the rim closer to the bottom of the bowl, it indicates that you are turning the rim too strait up and down. You needed to have pointed your gouge or curve more tword the center of the bowl in this case. There is now probably too much flex and warp in the bowl to go back and clean up the curve at this point. I'll say this Ken, you are a fast learner! This is not an easy thing for a fairly new turner to do.

Re: nat edge advice please

#6

Re: Thanks to all from Ken

ken chase

>