We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>About 4 years ago I built a piece I called just another face in the crowd. It started as a project to turn a goblet that shows a silhouette of the face. I thought that I should start a business around creating goblets with peoples profile. Well I was too late. I was reading the latest issue of Scientific American and saw an add in the back that goes to the link below. It takes a while to load so hang on.
>John, I can relate...well sort of. Just the other day I was having a conversation with a friend about an idea I had for a piece for a co-worker whose wife just had their fourth child. Forget buying a baby shower gift...they have everything they need in that regard. They didn't even have a baby shower. So I thought about a simple turning utilizing 6 spindles to depict each member of the family. Well tonight I'm over at WOW and see nearly the same exact thing I was describing to my friend! I should have made this weeks ago when the idea popped into my head.
>Well I don't want to open up this can of worms again, but like a moth to a flame, I am compelled to ask: how does this sit with the recent discussion on copying and plagiarism? On the one hand the copying of profiles into wood isn't a new idea, but on the other this guy has gone to a lot of trouble and effort to create a process, get a web site, etc. I don't want to put words into John's mouth but the idea that he "shouldn't have put off making one" seems to suggest that he feels that this might be one of those gray areas while Keith's reply seems to say it is OK. For a guy like me that has never had an original idea this is very confusing.
I'll shut up now and go back to making wood into mulch. (a process I didn't invent but have certainly perfected.)
>HI Bruce, I think the difference is....JOhn isn't copying anyone, in fact I saw the piece that John posted in Providence, RI at the symposium which was held there.. That was four years ago. It also is featured on the aaw video of that year, making it a very well documented piece. That shows he has been toying with the idea for some time.
It's therefore very possible that John's piece inspired the other turner to produce his similar pieces.
To me however, it appears to be just simple competition: similar to twenty car companies competing to sell you a car. Whoever makes the best car in your price range gets the sale.
That's very different than someone seeing the piece John just posted, copying it, claiming the idea as his own, then marketing the idea. That's basically stealing someone's intellectual property.
I would agree with both you and Keith on this issue. This profile thing is very old. I remember seeing it when I studied photography 30 years ago. Turning it in wood is a newer thing that I tried and probably others have as well. In fact there is a piece showing full figures using the negative space in Mike Darlow's book Woodturning design.
I will probably not market it because I simply don't have time. I'm kind of proud that my idea is being used whether or not he saw what I did or not. If your a woodturner and you have studied the negative space goblet I'm sure this idea has occured to you.
If I were to market it I would do it differently so that I wasn't copying his exact technique. However I think he would have a hard time convincing everyone that this was his idea alone. I'm hoping he is very successful.