New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Wipe-on finish test

Posts

Wipe-on finish test

#1

Wipe-on finish test

JamieDonaldson

>The August issue of Fine Woodworking has a good review of 17 finishes that are frequently used by turners. The best rated is also the least expensive- Minwax Wipe-on Poly, which I have been testing against Watco Wipe-on Poly, and I like both.

Re: Wipe-on finish test

#2

Re: Wipe-on finish test

john Lucas

>Jamie how to you apply it and how would you say it affects the color of the piece. I'm interested in a poly finish for some products.

Re: Wipe-on finish test

#3

Dave Shombert

Re: Wipe-on finish test

Dave Shombert

>John - I've used Minwax Wipe-On Poly and I liked it. Like other oil finishes, it works best if you apply it with a lint-free rag or paper towel (shop towels from Wal-Mart work great), rub it in, and wipe off the excess. I let it dry overnight and repeat three more times.

More often, I use Woodcraft's Oil Urethane finish, also mentioned in that FW article. I apply it the same way, same number of times. I kind of prefer it because I've seen pieces that I used it on that were three and four years old and it still looked great. Not sure if Minwax's stuff holds up like that or not, maybe Jamie knows.

The Woodcraft finish poses a spontaneous combustion hazard. There's no mention of that on the Minwax can, so I called them. They claim there is no hazard. I don't know whether to believe that or not. But it (Minwax) definitely has less odor than the Woodcraft finish.

Dave Shombert

Elkins, WV

Re: Wipe-on finish test

#4

Dave Shombert

One more thing...

Dave Shombert

>Oh yeah, they both darken the wood somewhat. I hesitate to call it yellowing, but it's definitely darker. Maybe a little more so with the Woodcraft than with the Minwax.

Dave

Re: Wipe-on finish test

#5

Re: Wipe-on finish test

Ron in Drums PA

>I used Minwax Wipe-on poly for the first time about a month ago on a maple table I had finished.

Boy was I impressed. I plan on trying it on some bowls this month.

Re: Wipe-on finish test

#6

Re: One more thing...

TomW in SouthJersey

>Do you apply it with the piece on the lathe and wipe while the lathe is on or it the finish applied off the lathe? Satin or Gloss?

Tom

Re: Wipe-on finish test

#7

Re: Wipe-on finish test

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Jamie, I haven't seen the article, but am curious if they include Rockler's wipe on Gel Poly? I have fallen in love with this particular finish as of late.

Jennifer

Re: Wipe-on finish test

#8

Re: Wipe-on finish test

Don Henthorn

>Actually, I use the Henthorn wipe on poly. I mix Minwax poly and VM&P naphtha 50-50 and find it effortless and forgiving. Also works great for wetsanding a turning that needs a little filler.

Re: Wipe-on finish test

#9

p.s.

Don Henthorn

>I can mix up a tablespoon full or a gallon, whatever I need.

Re: Wipe-on finish test

#10

Re: Wipe-on finish test

DWFII

>VM&P?? Naptha? Whassat?

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: Wipe-on finish test

#11

Re: Wipe-on finish test

Russ Fairfield

>There are several versions of the chemical that we call by the common name of "naptha". One of them is Moth Balls. Another is Varnish Makers and Painters (VM&P) Naptha; a thinner for finishing oils and varnishes that we can use as a substitute for Mineral Spirits because it evaporates faster. Buy it at any paint store.

Re: Wipe-on finish test

#12

Re: Wipe-on finish test

RP

>I just finished 14 segmented bowls and used Minwax Wipe on Poly. I finished them off the lathe. I bought the sack of lint free cloths at Lowes. They turned out real nice. The bowls were oak and walnut. It darkened up the walnut and only slight yellowing of the oak. It took several light coats, with 0000 between coats. Once the pores were filled it finished great. Just make sure you wipe them down for drying.

I also finished a table with it. Don't recommend it for large surface areas. I'd use Minwax fast dry for that. The wipe-on is just too thin for large surface and using a rag to apply is hard to control on the overlaping areas.

RP

Re: Wipe-on finish test

#13

Re: Wipe-on finish test

Charlie Anderson in Southern Maryland

>No, Jennifer, they did not review the Rockler Wipe-On Poly.

Dave Smith turned me on to it when I visited last week. I picked up a can at the Seattle Rockler store and used it on a small bowl this week.

I like it and will use it some more.