ahh, yes - I've had four of norton's trans
David Weaver
stones.... (some were translucent and labeled HTA, and some labeled "hard arkansas").
I've had perhaps four or five dan's stones that were trans (possibly more -I no longer have any, but they used to sell stones cheap on their specials page and I'd get one or two, then just sell them when I got bored and do it again).
Anything sold from dan's page is a finer stone. Nortons vary a bit.
Dan's stones sold outside of the dan's page can vary (sometimes resembling the seconds more than the firsts or if fairly inexpensive, they can have a coarser surface finish).
That said, comparing full price norton stones to full price dan's stones, every norton stone that I had was less fine initially and less fine terminally, but certainly plenty fine for use.
If I were spending $200, it would be on a stone from dan's instead of norton. I'm not picking winners here or trying to talk something down - I like Joel and his shop, this is just my experience with the two types.
The one other thing to consider is that these are superb lifetime stones (either dans or norton) and should be used and familiarized with, but they are different than anything modern sold to be used with a guide/flattened often and pulled. Arkansas stones reward touch and freehanding and sense to finish just the very tip of the tool, and sometimes to do work with heavier pressure.
I convinced a whole bunch of people to use arkansas stones on the razor forums. They would say things like "it takes 700 laps to do what my chosera does in 100 but the results is sublime". with synthetic stones, you work a razor with not much pressure on the finish, but with ark stones, you need a little pressure or you'll be there forever. I think those folks probably weren't as satisfied with their stones as they could've been.
If someone loves the way waterstones work, I'd say they're a candidate to also not be that satisfied with oilstones and $200 can be a lot of money for a paperweight.