Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Question for Don Pencil

Posts

Question for Don Pencil

#1

Question for Don Pencil

Ben Aragon

>Don,

I bought your Scorpion and Stinger hollowing system a year and a half ago and I think it�s great. I�m a hobbyist and not a professional turner so my comments are uneducated. I had to decide which hollowing tool out of all that are out there to buy. After reading Lyn Mangiameli articles and what people have posted on the web, I decided your system best fit my needs and price range. I have never regretted my decision and I can tell you I think this tool is very well made and performs great.

After reading many articles, turning many bowls, vessels, and boxes I know one tool can�t do everything. I good friend decided to by the new Munro hollower and I�ve had the opportunity to try it. It is also a very nice tool and my friend likes it very much. I know there are two types of cutting approaches, scraping (Scorpion) and shearing (Munro) and each one may work better than the other depending on the type of wood, grain orientation, dry or wet, ect�

My question is could you, would you, and do you have any plans on making a hooded shear cutter assembly that could attach to the Scorpion curved arm??? I�m also not a mechanical engineer this is just an idea I had and it may be a dumb one. I�m sure you would only do this if it could be done right and with the same quality you demand in your tools now.

Not being a professional I am limited on my budget and I don�t mind taking the time to change out parts on my tools. Thank you for listening. If anyone has comments on my question I would appreciate your views as well.

Best Wishes,

Ben

Re: Question for Don Pencil

#2

Don Pencil

Re: Question for Don Pencil

Don Pencil

>Ben,

Thank you for your kind comments. I'm glad you are enjoying the tools.

I'm not concidering manufacturing a hooded style cutter at this time. The Scorpion was brought to the market place because it was a much improved design over the existing tools that are available on the market and I could offer it at a price that was lower than the others. Therefore it was an overall improvement in both quality and cost to the woodturner. I cannot offer an improved hooded style cutter at this time.

Proform makes a good hooded cutter that fits on the Scorpion curved tool. May I suggest, that if you would like the best of bother worlds, get a Porform cutter for your Scorpion Curved tool and you will be in good shape.

New products will be out in the near future that will follow in the spirit of the Scorpion with quality and a better value for the turner.

Thank you for your suggestions and comments. I very much appreciate them.

Don Pencil

WWW.DONPENCIL.COM

Re: Question for Don Pencil

#3

Re: Question for Don Pencil

Ben Aragon

>Don,

Thank you for the fast response, and I appreciate the great suggestion.

Ben

× Share

Share on

✉ Email this page