Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

What wood do I have here?

Posts

What wood do I have here?

#1

What wood do I have here?

David Weaver

This picture is called one for me, two for bill (but not tindall - I don't have any 3v files). :b

The one with the dark handle is one of my first chisels after I kind of got the aesthetics a little better, and I used this same wood for a no-ferrule handle. It is only about as heavy as beech, but it smells like rosewood. It doesn't have the strength or oiliness of rosewood.

I got it back when rockler was "good" (they were local here and any turning wood or shorts that were hard to sell got sold for almost nothing - I've harvested bits of wood out of their shorts pile like kingwood and quartered cocobolo that are not easy to find - but that ended more than a decade ago).

I almost threw away the billet of wood (about 12x12x4) that this handle came from figuring it wasn't heavy enough for a plane and it has some cracks.


I have to admit I like the turned handle with ferrule better as it is guaranteed to fare OK if the bolster stretches a little over time. The tang is tapered so if that happens without the ferrule, the handle can split. But I actually broke the other handle adjusting the straightness of the handle vs. the tang below the bolster.


I've stopped burning handles in like a caveman, too (thought was fun, the mrs. banned it - some of the smell always makes it through the garage into the basement and upstairs - though the olivewood smoke was quite nice).

I'm using the "steve" method on the handles, which is probably something many non-steves use, and I think warren suggested it, too drill a hole, use the tang then to excavate and adjust the handle as it goes in and then drive the last bit tight.

(sorry the closeup of the wood is a little blurry, it's just a crop of the full picture - if you get the urge to say "walnut" for the wood, it's not close to walnut in properties, and remember the dalbergia smell comment - and dustiness).

Re: What wood do I have here?

#2

My guess is Hackberry


Re: What wood do I have here?

#3

more info on the wood..

David Weaver

...approximately 0.77 specific gravity and absolutely bone dry (15 years old and uncoated/Unsealed).

Re: What wood do I have here?

#4

Re: What wood do I have here?

Hank Knight

I'm guessing pear. The fine grain/figure and the color are similar to a handle I turned for an awl years ago, also from a Rockler sell-off of slow moving turning stock.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#5

Re: more info on the wood..

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would say persimmon. The rays are most conspicuous on the radial surface, but though barely visible on the tangential surface, form a pattern. They are in delicate rows, which gives a nice shimmer. We call these storied rays.

Persimmon is given to streaks in the heartwood and takes a very nice polish and sheen. The specific gravity is about right. A very fine wood. Persimmon is in the same genus as ebony.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#6

Can Pear be so dark?

Jim Matthews

I'm saving a few wide Pear boards for "someday".

They're bone dry and almost Lemon yellow.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#7

this wood doesn't have the conviction..

David Weaver

...that persimmon does, and it doesn't have that ebony sort of feel that persimmon does.

I've smelled the same kind of smell in cocobolo, indian rosewood, brazilian rosewood (though that's more spicy) and bois de rose. I tried to look through a list of woods from central america or mexico but there is about a zillion of them.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#8

Re: What wood do I have here?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It does not look like any domestic hardwood we ever sold. I don't think it is a North American species.

Any Hackberry I ever saw was white. We had 100 bd ft of Persimmon once that arrived by mistake. Never could sell it. It was white except around knots where it was black as ebony and heavy as hickory. I never saw a Persimmon big enough to yield a clear 12 x 12 x 4.

If Rockler had it it was some species that was commonly sawed somewhere and available in large clear logs to have been sawed 16/4.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#9

More pics 

David Weaver

If I had an allergy to rosewood or cocobolo, I could confirm that this is a dalbergia or closely related.

Except it's dusty when you saw it but not oily, and and it's splintery like oak.

I'd say it looks like ovankol or however that's spelled, but it doesn't have the pores.


Re: What wood do I have here?

#10

Re: More pics

Oskar

Plum maybe?

Re: What wood do I have here?

#11

Re: Can Pear be so dark?

Jerome

My pear boards tends to have a pinkish hue . And dark brown pith. I have not seen yellow pear.

The texture is mostly plain, dense and tight.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#12

Different texture

David Weaver

Different texture and smell than fruitwoods. Texture and smell point to some kind of weak rosewood, but I can't find anything like it with such small pores.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#13

Re: more info on the wood..

Philip F Duffy

Boxwood is my guess; has all the usage data, color, etc. P

Re: What wood do I have here?

#14

is there a boxwood...

David Weaver

..that's got stringy grain and is dusty rather than smooth? (the chisel handle looks really smooth, but i sanded it with linseed oil/dust cake and then burnished it).

Not sure how to explain the grain other than stringy -the quartered sides look interlocked, but it splits easily and cleanly like oak or straight ash.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#15

Questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You would need a bank loan to buy a piece of boxwood that size. Many, if not all, of these guesses are not considering the size of this piece of wood. It takes a huge clear log to contemplate sawing 16/4 lumber from it.

What do the growth rings look like? Do they look tropical? How large per year? Can you estimate log size from them?

Re: What wood do I have here?

#16

Re: Questions

David Weaver

Probably a two foot tree where this billet came from, in diameter.

The endgrain is a serious edge destroyer.


Shavings break easily. You can see the resulting dust.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#17

Re: Questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

growth rings look distinct. Tropical rings usually are not. I have no idea what it is. Ask the turners. They see a lot more of this kind of retail wood.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#18

color, but uniformity is still there

David Weaver

the rings have strong color variation, but in terms of seeing distinct rings like you would on honduran mahogany, there's not much - the wood is very uniform. Only the color variation is unusual.

I'm inclined just to send a sliver (there's plenty of cracking) to the USDA for testing. The way it fractures gives a feel on the quartered face like it's not that hard (ebony is a lot like that - it planes smoothly for its density because it fractures at the point of cut easily).

This is the wood that split without a ferrule, and very easily, but I don't think any of the indian rosewood that I have would do that (indian rosewood has much more distinct pores, nor anything else, and the color is much richer than common stuff like pau ferro - and it's also much more fragile, powdery and dry).

I'm not sure I've ever smelled the same smell in anything other than rosewoods before, though. I looked through about 450 samples this morning and lots of things look close but nothing exact.

Given what I've seen in khaya and honduran rosewood (sometimes they look very different and some samples are difficult to tell apart without the end grain or hand planing them), it could just be an unusual sample of something not that unusual, but it must've been something with a large main stem for a rosewood.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#19

Re: Dark Pear

Hank Knight

Several years ago my local woodworking store sold all of its small turning stock for pennies on the dollar. I bought a bunch of it for tool handles and such. Among the blanks I came home with were several labeled "Wild Pear."

[url=https://flic.kr/p/2khxA9k][/url][url=https://flic.kr/p/2khxA9k]6A722FBA-E857-48CE-B498-D8F6CC04BE02_1_201_a[/url] by [url=https://www.flickr.com/photos/158680038@N03/]Hank Knight[/url], on Flickr

The grain and texture is very tight and the figure, such as it is, is very fine. The color varies from a dark yellow to a medium to dark brown with occasional gray streaks. I planed one face of this blank so you can see the color and grain.

[url=https://flic.kr/p/2khBjb8][/url][url=https://flic.kr/p/2khBjb8]DCA50621-4A73-460B-8599-80402677D8F2_1_201_a[/url] by [url=https://www.flickr.com/photos/158680038@N03/]Hank Knight[/url], on Flickr

I made an awl and used one of the wild pear blanks for the handle. Originally the color was lighter and the grain was more pronounced. It looked very much like David's chisel handle, but as it aged the color darkened considerably and the grain variation became much more muted (it wasn't pronounced to begin with). Today it appears as a uniform dark brown.

[url=https://flic.kr/p/2khBmw5][/url][url=https://flic.kr/p/2khBmw5]6D8DFD11-AEAA-4932-96D0-25E7129ED72C[/url] by [url=https://www.flickr.com/photos/158680038@N03/]Hank Knight[/url], on Flickr

[url=https://flic.kr/p/2khBiDb][/url][url=https://flic.kr/p/2khBiDb]BB91602E-3208-462A-9F28-7D32EE049E58[/url] by [url=https://www.flickr.com/photos/158680038@N03/]Hank Knight[/url], on Flickr

We get a lot of ornamental Bradford Pear around here. It is very different from this wood. It is much lighter in both color and weight, and a lot of it has a pinkish tinge. I don't know what kind of wood David's chisel handle is, but it sure looks like the wild pear I have.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#20

Very close look....

David Weaver

aside from the pores, that does look similar. Actually, that pear looks like a million of the rosewoods and near rosewoods on the woodfinder list.

I think mine is the Louro Preto based on the matching end grain, color and the sap has the identical pattern in it that my billet has on a corner.

But the dark pear looks like a good guess. I've got some african pear that looks like a lighter version of your pear handle - got it thinking that I like pear woods, but it's not similar to european pear or US fruit trees in any way other than the word pear in the name. It's dense and heavy and has fairly prominent pores.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#21

Re: What wood do I have here?

Hank Knight

Ebony and persimmon are members of the same family, Ebenaceae. I was surprised to learn that recently.

Re: What wood do I have here?

#22

The green cast throws me off... *LINK*

Jim Matthews

I guess Sipo ("Utile") - which was commonplace in the late 1990's.

The turning reveals confusing grain, but the dry character (rather than resinous) points to the stuff. I have a few small planks remaining in my stash.

It carves nicely, but I found it prone to splintering.


https://www.rarewoodsusa.com/product/sipo-16/

Re: What wood do I have here?

#23

Re: Questions

Philip F Duffy

Well, I had better hire an armed guard for my garage stash if that is the case!! P

Re: What wood do I have here?

#24

Re: The green cast throws me off...

David Weaver

similar look, but pores arranged more uniformly, and hardness about double utile.

I think utile may have been offered as a low-cost replacement for mahogany for guitars (obviously, khaya is occupying that space now, which must be due to khaya being harvested in volume in africa in large trees). Sapele is also popular now to sell for bass guitars or electric/acoustic guitar necks.

Khaya probably looks and sounds closest.

But this wood is harder and more dense. I think it turns and planes more easily than it would seem it should due to the fact that it fractures. Planing the end grain off yesterday was an eye opener - difficult planing and destroyed two plane irons in about 50 strokes combined. it sort of reminds me of PH in that respect (PH planes nicely along the grain, but the endgrain is an iron destroyer, especially in denser heavier samples, and then it burns easily if you try to sand it and just plane a little - you have to sand through the burn).

Re: What wood do I have here?

#25

just looked....

David Weaver

.utile end grain pictures do show a much more uniform pore structure than I'd expected. Incompatible hardness and density, though.

I found some louro preto lumber with sap remaining on it (for sale in the interwebs, of course - probably won't show up at HD). The description of the smell, the hardness, density and pictures of the heart vs. sap and the strange color variation are a good match.

As you say - the color throws things off. When the guy at rockler said he thought it was cocobolo, I thought maybe it was cut from a half rotten downed tree, but have to admit I've never harvested a half rotten downed cocobolo tree. :\

All of my cocobolo is closer to 1 SG, though. From experience, the mahoganies (except sapele) are around 0.5-0.6 if they're in good musical range, the woods around 2000 hardness are usually around 0.8, and the 3000s or close are usually around 1 with ambient moisture.

There is denser mahogany around (including honduran), but it usually isn't worth much if sold by a guitar retailer because the density is off for electric guitar resonance -suddenly a big thing these days.

Lots of TLDR today!

But I followed a maker called collings around trying to figure out how they got honduran mahogany so identical and resonsant, and then on top of that, the similar density still varies but their guitars don't. They get their wood from one spot at a specific elevation ($$ extra for them to pay) and then they came up with a novel way of cutting thin parallel spots in parts of the guitar body so that the musical note and resonance is the same for each guitar.