Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A Humbling Experience (long)

Posts

A Humbling Experience (long)

#1

A Humbling Experience (long)

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I�ve been turning seriously for over a year now, and have had a lathe for over 20 yrs. I can turn decent bowls and platters. I�ve made boxes with nicely fitted lids and I�ve done the birdhouse and Christmas tree ornaments. I�ve been practicing my skew skills by doing exercises from the Lacer and Raffin videos. I�ve watched at least � dozen turning videos. I get my tools sharp. I was a carpenter for 30 years; I know what sharp tools are and how dull ones perform. OK! Here is the point, I thought my tool handling skills were getting pretty good. My wife, LOML, wants a shelf with shaker pegs made out of oak. No problem! I have shaker pegs in birch; I�ll just make 5 copies in oak on the lathe. Simple right? They are a simple shape; I�ll knock these out 1 � 2 �3. NOT! I can see why so many prominent turners came from production turning back rounds. The degree of tool control needed to match shapes is quite high. My turned pegs do turn out nicer than the store bought ones though. When you look at them side by side you realize how much torn grain the mass-produced pegs have. I had to turn about 10 to get 5 that matched well enough to use. It took me much longer than I thought it would also.

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

#2

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

adrien

>After the next 500 pegs, they'll go a lot faster�

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

#3

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

Ruth Niles

>and Welcome to the world of reproduction spindle turning! Have faith, like bowls, hollow forms and flat work, you'll be knocking duplicates out in no time after the initial practice time.

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

#4

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I�m already seeing improvement! When I started my carpenters apprenticeship, I remember one of the journeymen telling me,� it takes bout 7 years for someone to become a good carpenter�. I do believe he was right. Over 30 years I never did stop learning better ways to build things. I view turning the same way. It takes a certain amount of hands on experience to get good, and I�ll never stop learning. I was hoping my other experiences of working with wood, would give me an advantage. It probably does to a degree. I don't want to decide if or where I'm going to specialize in turning yet. I want to turn a wide variety of turnings using different techniques and learn as much as I can.

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

#5

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

Fred in NC

>It only takes 6 yrs and 11 months to become a good turner !!!!

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

#6

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

John Lucas

>Fred

I know how long it takes to become a great turner. A lifetime.

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

#7

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

Glenn Madsen

>Remember: Oak is not Birch. The grain structure makes is a lot easier to have tearout and rough surfaces.

I have a bunch of Tanoak, a non-commercial species native to Northern California. This looks a lot like white oak, but behaves much more like birch or soft maple when used with a sharp tool.

Maybe find some nice QS White oak?

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

Keith Tompkins

>Hi tek, welcome to the wonderful world of spindle turning!

The craze in turning is bowls, bowls, bowls: poor ol' spindle turning is looked down upon by today's turners.

I also got my start doing production work for furniture pieces, it gave me a good foundation on which to build.

I suggest practicing spindle turning every time you turn, as a warmup. The skills take time to develop, and will become second nature eventually. Technique is essential to smooth pieces that will require little sanding.

A big difference between the two types of turning is bowl turning is used to turn single objects, while spindle turning involves duplication of the same form. That is a BIG difference!

The use of calipers will be essential for accuracy at first, you won't need them much after a while.

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

#9

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

Barry Turner

>Sometimes the simplest shapes are the hardest to get right.

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

#10

JL

Re: A Humbling Experience (long)

JL

>Richard Raffan described a guy in one of his books who turned spindles for his balcony around his house. The first were somewhat amatuerish, but they got better and better as they went around his house. Practice makes perfect. I have no problem with bamboo style legs. My baluster styles need work.

× Share

Share on

✉ Email this page