When is a stile a stile? A rail, maybe? Or, does something else define what it is? There are so many joining layouts, so how is that stick identified?
I could give a reasonable answer if we were looking at a cupboard on a wall with a vertical stick and side hinge with rails butting into the stiles. ... But what about the top-hinged door?
Then, we encounter a box, with a lid. Frame and panel. Well, which is which? Not so easy with mitered corners. Hinged; on the ....? No hinges?
The photo shows a set of stone steps built into the stone wall right next to the wooden stile.
More observations: Goats would have no problem at all navigating either one, and a deer would just jump right over, but I think they would work fine for horses, sheep or cattle. You could probably send your border collies out to fix them when they wear out. ;^)
A cattle guard is a horse of a different feather. They are constructed of several rails or pipes set in a ditch across a road at a gap in a fence. The cattle are afraid to cross it for fear of tripping and breaking a leg. I saw one instance in which the guard had been made too narrow (not enough rails), and the cattle learned to just step across it. To fix the problem, the farmers simply painted a couple of white stripes on the far side about the same width and spacing as the real rails. The cattle were that stupid. I guess there was one member of the farmer's family who was stone stair challenged.
William, the location of the drystone dyke with the ladder is most likely in the Yorkshire Dales, County Durham, Northumberland, the Lake District or possibly the Scottish Borders. The primary creatures most likely to be constrained are sheep and perhaps cattle. Goats aren't raised in great numbers in those parts of the world, but I agree that goats would get over that dyke easily enough. Slainte.
Re: Definitions: Interesting Photo of Stiles—Strictly OT
Thank you, Richard! You nailed it—metadata for the photo located it in Yorkshire Dales, taken in 2006. Absolutely beautiful country.
As for Wm’s goats, they’re a whole other thread. We had a major construction project here in So. Cal. (Diamond Valley Reservoir), which was beset by endangered species. To keep the weeds down during construction, without discing up the mice, and to clear the reservoir walls where a tractor couldn’t go, we hired a Basque farmer from the San Joaquin Valley, who came with maybe 50 goats—the goats kept that place policed up for months. This is a regular commercial activity.
Our goats out here do about what they please. They love a high place when they’re not eating everything. In rural areas, I’ve seen them on the roofs of pick-up trucks.
Re: Definitions: Interesting Photo of Stiles—Strictly OT
When I was in Oman, the residents warned me not to park under trees. There were not very many of them and they resembled Parkinsonia, with tiny leaves and huge thorns. Although it seemed reasonable to use a bit of very scarce shade, if you did, there would soon be goats (with hooves) on top of your car, nibbling the leaves they couldn't reach from the ground.
Goats are smart too, especially when it comes to self preservation. In the Galapagos, we visited one island that consisted of two volcanoes, one large, with rugged and irregular topography and one small cinder cone, connected by a narrow isthmus. The island also had a large population of feral goats, that were hunted by the national park rangers because they destroyed the endemic native plants. The small volcanic cone had much lusher vegetation, because the goats stayed away, knowing they were much easier targets on that part of the island. The goats had originally been turned loose on the islands by whalers, who knew they would survive and be a good source of protein when they returned on later voyages.
I look at this too fractionally. I am too cheap to have my own Architectural Graphic Standards. Obviously, like in Wiley's image, I should crawl over the wall/dyke like the girl and ignore the stile and rock steps.
Re: Wiley's goats- In sensitive site areas we would recommend that clients hire goats (Rent-a-Ruminant) to clear the steep and wetland portions of invaded exotics, usually blackberry. The "shepherd" merely guided the eating machines through the flagged clearing zones. There was very little they would not eat.
Thanks for the insight. I thought she was just looking over the wall. Your observation that she was using a third option to get over the wall added a lot to the picture. What was even more amazing was that both Richard and Wiley identified its location, since I spend way too much effort trying to figure out where an interesting pic or video was taken.
The truth, William, is that I only have to travel a few miles northwards from my front door and I start seeing walls (aka, dykes) of that type of construction in the Yorkshire Dales. Continue northwards and over the England/Scotland border towards Scotland's Central Belt and variations of dyke style construction show up regularly. I'm not familiar enough with exactly how the walls or dykes are built, but there are, apparently, distinct historical construction methods used in different regions. So, for example, a drystane (sic) dyke in Scotland was, historically, and still is visually and structurally different to a drystone wall in the Yorkshire Dales. Slainte.
You’re living in history! FWIW, the actual location of that photo is a place named Malham. But then a fast google search of ‘Yorkshire Dales’ shows endless miles of these walls or dikes, before we ever get to Scotland. Then there are the stone barns and granaries….a phenomenal legacy!
One way or another Wiley, we're all living in places with history. But yes, the Yorkshire Dales do have something distinctly singular. The dales are tourist magnet. The place is hooching with them from all around the world. Slainte.