OK, now which one?...critique

Re: OK, now which one?...critique

Barry Turner

>I like the proportions on the one on the left better. The dark inserts are too close to the end on the right one.

Just a thought, are you an optometrist, by any chance?

Re: OK, now which one?...critique

JamieDonaldson

>Danny - they both look good, but the real criteria is which one sounds better to a turkey/hunter!

Re: OK, now which one?...critique

Duane C.Leach

>OK Danny. As before the one with the longer furel is more apealing to me. Kind of like a woman with a long neck versus a woman with a short neck.

Just my opinion.

Duane

Re: OK, now which one?...critique

Robert Cox

>Short ferrule, lose the middle dots, maybe both sets.

Re: OK, now which one?...critique

Danny Wells

>Nope, not an optometrist. Why do you ask?

Re: Thanks guys...

Danny Wells

>I appreciate your input. By the way they both sound great to the hunters. Some guys are hunting with them this season. We'll see what the turkeys think, however, part of that will depend on the one running the call.

Re: OK, now which one?...critique

Sam Dean

>I think they both look phenominal, but I like the one on the right just a little more. Not sure exactly why, though.

Thanks,

Sam

Re: OK, now which one?...critique

Fred in NC

>I agree. It is the shorter brass.

Re: OK, now which one?...critique

Barry Turner

>The responses just reminded me of questions my opteometrist asks: "Which one is clearer, A or B. Which is sharper, # 1 or # 2. Is it clearer to you now........or, now?" Just joking. Both are really nicely detailed and well made. Choosing the best one is about as hard as those danged eye charts.

Re: OK, now which one?...critique

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I like the one on the right, but I'm not a turkey. Well, I've been called a turkey, but that doesn't count.

My preference is not based on the length of the brass collar. that works fine in either model. I like the flair of the horn on the right one. It seems to flow better. The one on the left seems a bit stiff.

Secondarily, I like the positioning of the spots better on the right one. The spots on the left one are too conservative, as if someone were afraid they might break something if they got too close to the end with them.

LOL I thought they were candle holders

Anthony

>