New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Natural edged cherry burl

Posts

Natural edged cherry burl

#1

Natural edged cherry burl

Mike Schwing from Md.

>This started out as a normal bowl, rough turned and waxed, but in between roughing and finishing I bought a Foredom. It is totally carved now, wavy like, interior matching exterior to about 3/16" thick walls. A ton of labor but worth it, I think. Didn't look right sitting on the table so the pedestal is made of maple burl. I'm pleased with the shape of the pedestal but think it could be a little more delicate perhaps. I had considered painting the pedestal black. About 11" wide I guess, barely fit in my photo booth. All comments welcomed/sought.


img

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#2

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

Ed Kelle

>Nice work Mike! Looks fantastic. I don't think you should paint the pedestal black, I like the natural look to it.

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#3

Nice! *LINK*

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Mike,

This is a really cool looking piece. I would like to see the pedestal colored, but not painted. You might want to try some leather dyes. I've been having some neat results using a liquid leather dye that comes in a bottle with a wool applicator. It comes in various colors but I've only used USMC Black and Chocolate Brown. The brand I use is Fiebing's. About $5.00 a bottle. I get mine at Hobby Lobby. I could see it dyed a deep brown to accent the natural edge.

Jen


Fiebing's Colors

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#4

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

TomW in SouthJersey

>Mike - Very nice. If you feel you have to add something maybe 3 thin black lines around the very bottom of the base right where you have the little lip would accentuate the dark lines of the bark.

Either way its is beautiful work.

Tom Wright

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#5

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

Ben Aragon

>Mike,

It’s perfect I wouldn’t change a thing. The base should not detract attention from this exquisite bowl. The scale and detail of the base fits. I really like it, I have to get a Foredom. How many hours did it take?

Best Wishes,

Ben

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#6

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

Ruth in So. Cal

>Mike, I love it...it reminds me of an angel, head and shoulders down, with wings in full span....I would leave it as is.....

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#7

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

RevDoug

>That is one good looking piece of cherry, Mike. Have you tried blacking out the pedistal via your photo editing software? Might be a good tool to use before you actually paint it and then decide you've made a mistake.

Turn 'em round,

RevDoug

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#8

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

GaryG in MD

>With all due respect to Tom and Ruth for their good ideas, I think I like it the way it is. This way, the bowl just sort of floats. The base seems like a part of the bowl and consequently doesn't draw the eye away from the gorgeous top. I like that. Really nice. ...Gary

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#9

Thanks!

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Thanks for the nice comments. In response to the "how many hours" question, I was trying to quantify it for an answer, but the best I could come up with is "if it took an hour to turn a bowl, this would have taken 10 hours". The time was shortened dramatically by the use of an Arbortech mini-grinder as my 1/8hp Foredom isn't up to the task of really serious hogging out. The Arbortech rocks.

By the way - the 1/3HP Mastercarver kit w/ foot pedal and 3 handpieces is available for the same exact price ($349) as the 1/8HP Foredom kit at www.woodcarversupply.com . I intend to utilize the Woodcraft 1 year no questions garuntee policy to acquire the Mastercarver version.

There seems to be enough divergence of opinion on the pedestal that any choice would be good. I favor Jennifer's idea of a dye, which I'd probably apply as a translucent airbrush color that fades from top to bottom.

The suggestion to alter the appearance in Photoshop was a great one. I'd not considered that before - great suggestion and a great tool that I should use more.

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#10

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

john Lucas

>Mike Very nice. I think I agree about the pedestal. I would make is a hair thinner and possibly make the very bottom just a little wider. I think I agree with the others on the color. If you do color it use dyes so the natural wood will show through. I don't think a solid black would be the best choice. I love the shape.

I use a 24 grit sandpaper on my 3" angle grinder to rough shape pieces like that. goes much faster than the Foredom. It's surprising how delicate a cut you can do with practice.

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#11

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

Jim D.

>Mike, I really like this piece! The top gives the impression of just kind of floating there. The match in color for the pedistal is also very nice. I do not think I would do anything as far as coloring goes, but if I did it would be with a brown. Starting very light at the top of the pedistal and gradually going darker to the base. If I were to do that I would also consider texturing the base to look more like the bark.

A great piece of work!!!

Jim D.

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#12

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

John K Jordan

>Mike,

Nice piece.

As for the base, I think the two woods are too close in color/figure for contrast but are they not quite close enough to compliment? I almost want to see the base carved as well!

Regardless, I did a very quick simulation of a black base to let you see what it MIGHT look like if you made it soft black, not glossy. I used 3D software to make a base then did an overlay in photoshop. Note that I did NOT take the time to get the shape or perspective perfect (I think I made spindle too thick) just close enough to get by without spending more than a few minutes! With this method it is trivial to try shiny, some different paints or stain colors, etc.

JKJ in East TN


img

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#13

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

Jim King

>Jungle opinion: When you have something that nice and unique there may or may not be a couple of ways to make it even nicer but there are dozens of ways to screw it up. If it was mine I would leave as is. It is very nice.

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#14

JL

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

JL

>Well said. It looks good as is. Perfection is the enemy of good.

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#15

Which base?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>what a difference a base can make. I think I'm leaning towards the black one. I made one to match the rest of the piece with a bit of burning and airbrushing but it doesn't work at all, and is not shown here.


img

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#16

Black

Pete Kekel - Kentucky

>

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#17

Black

Jay in TX

>

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#18

Re: Which base?

Mike L (Orange County, CA)

>Mike,

My completely uninformed opinion is that the base is too solid for the bowl. I'm thinking perhaps a three-legged base with three arms to hold the bowl would draw the viewers eye to the bowl and make the piece look lighter. Perhaps the base could turned off-center on both ends and then have the legs and arms carved out so the base is asymmetric. (Not that I would have the slightest idea how it would be done).

Regards,

Mike

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#19

Re: Which base? Neither

Russ Fairfield

>This is one of those things where its displayed position is important. Your photo is not the normal viewing angle if it were placed on a normal tabletop display. We would be looking down on it and the base would be hidden in the shadow under it. In that case, Black would be the better color because it is easier to hide.

As you are showing it, the base is as visible as the piece itself; and I have to agree with the "neither" answer. You are mixing a symmetrical base with something that isn't. My eye is drawn to the base because it is a hard shape, and I don't think that is the accent you are wanting.

Get out the carving tools and free up the form of the base. Even a piece of drift wood would be more appropriate than what is there now. My opinion only.

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#20

Re: Which base? Neither

Ed in No.VA

>Mike

As you peek over the rim this is a landscape of rolling hills and and valleys with gulleys and other terrrain features. It should be riding on the back of a turtle.

Re: Natural edged cherry burl

#21

Re: Which base? Neither

Mike Schwing from Md.

>It definitely needs lift. I think that EVERYONE is right about this one, except for I know it looks weird sitting flat on the table. As it is, the photo with its original base was accepted for one of the national magazines, so I think I am going to leave it that way. This is one of those pieces best viewed at shoulder height on a shelf somewhere, by the way. Looking straight down it resembles an oyster shell, which of course gives me other ideas... initially I was going to call this "cherry on the half shell" till I made the base. This one has been fun to tinker over. Thanks again all.