New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Setting up new lathe questions

Posts

Setting up new lathe questions

#1

Setting up new lathe questions

Kudzu

>I bought an old J-line bowl lathe, 16" swing without a motor and I am in the process of setting it up. I am going to build a new heavy stand for it that I can weight down with sandbags.My question is is there a rule of thumb for how high you want your lathe to be? I am trying to decide on the height for the stand.

I am trying to decide on a motor to power this. I have a couple laying around that I could use. A 3/4 hp continuous duty cast iron antique. A new imported 2hp off a table saw (probably more like 1.5 hp) and I am considering just buying a variable speed DC motor. I was looking at just using one of my motors and putting in a jack shaft. I ran some numbers last night snf discovered that getting a good set of speeds requires a jack shaft with a 2 step pulley A 1:1 and a 1:2 ratio works well. Problem is I don't of a source of 2 step pulleys. Do you?

BTW using 2 sets of standard 4 step pulleys provides you with only about 6 usable speeds. Unless you like spinning you bowls faster than 4,000 RPM.And you can get 27,000 RPM using these and 1725 RPM motor! At this point even though it cost more the DC motor is slightly ahead because of the variable speed. I have only spun a few large rough blanks but I think that the variable speed could be a very nice feature for that.


img

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

#2

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

John Lucas

>I would set it up so the spindle height is about elbow height.

I very fond of Variable Frequency Drives and 3 phase motors. You lose torque at slow speeds with a DC motor but the VFD maitains torque at low speeds. it does require a 220 input however.

If you do a search for Sheeves on the web you will find a bunch of places that sell multi spep pulleys. My local hardware carries 2 step and my local bearing supply house has been able to order all the different pulleys I want. Some of the high quality step pulleys are really pricey.

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

#3

JL

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

JL

>I had a variable speed pulley system on my first lathe. Noisy, and I didn't like it. I now have a variable speed with two pulley steps - infinitely better and less noisy. I would have a tendency to vote for a variable speed motor with a low range pulley and a high range. As to how high - elbow height or a bit (1-2") above for the center of the spindle. If you have adjustable legs on your lathe base, you can adjust it somewhat.

Do an ergonomics test. Set it at a particular height and turn a bit (bowl and spindle). Do a couple of stretches and move your arms around - if you feel strain and kinks - change the height.

My $0.02.

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

#4

Ahh sheeves!!

Kudzu

>I should have thought of using the word sheeves! I was looking for step pulley and you don't find much that way.

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

Brad Vietje

>Kudzu,

First -- That's an interesting lathe there -- never saw one of those. Is that 16" total swing (8" from bed to center) or a 16" spindle height (translating to a 32" bowl) ? The tool rest post looks a little light for bumping along an out-of-round and/or out-of-balance bowl blank, though if you intend to make bowls from blanks cut round, it should be fine.

Second -- how heavy ? As heavy as you can make it and still work comfortably at the machine. People cuss lathes that are too light, but only cuss heavy lathes when they go to move them. Heavy is good, heavier is better.

As for speeds for large bowls, slow is good, slower is better. You can create jack shafts with off the shelf inexpensive pulleys, or spring for the electronic variable speed.

Places like Dealer's Electric sell variable speed motor/inverter packages at good prices. You could use a 1 Hp package which runs a 1 hp 220 volt 3ph motor off a 115 volt single phase input. Jacking that down to 50 rpm or so will give you all the power you need to rough out bowls of the size/weight this machine will handle. you'll probably never need more than 500 RPM for bowls.

Great project -- good luck !

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

#6

Re: Setting up new lathe questions *LINK*

Ben Aragon

>Kudzu,

I would go three phase. I would also use a grooved belt like the ones used on the newer lathes. The grooved belts have a lot more friction than V belts. Here is the site were I got my 3 phase controller, the Altivar 11 (3hp, 220V single-phase input). I think paid around $150, it’s made by Square D. You can find used 3 phase motors cheap.

Ben

http://www.squared.com/us/products/drives.nsf/unid/6A62B823134D194685256A1F005F1E13/$file/ACDrivesFrameset.htm


http://www.squared.com/us/products/drives.nsf/unid/6A62B823134D194685256A1F005F1E13/$file/ACDrivesFrameset.htm

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

#7

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

Kudzu

>I has a 16" total swing (bowl size). I agree about the tool rest but before I do anything I will check it out. If it needs some beefing up I can do that.

The lathe minus motor is about 50 lbs so it's a light weight. It appears to be very rigid however. The weight is why I want to build the stand with room for sandbags/ballast. I am thinking of starting with 300 lbs total weight and see what happens. It's easy enough to add more sand.

I am really leaning toward a variable speed motor. I am also thinking about leaving the 3 step pulley it came with and then adding the same to the motor. That would allow me to under drive the motor and keep the motor RPM's up even at slow spindle speeds.

I looked at Dealers Electric and they by far have the best price on a package I have found. However for well under $200 I can have a 1hp DC motor and controller so it's a tough choice what to do. I like the idea of 3 phase but I like that money in my pocket too. :-)

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

#8

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

Kudzu

>That place gets my vote for one of the worse web sites I have seen! Assuming that they actually sell of the web site. I never did find prices and gave up.

Did I understand you right and bought from them?

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

#9

Re: Ahh sheeves!!

Barry Turner

>Actually, it's "sheaves"............ :-)

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

#10

I think I have decided on a motor

Kudzu

>I have looked at a bunch of motors, controllers, AC, DC, 3-phase, single phase etc. I think I have settled on a DC motor largely because of cost. After some searching and a lot of math on scrap paper I think I have made my choice. I have found a 1 HP totally enclosed motor, 1725 RPM, sealed unit and rated for continuous duty. It costs more than some of the other DC motors but it seems the better choice in a dusty environment like a lathe.

Having no experience with DC motors I have some concerns about the loss of low speed torque. My lathe has a 3 step pulley on it. I have decided to swap it out and use a pulley with a 3", 4" and 5" diameter and a second one with a 1 5/16", 2 9/16" and 3 3/8" dia. If I need to, with this setup I can run the motor at a higher speed and still keep the spindle speed down and torque up.

On the lowest setting my max. spindle speed would be 455 RPM and I have close to a 4 to 1 multiplication factor in my favor, so even at very slow speeds I should still have plenty of torque. The next step has 1120 RPM max and a 2 to 3 ratio. The highest setting is almost 1 to 1 and would be way faster than I think I would ever need.

While I hope to just set it and not have to change the belt location at least if I find that at slow speeds on larger items that I am lacking torque I have the option to gear it down and speed up the motor.

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

#11

Re: I think I have decided on a motor

Gary Evans, Tallassee, TN

>One thing to consider about DC motors and drives. If the drive fails because of losing a diode, you can put AC voltage across the windings of the motor, resulting in motor failure. DAMHIKT 8^]

The one AC drive that I am personally aware of that failed didn't hurt the motor at all. In fact that motor now lives with our buddy Dave Smith.

Gary

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

#12

Re: Setting up new lathe questions

Ben Aragon

>Sorry I didn't check back sooner.

You have to find a SquareD distributor.