Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

Posts

RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

#1

RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

ken ca

I've owned a "harlequin" set of Irwin bits for Donkeys years, and I have a few Greenlee bits. But I've always lusted after a set of Russell Jennings bits as they are supposed to be superior in hardwoods. I recently gave in and purchased a boxed set off that over priced auction site we all love to hate. It was an older set with 14 bits, rather than the later 13 bit set (no idea WHEN that change occurred). I tested the #12 of all three in 3/4" red oak, selecting a Yankee 2101 bit brace from my overly large collection of braces and found that although the RJs were almost twice as slow in cutting through, the quality of cut was about equal between all 3.

Since all three were subjected to my sharpening skills, the results are somewhat dubious.

Ignore the RH hole and the obvious backside damage as I made no effort to cut the hole cleanly on the backside by reversing the board etc.


img

Re: RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

#2

Rafael from PA

Re: RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

Rafael from PA

I'm not an expert, but my understanding is that the thread size of the snail is what makes the bit best for hard or soft woods. The fine threaded ones are for hardwoods.

Re: RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

#3

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

RJ slowness a result of ? finer pitch lead screw? Moral of story all bits perform equally? Was the force required to auger through the oak less with the RJ's.

If one does not care how a hole is made the LV spur bits are devine. The bits are so sharp that blowing out the exit can be avoided with a slow feed at the end of the hole.

Re: RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

#4

A variety of augers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ken, I have used the Russell Jennings for years, and was lucky enough to purchase a boxed set a long time ago ..


These are great. I prefer them to the Irwins I also have, but it is a long time since I last used the Irwins and I have now forgotten why!

For those who do not know the difference ...


Of all the augers, the one I now most use are made by Woodowl in Japan. Chris Schwarz posted about these several years ago, which is how I discovered them. What is different is that they have three cutting edges ...


They have a hex shank. Unless you have a Bell-type chuck, you will need an adapter ...


Here is my tip when boring into hard wood: the lead screws are often mentioned as either “fine” or “coarse”, and too coarse can create difficulty in boring. Well, I discovered that hardwoods will triple any difficulty. The solution is to drill a pilot hole for the screw. This hole should not be larger than the screw. It is amazing how easily one can drill really hard woods .. or anything, for that matter.

Here I used a cordless drill into a very, very hard Jarrah bench leg (the wood here was ex-roof trusses, which had dried over decades in the West Australian sun) ...


... followed by a 3/4” Woodowl auger bit ...



The other type of Woodowl bits I use are for the drill press. These do not have screws ...

At the front ...


Used for boring the mortices in a few stools I am making ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

#5

Re: RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

ken ca

Yes, my understanding too, except that the coarse snail Irwin and Greenlee cut just as clean a hole but at twice the pace!

Re: RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

#6

Re: question

ken ca

I believe it's the fine pitch that does it, but no I didn't feel any great difference in the effort required, although it stands to reason that there would be as you are removing less wood each turn of the brace.

Re: RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

#7

Re: A variety of augers

ken ca

Nice tools as usual Derek, do you know when RJ went to 14 bits/box to 13 bits/box? I know mine are quite old, predating Stanley, but would like to know when they stopped including the #3 bit.

Re: RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

#8

Re: A variety of augers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ken, George's Basement is where you are likely to find the answers. I do not know, as I am not a student of their history.

When I Googled, this is what came up :)

https://www.georgesbasement.com/braces/RussellJennings/RussellJenningsAugerBits.htm

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

#9

Re: RJ vs Irwin vs Greenlee auger bits

Pat Riley

I would suggest trying the same test with 2" to 3" stock. It might be more telling.