New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

busted!

Posts

busted!

#1

busted!

Jim Davies, Clayton, NJ

>A piece of white birch. It was 3/32 thick. One little catch does amazing things! I know hollow forms like this have a learning curve but one for four can get very discouraging!

Comments welcome


img

Re: busted!

#2

Re: busted!

john Lucas

>Jim

What tool are you using to hollow?

Re: busted!

#3

Re: busted!

Jim Davies, Clayton, NJ

>John,

I am using the Kelton Hollowers. Pieces this small I am using the mini set, 5/16" diameter. The catch was really my fault now that I am thinking about it. I caught the lip while pulling the tool out to blow the chips out. Wasn't much, just a tap, but enough.

I have a couple of small pieces of the white birch, and one is already on the lathe roughed out to try again. I have always loved a challenge and never claimed to have any brains.

Jim D.

Re: busted!

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: busted! -- Been There, Done That !

Brad Vietje

>Jim,

Looks like things were going so well, too ! Oh well, I cut through the side of a small end grain HF in White Ash this AM -- not a catch, but was trying to make the entire thing around 1/16", and just went a little too far in one spot. White Birch is a little weak, and your photo looks like there was a little blotchy spalting getting started, too, which could have weakened the wood further.

Your ratio of 1 in 4 will improve dramatically with time; soon your success rate will be 30/40, and you'll feel better. A busted turning every now and again just gives us a little dose of humility, so we don't get too full of ourselves !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: busted!

#5

1:4 is about the regular entry fee

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Don't worry about it! Just consider it part of the entry fee into the hollow form turner's club.

Re: busted!

#6

Re: busted!

ken chase

>Looks just like some of mine. Amazing how close to being finished when it happens. My conclusion. when near finishing go extremely slow and stop very often to measure thickness. for what it's worth.

Re: busted!

#7

Dick Hines

Re: busted!

Dick Hines

>Jim. if you don't blow up a few pieces you are not going hollow forms.

Re: busted!

#8

Re: busted!

Dave Fuqua

>Looked awesome, still looks kinda cool even while busted. Large pieces of debris flying off the lathe will get your heart going. Question though: Why so thin? I just started turning and made a cup out of a small piece of maple that wound up < 1/8" thick and it was very light, translucent, and felt like plastic instead of wood. I decided not to do anything that thin again.