New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

Posts

re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

#1

re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

DWFII

>Well, thanks to everyonbe for the help. I guess I was in a little over my head...

I had some maple that I got shortly after it was cut. I chainsawed it in half lengthwise and cut rough blanks from it. I sealed everything with several coats of anchorseal. After about i month I noticed my two biggest and most promising pieces cracking. I cut straight down the pith but left it in figuring it would be easy to turn out. bu that's where all the cracks were coming from...no I take that back some were actuall starting closer to the bark.

So in a vain attempt to save this wood I thought I would try a natural edge bowl. I've read Turning Green Wood but I don't own a copy.

Actually things went alright....I got a bowl/vase, roughly triangular in cross section, turned pretty much to an even 1/8 inch thickness. But I didn't get to the bottom quick eveough and before I could thin it down all the way it started cracking. I filled those cracks with CA and proceeded on.

By this time my walls were so thin that I didn't have enough to cut the base down smaller and still blend it into the top. And the bowl was warping even as i worked it. Seemed I'd just get it trued up and five minutes later it would be out of true. ( My lathe and chuck have, to this point, always been very precise) So the form ended up a little clumsey, too.

When I went to finish it off I noticed a lot of bad, bad tearout. Even though I was getting lovely shavings with my gouge and scraper. I couldn't get rid of it....just too deep, I guess.

And after sanding to 120, I noticed that the although the original cracks had stopped, and whole new set further up the bowl had developed...tiny nasty things running half way uo the bowl and in wood that is a true eighth of an inch thick [sigh].

At that point I more or less gave it up as a lost cause. I put some tung oil on it and gave it to my wife.

I hope the anxiety and effort translates into a somewhat improved skill set, somewhere down the line, if nothing else. In other worlds I hope I learned something...right now, I don't even want to look at the lathe. [heavy sigh]

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

#2

Re: re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

Barry Irby

>If you are actually in the high desert (not just in your mind), you probably need to wax and bag your blanks in plastic bags, and move on to turning them asap.

While you are turning, try misting your pieces with water form some thing like a windex bottle to keep them wet. I've never tried the soapy water, but that might work, also.

Re: re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

#3

Re: re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

adrien

>Another technique is to turn an inch at a time to requisite thickness, sand and apply finish, then go the next inch. The strategy is to keep the heavy base stable and to minimize the time that one is turning the thin rim so that warpage is also minimal. You do not go back to the already turned part, that will have warped oval and no longer be turnable. You go an inch at a time and don't go back.

Re: re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

#4

Re: re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

DWFII

>Well, tonight I'm both. I live in Redmond Oregon...high desert bona fides.

Your remarks about wrapping in plastic makes sense. Right now I have too much wood I guess. Working just on weekend...usually one day only...I can't turn it into blanks fast enough. Two months ago I was begging for wood. didn't hanve anything except a couple of squares I bought off of Ebay.

Good tip on the spray bottle too. Thanks for that.

Also I think I need to get the outside done...shape and finish before I start on the inside. I had most of the shape but figured I'd refine it as I went along. Not smart...at least not to that extent.

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

#5

Re: re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

Skip Beardsley

>The only wood we get here in Montana is birch which I turn green. After preparation I cut the general shape of the bowl, inside and out and leave it rough. For small bowl I turn walls to about 20mm and larger ones to 25-28 mm. I then seal the end grain, inside and out, and put the roughed out blank into double brown paper grocery bags and put away for about twelve weeks, minimum. When they get to about ten percent moisture content they go back on the lathe to be finished down to about 6-8 mm. Have found the above really reduced the cracking and checking to almost nothing,

Hope this helps

Re: re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: re: thin green bowl....a sad story (l0ng)

Brad Vietje

>Hey DW,

Bummer on the cracked bowl... Good suggestions have been offered, and I'm sure your next will go better.

A thin-wall bowl is a pretty demanding project, so be sure to select the wood very carefully before you start. You may not have gotten all the cracks out when you made the outside profile of the bowl.

Tiny cracks can also be hard to see. I find wetting the wood, especially the end grain helps me see them, and it also helps if you get a real clean cut off the gouge. If you still see cracks, you have to remove more wood, making the bowl smaller, or maybe change gears entirely and change the shape to get away from the cracks, or turn smaller projects between them. Better to have a smaller bowl w/out cracks than a larger one that either cracks or -- worse -- flies apart on the lathe.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT