Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

Posts

Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

#1

Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

Bruce McCrory

You guys singing the pleasures of Novaculite have me scratching my head. Maybe, I didn't have enough respect for Smith's, or the other names that fade from the supply chain?

Has anyone used one of Joel's (TFWW) "special" translucent white, hard Washita's from Norton?

It's a really costly choice, but I have only broken ones from my youth--I thought were too hard already--and one antique billy club from the 1800's. Said billy is about 2" square and over 8 inches long; well deformed.

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

#2

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washi

David Weaver

can you send a link? not familiar with the terminology and am assuming you may mean hard translucent.

Nortons hard translucent is decent, but dan's is better. Better finished from the start (smoother) and better (finer) terminal performance on average.

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

#3

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washi

Bruce McCrory

This is sold by Tools For Working Wood. Read the description for clarification.

https://toolsforworkingwood.com/store/item/NO-ARK-HB8

Aside: I have been getting malicious warnings from my free Kaspersky in the last couple days.

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

#4

Re: TFWW Hard Translucent Arkansas Stones

David Bassett

I think the confusion is you use Washita and White in your subject line, though you are asking about TFWW's fine Norton Arkansas stones. (Note TFWW doesn't use White nor Washita in the description you linked to. I don't recall Norton doing that, but their language has evolved over the ~two centuries they've mined these and I certainly haven't seen all their descriptions.)

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

#5

Rafael from PA

Hard Arkansas

Rafael from PA

The stone listed in the TFWW site is a stone graded as a hard Arkansas. As pointed out in the link you posted, they recommend a medium India to use along with this stone.

If you can get a hold of an actual Washita stone, you could use that single stone instead of the India and the hard Arkansas. Finish the edge tool with the strop.

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

#6

ahh, yes - I've had four of norton's trans

David Weaver

stones.... (some were translucent and labeled HTA, and some labeled "hard arkansas").

I've had perhaps four or five dan's stones that were trans (possibly more -I no longer have any, but they used to sell stones cheap on their specials page and I'd get one or two, then just sell them when I got bored and do it again).

Anything sold from dan's page is a finer stone. Nortons vary a bit.

Dan's stones sold outside of the dan's page can vary (sometimes resembling the seconds more than the firsts or if fairly inexpensive, they can have a coarser surface finish).

That said, comparing full price norton stones to full price dan's stones, every norton stone that I had was less fine initially and less fine terminally, but certainly plenty fine for use.

If I were spending $200, it would be on a stone from dan's instead of norton. I'm not picking winners here or trying to talk something down - I like Joel and his shop, this is just my experience with the two types.

The one other thing to consider is that these are superb lifetime stones (either dans or norton) and should be used and familiarized with, but they are different than anything modern sold to be used with a guide/flattened often and pulled. Arkansas stones reward touch and freehanding and sense to finish just the very tip of the tool, and sometimes to do work with heavier pressure.

I convinced a whole bunch of people to use arkansas stones on the razor forums. They would say things like "it takes 700 laps to do what my chosera does in 100 but the results is sublime". with synthetic stones, you work a razor with not much pressure on the finish, but with ark stones, you need a little pressure or you'll be there forever. I think those folks probably weren't as satisfied with their stones as they could've been.

If someone loves the way waterstones work, I'd say they're a candidate to also not be that satisfied with oilstones and $200 can be a lot of money for a paperweight.

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

#7

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washi

Joe Rogers, North Eastern West Virginia

At one time Joel had a supply of new Lilly White Washita Norton stones. Luckily I was able to get one. I also have an apprentice drop tested Norton translucent purchased in 1966-67. Joel also supplied a replacement for that sad event stone. I love the Lilly White. The replacement HB8 is not as fine as the 60s stone. I also can say that Dans Whetstones offer a premium product. I have several slip stones and they are awesome.

Joe

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

#8

Re: ahh, yes - I've had four of norton's trans

Bruce McCrory

Yup, I think the 'paperweight' grade may be my prognosis also. I went to water stones out of frustration with the oil stones.

If I get excited I can try to flatten a side on the big old stone. The others (pink, I think) still have enough size to be used with carving knives.

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

#9

Re: TFWW Hard Translucent Arkansas Stones

Bruce McCrory

For a moment I thought you were another member. He is Barnett, however, after checking his Opti-Visor article. We had a good chuckle about lenses we needed before he posted the article.

Yes, Norton is pretty oblique in its descriptions of natural stones. I was trying to describe the stone, as I see and read, after several articles and stock descriptions. I am not familiar with variable honing techniques.

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

#10

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washi

joel moskowitz

The new HB8's supplied by Norton are as fine as ever BUT need to be broken in first. The reason is that up until the 1980's or 90's Norton made the HB8's the old fashioned was by cutting the stones with wire and abrasive and then flattening them on a modified blanchard mill. They they switched to diamond saws and it's a lot easier to make the stones and prices when down for awhile, BUT the freshly sawn stones have sharp crystals and are coarser out of the box.

I bought my personal HB8 new in the mid 1980's and it is like glass. In the shop we use a longer stone. It started out coarser but except for the ends now is exactly the same amazing fineness like glass. The ends of the stone - which don't get used are still a little coarse - which comes in handy sometimes.

Norton rates it's stones via density and doesn't officially make a "translucent" stone. Currently BTW they are having trouble getting larger flawless stones out of their quarry and prices have gone up. Norton also sells another version of their HB8 - that is glued to a substrate. It's cheaper because the stone had a flaw on the glued side. HB8's are flawess (no cracks) on either side.

There is no industrial grading of "translucent" or "black" stones are rated via density and any name put on this is for marketing purposes. Periodically Norton has used these designations on stones at the request of dealers. Washita's (Lillywhites and others) are also grated by density, "Lillywhite" being a Norton trademark

Re: Tools for working Wood White Translucent Washita?

#11

Initial vs. terminal difference...

David Weaver

..in general, the webpage-front stones from dans are slightly more dense in translucent than norton's stones. I haven't bought vintage norton's trans, but that's more recent purchases - four or five - I'd have to count.

In black stones, newer nortons have some visible pores, and the separation between them and dans is bigger.

That's not to say that the nortons aren't a usable finish stone - of course they are. They just aren't quite as fine as the material that dan's mines.

I measured the stones that I had from norton and some of the translucent white stones were in the ballpark of 2.6. The dan's stones are mid to upper 2.6s, which is about the limit for a completely pore free stone. It sounds like a small difference, but it translates to the volume of the norton stone being about 2.5% more in air space vs. the dan's. At that point, they start to pass light less well (separate issue from the stones that don't pass light at all but don't have pores) at the same thickness and an a/b comparison between two similarly prepared stones (or similarly fine surface) will show the norton to be a little faster cutting and a little less fine.

I've sold the stones that I had that were around 2.6 - I just don't know what they're good for, because if you buy half a dozen vintage washitas and sell the four in the middle (keeping the coarsest and finest), the finest of the group will be more capable than a translucent stone that's on the bubble of being translucent and as fine in practical use. The trans stone won't have the speed to match the washita unless it's constantly abraded, and it won't do anything with light pressure whereas a washita will cut finely.

Before the internet, I doubt anyone would've noticed any patterns like this, because who would you talk to about it? Now, we can compare notes and collect data. There was a point where first quality dan's 8x2s were cheaper than norton, too, but that's no longer the case.